News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Power Posing: Fake It Until You Make It by lsc on Monday September 20, 2010 @05:37PM (#1710588)
The problem is that most managers seem to prefer to hire and work with people who have high levels of confidence. Why is this? Personally, I have no idea. All other things being equal, I prefer hiring people with lower apparent levels of confidence. Aside from, in my opinion, simply being more pleasant and easier to get along with day to day, they tend to stick around longer at any given salary level. Confidence commands quite a bit of a pay increase in nearly all job roles, and in the roles I hire for, confidence doesn't really help you do the job, so people with less apparent confidence are quite often bargains.

Besides, I'm pretty good at faking confidence, so in the rare instances where that skill is demanded, I can just do it myself.

Re:Power Posing: Fake It Until You Make It by philwelch on Monday September 20, 2010 @06:40PM (#1710755)
There's no tactful way to say this, so I'll just say it directly: what you're saying isn't very far from "I only hire people who aren't confident and assertive enough to demand the salary that they're worth". It might not be that bad (you might be afraid that a prospective employee who was more confident than you would negotiate out of you a higher salary than he was worth) but it's an ethical hazard to think in that way.
Re:Power Posing: Fake It Until You Make It by lsc on Monday September 20, 2010 @08:23PM (#1710990)
Yeah, you could put it that way. Personally, I prefer "I can't pay very much, so people who think they can earn more go elsewhere" I mean, hell, I'm only paying myself about $30K a year, and I'm located in Silicon Valley. You can get new people for that, but you can't keep experienced folks for that kind of money. Not here. I'm very conscious of perceived fairness, and try to pay people accordingly, so I'm not worried about a confident employee negotiating a higher that warranted salary. I mean, I acknowledge that they are worth more, and I'm not offended when they shop around their resume... but my budget is what it is.

I also tend to go for inexperienced people for the same reason. Do you think that's unethical?

I mean, I've told everyone who has worked for me that I will expect them to leave for more money at some point (unless my business grows fast enough to suddenly pay everyone 'experienced person' rates... but so far the experience of people who worked for me has grown quite a bit faster than my company's ability to pay, so people leave, and I give good recommendations.)

You are right that you should try to ignore attributes that are not relevant to the job at hand (including, in this case, confidence) and my own personal prejudices in the matter, I agree, make me look like an asshole who doesn't like dealing with other assholes (which, to be fair, I am.)

Re:Power Posing: Fake It Until You Make It by philwelch on Monday September 20, 2010 @09:05PM (#1711081)
If you're completely upfront about that situation it sounds pretty good--to the point where I wouldn't mind working for you myself to gain experience. I suspect a confident person will, worst case, just tell you they're not interested from the outset. Not hiring confident people implies that you're less than upfront about the situation (edit: absent the other explanation you've given--right now I don't find that ethically questionable at all anymore).
Re:Power Posing: Fake It Until You Make It by lsc on Monday September 20, 2010 @09:35PM (#1711141)
Most of the people I've hired in the last five years have known oneanother socially before they worked for me, so if the first guy had a bad experience, it's likely that nobody else would have touched me.
Re:Power Posing: Fake It Until You Make It by donw on Tuesday September 21, 2010 @01:30AM (#1711579)
As long as you're willing to train people up, this sounds like a great way of doing business. You get cheaper employees, with the trade-off of having to educate them (which costs time), and they get both useful skills and a reference (in exchange for taking a much lower rate of pay).

Definitely not a zero-sum game. :)

Re:Power Posing: Fake It Until You Make It by lsc on Tuesday September 21, 2010 @06:50AM (#1712096)
Yeah, that's the idea.

It is the only way to hire customer support people. people who have worked phone or email tech support at other companies are extremely difficult to train into any sort of a customer facing role. I mean, sometimes they will make fine SysAdmins or Programmers, but working phone support usually kills off that which is required to deal with customers like human beings, especially in introverts, and, well, most qualified SysAdmins and Programmers are introverts.

as for other roles, it has it's ups and downs. On the upside, you get things done your way. On the downside? well, if your way isn't the best way, well, in the worst case you think your way is the best way and you keep doing it until it ends badly. In the best case, you know your way isn't any good and you hire an expert for consultation. There are many projects where I look back and say "It would have been cheaper if I just paid someone who knew what they were doing $100/hr to come in and just make it work for us." but obviously, I keep doing it, so I think, overall, the approach works for me.

Re:Power Posing: Fake It Until You Make It by donw on Monday September 20, 2010 @06:40PM (#1710754)
They can be, although in my experience, you can't put low-confidence people in roles that require a lot of self-direction. Low-confidence people are less likely to branch out and learn new techniques, as they prefer to play it safe with what they already know.

I've had problems before with a programmer who was terrified to do testing, because he didn't have the confidence that he could learn something new. He was otherwise a bright guy, but his lack of confidence severely hurt both himself, the team, and the company.

Re:Power Posing: Fake It Until You Make It by lsc on Monday September 20, 2010 @08:34PM (#1711012)
Eh, I think it just requires a different management style. You need to be much lighter on the stick with someone who is less confident, and to use verbal praise as the carrot (along with periodic raises) The easy mistake is to blow up when something bad happens. Generally speaking, people who seem to lack confidence have a difficult time dealing with that sort of thing, so you see them becoming risk-averse in ways that are damaging to the company. But, if you can avoid blowing up, my experience has been that they can take reasonable risks as well as anyone else.

Confident people, I think, usually require a more confrontational management style. Sometimes you /need/ to blow up to get them to do what the company needs rather than what they want to do (which is something I'm not particularly good at)

Re:Power Posing: Fake It Until You Make It by donw on Tuesday September 21, 2010 @01:27AM (#1711573)
I can honestly say that I have never needed to 'blow up' at one of my employees. Ever.

