News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by aviv on Saturday May 19, 2018 @08:40PM (#17110531)
Acids and large protein consumption. Meat, wheat, dairy. Toxic to the human body. It's really quite simple. You eat death, you get death.
Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by coldtea on Saturday May 19, 2018 @08:47PM (#17110550)
>Acids and large protein consumption. Meat, wheat, dairy. Toxic to the human body. It's really quite simple. You eat death, you get death.

Whereas vegans don't die?

Also "toxic to the human body" is just bad dietary advice.

Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by wolco on Saturday May 19, 2018 @10:48PM (#17110904)
Breaking down wheat and dairy is difficult and breaks down into toxic elements. For thise who cannot remove the waste it becomes toxic.

Meat can be extremely healthy but some types are rich in oils that can't break down easy. Bacon vs lean pork

Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by trentlott on Saturday May 19, 2018 @11:37PM (#17111061)
Carbs are the easiest thing to break down and digest.

Pure glucose would be ideal, from a 'breakdown' perspective.

Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by aviv on Saturday May 19, 2018 @08:56PM (#17110577)
Fast food vegans sure do die. And if you believe that nothing you can eat can be toxic to your body, you already lost in life.
Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by DmenshunlAnlsis on Saturday May 19, 2018 @10:14PM (#17110804)
Everything you metabolize both keeps you alive, and harms you. Like fruit? Well, pectin isn’t very good you in the long run. Metabolic activity is messy, produces toxins we need to Eli inste through urine and feces, and that’s that. We’re all dying, and no fantasy of a special diet can change that. While some diets are better for you than others, it’s not as laughably clear cut as “eating death” or whatever nonsense.

The very act of living produces toxins, period.

Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by throwaway5752 on Saturday May 19, 2018 @10:29PM (#17110850)
Wait. Please elaborate on how pectin isn't good for you.
Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by DmenshunlAnlsis on Saturday May 19, 2018 @10:45PM (#17110900)
Oxidation of pectin produces a small quantity of formaldehyde as a metabolite. I’m not suggesting that you shouldn’t eat fruit or jams by the way, it’s just an example of how something considered broadly healthy still produces toxins that require elimination. Metabolism by its very nature produces energy and “exhaust” in the form of heat and metabolites. To be clear, you’re getting a lot more methanol metabolism from a drink of alcohol than an apple, so eat the fruit. No matter what we do we’re. It living forever based on diet, we should just try to avoid too much excess and accept that living isn’t a thermodynamically favorable process.
Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by throwaway5752 on Sunday May 20, 2018 @12:03AM (#17111145)
... So, "The benefits of eating fresh fruits infinitely outweighs the negatives of pectin. Even pure pectin probably is a net benefit because it slows sugar digestion and lowers cholesterol absorption vs the small amount of formaldehyde produced as a metabolic byproduct." ... would that be a more better way of describing pectin than what you said earlier?
Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by trentlott on Saturday May 19, 2018 @11:39PM (#17111065)
Formaldehyde is such a small molecule that you'll never avoid it. It forms pretty easily.
Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by cimmanom on Sunday May 20, 2018 @07:04AM (#17112218)
Molecule size isn't what determines how easily a molecule forms.
Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by coldtea on Sunday May 20, 2018 @07:35AM (#17112300)
>Fast food vegans sure do die.

As opposed to proper vegans, who live forever?

>And if you believe that nothing you can eat can be toxic to your body, you already lost in life.

Plenty can be toxic, including all kinds of plants (heroin is made from a plant). But the best diets according to longevity statistics and scientific studies still include meat, e.g. the Mediterranean diet.

Or you can ignore those, and opt for some semi-mystical, culting fad diet.

Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by chiefalchemist on Sunday May 20, 2018 @07:02PM (#17115205)
Afaik, the best diets for longevity are based on calorie reduction. For some reason that doesn't compromise the immune system, and a stronger immune sys leads to a layer death.

Again, afaik.

Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by aviv on Sunday May 20, 2018 @07:44PM (#17115338)
Exactly, and to that point, many many "diseases" can be cured with a prolonged water fast (10-40 days, depending on severity, and obviously closely monitoring vitals throughout the process). It's incredibly unfortunate that not more people have access to this very simple guidance. Diabetes (yes, some type 1s included), Crohn's, Colitis, arthritis, the list is as long as the number of downvotes I get every time I share this.
Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by aviv on Sunday May 20, 2018 @12:42PM (#17113582)
It's funny how in these type of threads people like to play dumb.

