News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Congress wants to extend the copyright on some sound reco... by rayiner on Friday May 18, 2018 @11:33AM (#17102275)
Copyright is about the least artificial monopoly that exists. An artificial monopoly is the government sending men with guns to keep bigger stronger men than me off my land. It's a chunk of dirt that existed millions of years before I was born and will continue to exist millions of years after I'm dead, but the government allows me to call it "mine." That's as artificial as it gets, but we call it "natural rights."

A monopoly on creative works--something that didn't exist before the person who created it--is far less artificial. (And granting a monopoly on something that's non-rival, so everyone can have as much of it as they want so long as they're willing to create their own, seems far better than granting one on a scarce natural resource.)

Re:Congress wants to extend the copyright on some sound reco... by barrkel on Friday May 18, 2018 @11:45AM (#17102379)
I don't accept that for a moment. Monopoly over land predates humans, as any observation of territorial creatures will let you know.
Re:Congress wants to extend the copyright on some sound reco... by harryh on Friday May 18, 2018 @09:58PM (#17106219)
Animals might have monopoly over land that they are physically standing on and protecting right this very second. But they have no concept of property: land in some other place far away from them that somehow remains theirs even if they aren't there or never intend to go there. That sort of property is solely a creation of the modern state.
Re:Congress wants to extend the copyright on some sound reco... by rayiner on Friday May 18, 2018 @11:50AM (#17102409)
Territorial creatures have possession, not property, which is completely different. Bashing someone's head in and taking their property is natural right. Having the State send men with guns in response to that action is a highly artificial deprivation of that natural right.
Re:Congress wants to extend the copyright on some sound reco... by mijamo on Friday May 18, 2018 @12:16PM (#17102615)
I think you should read about natural rights. The traditional natural righta are life, liberty, and property, which is the opposite of what you describe. And natural rights only exist in an organized society, they are just the limits of what a human should give in its social contract with the society.
Re:Congress wants to extend the copyright on some sound reco... by icebraining on Friday May 18, 2018 @01:42PM (#17103367)
I'm pretty sure rayiner knows what the concept is, he's criticizing it for misusing the term "natural" and he's replacing it for something that is actually natural.

Besides, current property is quite far from the Lockean concept of mixing your own labor and only taking it when "there is enough, and as good, left in common for others", which the original "natural right of property".

Re:Congress wants to extend the copyright on some sound reco... by mywittyname on Friday May 18, 2018 @05:30PM (#17105105)
> Having the State send men with guns in response to that action is a highly artificial deprivation of that natural right.

Pack animals will do the same. If you attempt to take their property, the leader (State) will likely engage with you.

Re:Congress wants to extend the copyright on some sound reco... by thomastjeffery on Friday May 18, 2018 @11:46AM (#17102383)
One is a monopoly on a physical object, the other is a monopoly on an idea.

Ideas are far more abstract.

Re:Congress wants to extend the copyright on some sound reco... by rayiner on Friday May 18, 2018 @05:53PM (#17105258)
Copyright is a monopoly on a specific creative work, not an idea. It’s intangible but it’s not an idea (Microsoft Windows for example, isn’t an “idea”). It’s a product of labor, just like a house you built.
Re:Congress wants to extend the copyright on some sound reco... by dctoedt on Sunday May 20, 2018 @05:01PM (#17114702)
> Copyright is a monopoly on a specific creative work, not an idea.

But courts — urged on by copyright owners — have extended the scope of copyright protection to nonliteral aspects such as (for example) look and feel and structure, sequence, and organization. Sometimes this is done while paying lip service to the principle that copyright doesn't protect ideas. The resulting fuzziness of the boundaries is one of the major sources of complaint.

