This is even more true when the control is done through more clever means. For instance one way that black individuals and poor whites (who were just as much a cause for concern - see: armed labor strikes) were prevented from having access to weapons was by putting absurdly large taxes on them. Since the tax ostensibly affects everybody equally, it makes it much more difficult to argue that it's discriminatory even though such acts 100% through and through were aimed with exclusively discriminatory ends in mind.
Again, if true, that clearly undermines the claim that guns prevent violations of rights.
I'm not much of a gun person, but in looking at the history of guns and the quite ambiguous information on positive impacts of control - I've become not only more understanding, but also in support, of their efforts to maintain their rights to arm themselves.
That seems to pretty clearly undermine the whole case for guns somehow preventing violations of rights.
>~150k surviving black soldiers with an unknown number who decided to stay in south, doesn't really justify stating that blacks had easy access to weapons.
Then why did they bother passing the laws? It's also patently absurd to suggest that an occupying army doesn't constitute a significant force. No citizens' militia is likely to approach the capabilities of a 150k well-organized soldiers.