Obviously no one is saying vegans live forever. It's not what this is about. Even if we all die eventually, why not have the best quality if life possible and have as few health problems possible, if any at all?

Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by coldtea on Sunday May 20, 2018 @04:13PM (#17114536)
>Even if we all die eventually, why not have the best quality if life possible and have as few health problems possible, if any at all?

That's not what's disputed here though. That a vegan diet is the best way to achieve that, is.

Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by aviv on Sunday May 20, 2018 @04:44PM (#17114641)
There is no such single concept as a vegan diet. Drinking coca cola is vegan. "Vegans" can have a diet worse than those who simply consume animal products. I did not say the answer is a vegan diet, commenters here kind of assumed it.
Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by coldtea on Sunday May 20, 2018 @07:35PM (#17115309)
>There is no such single concept as a vegan diet.

Well, you now get all subtle on us, whereas a few comments before you summed consuming meat as "eat death, get death".

Turns out there's not a single concept as a "non vegan diet" either. It doesn't mean one gorges on huge steaks all day, or one doesn't have a perfectly healthy and balanced diet.

Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by jrace on Saturday May 19, 2018 @10:04PM (#17110774)
All vegans die, all things can be toxic to the human body, water and even air.

Plants and vegetables were "alive" in some capacity before they were torn from their natural habit, violently macerated and forced into a highly acidic stomach to be digested over a period of hours.

Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by aviv on Sunday May 20, 2018 @01:00PM (#17113685)
Fruits are given to you by nature, no one takes them violently (unless picked unripe, which is a problem on its own in this country). Also unlike dead flesh, they take at most 30ish minutes to digest, not hours where they go rancid in your body like most other foods.
Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by coldtea on Sunday May 20, 2018 @04:15PM (#17114545)
>Fruits are given to you by nature, no one takes them violently

You'd be surprised: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banana_republic

>Also unlike dead flesh

This has a tone of religious indignation in it. You do know that it's not only perfectly natural, but that there are species that have evolved evolutionary to eat meat, the ones we call carnivores, right?

Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by aviv on Sunday May 20, 2018 @05:27PM (#17114827)
Again you resort to extremes to justify your (likely) unhealthy lifestyle and make a point that really contributes nothing to the conversation.

And then, what is your second point there? Are you a carnivore?

Why is "dead flesh" triggering you so much? Are you ripping into live animals in the wild and swallowing them whole? I'm giving you the benefit of the doubt, I would love to meet the first lion using HN.

Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by coldtea on Sunday May 20, 2018 @07:56PM (#17115376)
>And then, what is your second point there? Are you a carnivore?

No, but I'm an omnivore, and belong to a species that has been known to be eating meat all throughout its evolutionary history [1], and throughout all its 4+ millennia of actual civilization and history, all around the world. So, there's that.

>Why is "dead flesh" triggering you so much?

Don't confuse someone objecting to morally loaded language like "dead flesh" with being "triggered".

In fact, don't use cheap parlor tricks like "why are you triggered" to shift the discussion from arguments to sentiments and ad hominem.

>Are you ripping into live animals in the wild and swallowing them whole?

If live oysters qualify, then yes.

But usually we don't call what we eat "dead flesh", in the same way we don't say we eat "ground wheat" when we eat bread or pasta. we eat steaks and meatballs and so on. We also don't eat just the flesh. We also eat the skin -- and some of us, we enjoy the bone marrow too.

So your phrasing is just a cheap (and insulting to our intelligence) trick to impose a sentimental undertone to the discussion. Which is part of the reason you have been downvoted to grayness.

Plus, fruits and plants are still alive when you eat them (their cells are still working fine) -- so, are you eating them alive? You monster!

[1] https://www.americanscientist.org/article/meat-eating-among-...

Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by emmelaich on Saturday May 19, 2018 @10:43PM (#17110891)
There's a few cases of people going all-meat -- apparently successfully fixing autoimmune and inflammation.
Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by robbiep on Saturday May 19, 2018 @08:43PM (#17110544)
None of us are getting out alive. Sprouting pseudo science isn’t going to keep you here any longer
Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by aviv on Saturday May 19, 2018 @09:12PM (#17110615)
Also, don't forget to drive without a seatbelt, never get any exercise, don't brush your teeth, and don't have a fire extinguisher. Because, you know, anyway none of us are getting out alive.
Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by nso95 on Saturday May 19, 2018 @09:27PM (#17110648)
Except exercise and seatbelts aren’t pseudoscience
Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by throwaway5752 on Saturday May 19, 2018 @10:29PM (#17110847)
With all due respect, there is science on plant based diets and caloric restriction being correlated with increased longevity.

Vegans still die, non-vegans can still outlive them, anyone can get hit by a bus, etc.

Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by toasterlovin on Saturday May 19, 2018 @11:18PM (#17110989)
Let’s just get this out there: there is no long term randomized controlled trial that has ever been conducted which is capable of proving that one diet is better than other diets.

Period.

Nutrition science is a joke. It’s basically all short term studies which tell you nothing about long term effects of diet, or it’s long term epidemiological studies which are fundamentally incapable of controlling for confounding variables.

Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by DenisM on Saturday May 19, 2018 @11:33PM (#17111049)
I heard it that the Mediterranean diet is the most studied of them all, and it seems [1] that all studies are within 5 years of length.

So yeah. No long-term studies. It's not even clear if we have hope for such. The military could summon the discipline, but soldiers do retire early. Maybe the officers, I don't know.

[1] https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/5-studies-on-the-medite...

Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by toasterlovin on Saturday May 19, 2018 @11:44PM (#17111086)
It’s crazy because diet is probably the most important thing we could study right now. Surely the astronomical cost of a randomized controlled study would be way less than the healthcare costs associated with not understanding what diets are healthy.
Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by aviv on Monday May 21, 2018 @02:43PM (#17120682)
It's not a high priority because the correct diet (raw fruits and some veggies) will lead to a huge reduction in so-called "auto-immune diseases", diabetes, cancers, all IBS related, etc. Big Pharma and all others involved in the machine called modern medicine will suffer financially.
Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by chiefalchemist on Sunday May 20, 2018 @07:12PM (#17115229)
Yes. But I think if you step back it makes (evolutionary) sense that genetics and diet are tied. That is, diet for one gene profile might not be idea for another gene profile.

That, to me, makes sense.

If that's the case, what is the ideal diet for genetic "hybrids"? Does mixing gene pools __and__ diets lead to more disease?

Modern First World dietary habits are driven by want, not needs. Does this confuse (?) the body and lead to more disease?

If evolution is about survival, and health is tied to survival, it's not as crazy as it sounds.

Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by toasterlovin on Monday May 21, 2018 @09:59AM (#17118391)
I’m not at all saying that there isn’t a diet that works best for most people most of the time. I, personally, believe that this is the case. But there is simply no conclusive evidence in favor of any given person’s favorite diet being that diet. And the inconclusive evidence that does exist is much weaker than most people seem to think that it is.
Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by robbiep on Sunday May 20, 2018 @11:30PM (#17115963)
It might make sense to you, but there is as yet no evidence for any of this, except more broad statements such as 'eating enormous bulk calories every day will probably kill you faster than not doing so'.

What are you saying/meaning by disease? Cancer is tied to length of life, and to a small degree, diet (bowel ca) and other modifiable risk factors (ie fat people have higher rates of cancer due to increased numbers of cells... which is interesting because most data says we don't produce new cells for fat, the fat cells just get bigger. So there is a mismatch there that isn't entirely explained by the data i've seen)

Osteoarthritis is clearly linked to weight, so people put their knees/hips/backs out at higher rates.

lack of exercise/modern lifestyle again ties in with the sports injuries.

On everything else, I challenge you to Prove that there is actually more disease. More disease of what? We have reduced or eliminated huge volumes of disease through vaccination and other preventable health. The other stuff is life/longevity linked, or reduced activity linked (ie T2DM/Metabolic Syndrome).