Re:Congress wants to extend the copyright on some sound reco... by thomastjeffery on Saturday May 19, 2018 @05:38AM (#17107232)
That intangibility is what I am trying to get at: If someone builds an exact copy of your house across the street, you don't lose anything. The idea that you should be allowed to prevent them from doing so is copyright.
Re:Congress wants to extend the copyright on some sound reco... by gnode on Friday May 18, 2018 @12:01PM (#17102492)
I don't think it's sensible to refer to all ownership of land as monopolistic. In most cases land is fungible. There are many landowners in my town of plots of land which are largely interchangeable. Saying someone has a monopoly on their specific plot of land is about as relevant as saying someone has a monopoly on a specific cheeseburger. If one party were to own all the land in a particular region, like a feudal lord, that may be considered monopolistic.

The case with copyright is that copyrighted works are by definition not fungible; if you create a trivially similar work, you violate the copyright.

Re:Congress wants to extend the copyright on some sound reco... by rayiner on Friday May 18, 2018 @05:54PM (#17105265)
You don’t violate copyright by creating a “trivially similar” work. Maybe if you start with someone else’s work and make only trivial modifications.
Re:Congress wants to extend the copyright on some sound reco... by ModernMech on Friday May 18, 2018 @12:59PM (#17103008)
> In most cases land is fungible.

Err, there's a reason the first three rules of real estate are 1. location 2. location 3. location

The key thing about land is that it's unique, there is no other place on the entire planet identical to the place you're standing. There may be similar places, and that may be fine enough for some people. But plenty of wars have been fought over a particular piece of land. Just ask the Palestinians if land is fungible.

Re:Congress wants to extend the copyright on some sound reco... by chimeracoder on Friday May 18, 2018 @05:15PM (#17105009)
> Just ask the Palestinians if land is fungible.

That analogy would only make sense if Palestinians were being offered similarly-sized and similarly-resourced land, to compensate for what was taken away from them at the beginning of the Nakba 70 years ago.

Except, they're not. The land was seized, with no new land provided in return. Over time, more and more has been occupied and taken away from Palestine.

Re:Congress wants to extend the copyright on some sound reco... by gnode on Friday May 18, 2018 @03:33PM (#17104308)
I was referring to a local basis. I.e. in most cases, plots of land of equal size on a given street are of similar value for similar purposes. My point is that people don't typically monopolise land to the extent that a prospective land buyer has one potential current owner they could deal with. Of course there are always exceptional cases where this breaks down.
Re:Congress wants to extend the copyright on some sound reco... by Dylan16807 on Friday May 18, 2018 @03:53PM (#17104468)
Are the Palestinians being offered similar land? That fight seems pretty all or nothing.

But more importantly, very few bits of land are all that special. Location, location, location means that if a business got its pick of nearby plots, most would happily switch, and reap the benefits!

Re:Congress wants to extend the copyright on some sound reco... by Strang on Friday May 18, 2018 @11:49AM (#17102401)
That's a very unconventional view. I'd argue that as presented it is based on an over-simplification of copyright. Specifically, "something that didn't exist before the person who created it" and "everyone can have as much of it as they want so long as they're willing to create their own" do not seem to accurately describe copyright law to me.
Re:Congress wants to extend the copyright on some sound reco... by rayiner on Friday May 18, 2018 @11:54AM (#17102438)
I don't think it's unconventional. Almost nobody outside certain circles cares about the "public domain." It's a romantic idea that has little relevance.

And why do you think that description of copyright law is inaccurate? Copyright protects concrete expression, not abstract ideas, and independent creation is a defense to copyright infringement. How many sci-fi books are basically identical and rehash the same tropes? That's not copyright infringement. It's only infringement if you actually copy someone else's work.

Re:Congress wants to extend the copyright on some sound reco... by gnode on Friday May 18, 2018 @12:12PM (#17102584)
> It's only infringement if you actually copy someone else's work.

This is inaccurate. Copyright has been extended to cover fictional characters for instance.

Consider that at the copyright term of 144 years proposed, the character of Count Dracula would still be under copyright, and not freely usable for artistic works.