If I had an employee that was totally unwilling to listen to direction, they would be an ex-employee very quickly. I'm not a dictator or a micromanager -- I do my best to hire smart people and let them do their jobs. But sometimes, someone needs to take charge and make a decision.

If someone's ego can't cope with that, they are bad for the business, and need to go.

If you have to bite someone's head off to get them to do their job, that's not confidence -- that's arrogance. Two very different things.

Re:Power Posing: Fake It Until You Make It by lsc on Tuesday September 21, 2010 @01:32AM (#1711584)
I've never gotten a clear explanation of the difference between confidence and arrogance, I mean, except as just a matter of degree. People tell me "well, that explains a lot about you" which, I'm sure, it does. but nobody seems to have an answer to the question that makes even a little sense.

As for "blowing up" what I mean is that you need to adjust the, ah "volume" or "intensity" of your feelings upwards, vs. managing a person who isn't very confident, in which case you want to seem very low key, especially when the shit hits the proverbial fan; as I was mentioning in a previous post, if your emotions seem too intense when there is a failure, you can inadvertently train your less-confident people to avoid risk more than you like.

I'm trying to say that more confident people will often ignore the less intense criticisms. they are more likely to assume everything is OK unless you make it very clear that it is not. If you try to be low key about it, a more confident person generally gets quite irritated, calling you "passive aggressive" (even if you are direct in a soft voice... it is the soft voice or soft framing, I think, that they find irritating.) and, well, getting quite irritated. My experience has been that an error on the side of too much emotional force usually has better results than an error on the side of not enough emotional force with the more confident sort of person.

The interesting thing, I think, is that you can almost say the exact same words to the two groups of people. Being direct is almost always a good thing. But with the two different groups, you need to frame it and communicate it very differently. Having an appropriate amount of emotional force behind your words is key, and that appropriate amount of emotional force varies quite a lot depending on what sort of person you are attempting to communicate with.

I'm approaching this problem from the perspective of someone who is naturally not all that aggressive, who has learned how to fake it, to some extent.

(and yeah, to tie this back to the article, one of the things I taught myself was to sit in a very relaxed and expansive way that takes up a lot of space. I got the idea because I read a lot of feminist literature as a youth, and that is one of the behaviours a particular author found irritating in men. "wow," I thought "I sit like a woman." because yeah, I tended to sit very compactly, to take up little space. So as I got older and tried to fake this confidence, I started to sit more, uh, expansively. To consciously take up more space than I needed to. It feels pretty natural now. The really funny thing about this is that other people are aware of it too. try putting your feet up on the table or otherwise visibly relax and take up more space while talking with a male who is of greater status. You will often notice them doing the same thing, sometimes to a ridiculous extent.)

so yeah, you are probably better at modulating your emotional force on the top end than I am, just 'cause that's not my natural state- that is something I learned. But my experience has been that even overdoing the emotional force by quite a bit usually results in more positive outcomes, when dealing with a confident person, than underdoing the emotional force, and looking like a wimp.

Really, though, I think the key to this emotional confidence is having that willingness to experiment, and to screw up. I have yelled at people (and yeah, it's almost always the wrong thing to do.) I've made people cry without really meaning to. I mean, it's not something I regularly do, and it's something I'll try not to do again, but for me it was part of this learning process.

Re:Power Posing: Fake It Until You Make It by donw on Tuesday September 21, 2010 @01:37AM (#1711593)
Have to reply here, since there's a limit to nesting depth.

To me, confidence stems from knowledge and experience. A confident person can back up their assertions to a very deep level. They can explain and defend their reasoning. With this also comes the experience that the world isn't perfect, and that sometimes you just need to do something you don't want to do.

Arrogance, on the other hand, is nothing but ego and fear. Fear that anything that might threaten that huge ego. An arrogant man has little knowledge or wisdom, but plenty of bullshit to masquerade as such.

A confident man can lose well. An arrogant man can't.

Re:Power Posing: Fake It Until You Make It by lsc on Tuesday September 21, 2010 @02:04AM (#1711648)
>To me, confidence stems from knowledge and experience.

To me, this entire continuum from not confident, to confident to arrogant has to do with how you act when you encounter a new situation, or some other unknown, well, and how you act around other people in a social situation. Re-reading my posts, this is obviously most of what I'm talking about.

The guy I think of as the least confident guy I know is an absolutely awesome c++ programmer. Incredible. The man holds himself like he thinks you are about to punch him. He looks a good four inches shorter than he really is because of his posture. He speaks with such a soft voice that he's usually got to repeat himself several times when he orders food. In any sort of social situation, he looks pretty uncomfortable.

But if you talk about C++? He'll look you in the eye and say "I don't write segmentation faults" or "My code has no buffer overflows." and he believes it, too. (hell, after working with him, I believe it.) - but to me, that doesn't seem like confidence. that's just experience, and being obviously very, very good at something.

>A confident man can lose well. An arrogant man can't.

Logically, I don't think that is the whole story, but emotionally, I really like that definition.

Re:Power Posing: Fake It Until You Make It by Psyonic on Wednesday September 22, 2010 @02:39AM (#1715384)
I think thats precisely what confidence is. He makes statements that would be arrogant coming from someone less experienced, but since he can back it up, its confidence.
Re:Power Posing: Fake It Until You Make It by tome on Tuesday September 21, 2010 @06:04AM (#1712030)
> Have to reply here, since there's a limit to nesting depth.

Not as far as I know, and if there is, a depth of 4 or 5 isn't it!

Sometimes the "reply" link doesn't appear and you have to reply via the permalink "link" instead.