It is a very modern and pseudoscientific concern to be trying to link all this to diet. Yes, you should probably try and eat fresh stuff more than processed stuff. Yes your life should include an exercise regime. But your body is pretty good at breaking down macronutrients into micronutrients, and even though some of those micronutrients can function as drugs, there is not enough evidence to say anything too exciting here

Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by throwaway5752 on Sunday May 20, 2018 @12:11AM (#17111166)
That is an awfully strong statement. Do you have qualifications to dismissed the entire field, or is more of an opinion? And even though it's not up to your (admittedly best case) standard, don't population studies, twin studies, et al have some value. It seems it would be effectively impossible to research anything at all about nutrition otherwise.
Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by em500 on Sunday May 20, 2018 @07:17AM (#17112251)
As a professional statistician I support the statement that most nutrition studies suffer from grave methodological problems. See https://www.vox.com/2016/1/14/10760622/nutrition-science-com... for a good layman writeup.
Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by toasterlovin on Sunday May 20, 2018 @12:13PM (#17113420)
Overall a good write up, but that they end with a consensus statement by nutrition researchers after explaining why no nutrition research is really capable of telling us anything is just about the perfect encapsulation of what is wrong with nutrition research and reporting on the subject.
Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by toasterlovin on Sunday May 20, 2018 @12:51AM (#17111290)
Show me your favorite nutritional study and I’ll be happy to explain why it can’t actually tell us anything about the long term effects of diet on health.
Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by nso95 on Sunday May 20, 2018 @07:04AM (#17112221)
Which is very different from drinking baking soda
Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by shorttime on Saturday May 19, 2018 @09:42PM (#17110707)
Acids? Like stronger acids than the stomach acid already inside of the human body? I doubt that considering stomach acid damages teeth. Nobody would have teeth left.

Large protein consumption? Like what many many people do for health reasons, keto, body builders, etc? People in prime health condition?

And what about fructose malabsorption with certain fruits and vegatables? Some people can't eat certain things otherwise it will make them sick due to this illness.

Go back to reddit with your pseudo science trolling. HN is one of the few decent spots on the internet for discussions and it certainly isn't improved by people like you.

Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by PerfectElement on Saturday May 19, 2018 @09:40PM (#17110696)
There are many good rational arguments in favor of veganism. "You eat death, you get death" is not one of them.
Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by toasterlovin on Saturday May 19, 2018 @11:23PM (#17111004)
Not sure if you’re aware of this, but dairy has been a fundamental part of European diets for thousands of years. Plenty of Europeans live to old age.
Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by perfmode on Saturday May 19, 2018 @08:42PM (#17110541)
Plants are death too no?
Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by aviv on Saturday May 19, 2018 @09:04PM (#17110596)
If you think a melon or celery represent death more than a piece of steak sliced out of a dirty, diseased cow full of nasty man made food, hormones and "medications".. then you are quite far gone. Hopefully you will see the light before the illnesses kick in for you.
Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by jrace on Saturday May 19, 2018 @10:02PM (#17110765)
Have you stopped to think about what "feeds" the plants and vegetables?

There is a whole lot of "death" in the dirt.

Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by a_t48 on Saturday May 19, 2018 @09:24PM (#17110642)
I hope you remember to sanitize your keyboard daily. :)
Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by aviv on Saturday May 19, 2018 @09:29PM (#17110652)
I'm not sure I understand your point - are you comparing the cleanliness of my keyboard to the horrible living conditions of a typical cow? I highly doubt the keys on my keyboard have manure on them.
Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by matte_black on Saturday May 19, 2018 @09:42PM (#17110704)
You’d be surprised. If you’ve ever taken a dump and then returned to your keyboard right after without taking a shower then fecal matter has almost certainly found its way to your keyboard. Fecal flakes proliferate through the air when you take a shit. The stronger the smell, the more flakes there are. They stick to your body and clothes, and then inevitably smeared on your keyboard.
Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by nate_meurer on Sunday May 20, 2018 @10:40AM (#17112885)
Excellent. Multiply by 10 if you have dogs.
Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by aviv on Sunday May 20, 2018 @11:24AM (#17113135)
In an effort to make a smart witty comment you completely missed my point. I said my keyboard doesn't have manure on it, not any kind of fecal matter.
Re:Evidence that drinking baking soda can promote an anti-in... by a_t48 on Saturday May 19, 2018 @11:55PM (#17111117)
For that matter - you don’t keep your toothbrush in your bathroom do you?