Re:Congress wants to extend the copyright on some sound reco... by wahern on Friday May 18, 2018 @01:57PM (#17103506)
Unlike patent law which protects novelty, copyright only protects originality. Violating copyright requires actual copying of material.

Theoretically, you could independently conceive of Count Dracula[1] and put him into your own work without violating someone else's copyright. To prove violation of copyright the copyright holder must as a preliminary matter provide evidence that the defendant likely had access or exposure to the copyrighted material. Only once that evidence exists could the fact finder infer, based on similarity, actual copying. For widely disseminated pop cultural material, however, exposure is a rather easy burden to meet.

[1] I presume for the sake of argument that the character Count Dracula is per se copyrighted. But I don't think that's true. AFAIU only certain stylized versions of that character are copyrighted. This necessarily follows from the fact that to show violation of copyright you must first identify the specific material that has been copied, and then show substantive similarity and the extent of copying. IMO modern copyright law is too liberal in this regard (i.e. favors copyright holders) and has gotten rid of many bright line rules that rejected infringement claims early on. But all of this absolutely matters if you're going to trial. The Oracle v Google case was fundamentally about how to construe similarity and extent in the context of APIs.

Re:Congress wants to extend the copyright on some sound reco... by rayiner on Friday May 18, 2018 @05:43PM (#17105199)
Copyright only covers coming someone else’s fictional character. It’s not copyright infringement if you happen to come up with a character that resembles Hermione or whatever.

As to the Dracula example: why should you be able to use the fruits of someone else’s labor for free? There is literally an infinite amount of independent things you can create without using other people’s work.

Re:Congress wants to extend the copyright on some sound reco... by darkarmani on Friday May 18, 2018 @09:02PM (#17106072)
> why should you be able to use the fruits of someone else’s labor for free?

Why not? I like the letter 'i'. Why do you get to use the letter 'i' for free when it is my favorite? Every time you use it without paying me, you deprive me of the potential profits that i could make licensing that usage. Why do you get to benefit from the heat my body gives off?

Anything that has infinite supply is going to have a low price (to free) price without artificial constraints. In this case the artificial monopoly is copyright. There is no scarcity, so gov't "regulates" and "distorts" the market to reward content creators. This is not a natural state.

I'm not against a well-balanced copyright system that actually encourages creation in exchange for a limited time monopoly.

Re:Congress wants to extend the copyright on some sound reco... by gnode on Monday May 21, 2018 @09:32AM (#17118225)
I don't have a problem with copyright covering characters, but with the excessive copyright term. My example of Dracula is that he is regarded by most as a classical character, like Frankenstein or Scrooge, not a modern character to be licensed like a Marvel superhero. Should the works of Shakespeare be under the creative control of his distant descendants?
Re:Congress wants to extend the copyright on some sound reco... by snowwrestler on Friday May 18, 2018 @04:35PM (#17104755)
> Copyright has been extended to cover fictional characters for instance.

Can you provide an example?

Re:Congress wants to extend the copyright on some sound reco... by gnode on Monday May 21, 2018 @09:39AM (#17118272)
Yes; Mickey Mouse is covered by copyright law, via the copyright on the original work he appeared in -- Steamboat Willie.

While the protection of the copyright of Steamboat Willie in itself is probably of no consequence to Disney, it's foundation to the licensability of Mickey Mouse is.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steamboat_Willie#Copyright_sta...

Re:Congress wants to extend the copyright on some sound reco... by snowwrestler on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @01:00PM (#17127434)
The copyright on Steamboat Willie only protects Steamboat Willie. Copyright is specific to the work it protects; it does not provide general protection of the characters in the work.

Mickey Mouse the character is protected by trademark. Unlike copyright, there is no time limit on trademarks. As long as they remain in active use and defended by the mark holder, they remain protected. To be clear: Steamboat Willie could enter the public domain tomorrow and it would not affect Mickey's trademark status.