News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rust programs versus Go by dullgiulio on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @06:20AM (#17081247)
Oh no, not The Benchmarks Game again :(

This whole thing is meaningless and deeply flawed.

The sources of the various solutions vary a lot in quality: different libraries are used, different settings (in Go vs Java the use of threads is almost never the same).

I suspect the only true end of this benchmarking exercise is to make people comment vigorously on HN and similar forms.

Can we stop posting them?

Re:Rust programs versus Go by chatmasta on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @06:55AM (#17081389)
I’m the OP. I figured this post would either get tons of upvotes or flagged off the first page. The title really is a firebomb on HN lol.

But honestly I find it genuinely interesting. I’m planning to take some time to learn either rust or go this month, so comparisons like this are helpful for me. And I also appreciate the contrarian comments and discussion of the merits (or lack thereof) of the benchmarks.

Re:Rust programs versus Go by notheguyouthink on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @09:06AM (#17082034)
I really, really like Rust. Yet, I use Go.

This is mainly do to firstly, Go just fits way way better for my shop. The transition from my fellow employees from Python to Go is pretty straight forward. Secondly, Go is just nicely setup for ease. I had so much hell in Rust cross compiling a simple https server.. it was mind numbing. It might be better now, but I was shocked at how difficult it was.

Finally, Go is just more nice to write in when you're.. well, writing it out. I guess I tend to write as I think about data structures, abstractions, general design. I don't draw it ahead of time or w/e, I just write code. Go is very minimal, and is pretty forgiving to quick rewrites/etc. In Rust I found myself writing myself into a corner constantly when all I was trying to do was get an idea out of my head.

With that said, I vastly preferred Rust's feeling of knowing exactly what my program is doing. No question on if something is nil or not, you know it is or isn't (or know it's unknown haha).

I think for me, in another 2 years I'll push again for Rust > Go in my shop as I imagine the Rust tooling will have improved to the point where it's easier and more quick to write things. Rust was experiencing a lot of cargo package churn, I spent hours debugging which packages worked together, it was a headache. Even understanding errors was a bit of a headache, despite the compiler trying really hard. Rust is making great strides though, and even though I use Go to get shit done, Rust is probably my favorite language.. that I don't use heh.

edit: Oh yea, and green threads, god do I wish Rust had green threads. I found Rust to be similar to Go in multithreading ergonomics, but I couldn't use them in the same manner as with Go - ie, fire off as many as I want. There are several libraries in development that should take care of this though, I believe.

Re:Rust programs versus Go by vanderZwan on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @09:32AM (#17082209)
> Oh yea, and green threads, god do I wish Rust had green threads.

They still don't? I thought they were working on that years ago, no?

Re:Rust programs versus Go by steveklabnik on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @11:24AM (#17083137)
1. long ago, we used to have green threads and a runtime

2. we decided to eschew the runtime, and therefore, the green threads.

3. Since then, various libraries have implemented green threads in various ways

4. Tokio is basically green threads today. It really depends on what you mean exactly by "green threads".; but it schedules N tasks on M OS threads, so...

Re:Rust programs versus Go by vanderZwan on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:03AM (#17091287)
Thank you for clarifying!

> 2. we decided to eschew the runtime, and therefore, the green threads.

The most important bit I guess, regarding the question of whether Rust will ever have green threads/fibers/trails/whatever (answer: no, because no runtime).

Re:Rust programs versus Go by steveklabnik on Thursday May 17, 2018 @10:10AM (#17091320)
Not built into Rust, yes. But since Rust has no runtime, if you want those things, you can bring them along, as a library. The danger there is splitting an ecosystem, but in general the community has been sensitive to this, and once Tokio was determined as the way forward, the other projects stopped to throw their weight behind it too.
Re:Rust programs versus Go by notheguyouthink on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @09:36AM (#17082239)
They had green threads, but removed it. To my knowledge, there are multiple libraries that effectively implement green threads, but it's still a work in progress. Might be production ready, not sure, but I believe at the very least the ergonomics are a work in progress.
Re:Rust programs versus Go by vanderZwan on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @10:14AM (#17082532)
Hmm, sounds like the kind of thing that is hard to get right then. Maybe it's for the best that it isn't in the standard library until the design and implementation stabilises then.

Sucks for early adopters though!

Re:Rust programs versus Go by vertex-four on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @10:30AM (#17082674)
I doubt Rust will ever get green threads - it turns out that OS threads are good enough, and futures (async/await) is how IO will get dealt with at scale. Green threads don’t help compute-bound code, so with a solution in place for IO, they’re unnecessary.
Re:Rust programs versus Go by steveklabnik on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @11:39AM (#17083258)
It's quite unlikely that Rust the language will get green threads, yes. We are getting stackless couroutines ("generators"), which are related but not the same thing.

There's a ton of options in this space, and they're all slightly different, with different tradeoffs, so it's really hard to make good comparisons. You have to deeply understand exactly what each language is doing.

Re:Rust programs versus Go by pcwalton on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @10:24AM (#17082615)
Did you try to spawn lots of threads? OS threads scale better than you'd think.
Re:Rust programs versus Go by forgot-my-pw on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @11:41AM (#17083269)
Right tool for the right job.
Re:Rust programs versus Go by giancarlostoro on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @07:09AM (#17081452)
I used to like Go a bit, but never did a full blown application in it, just did enough to get a feel of it. Having tried Rust recently (after not liking the idea of not having classes like in Go) I have to say I prefer Rust for several reasons.

For starters the tooling for Rust is well done. If I want to install Rust on any machine I'm on I just go to https://rustup.rs/ and go from there, then I can use rustup to update my tooling or add features to the compiled.

The other thing is the wealth of packages[0] that expand upon Cargo (Rusts build system and package manager) namely the cargo-deb package which lets me build my Rust projects directly into a Debian package.

Continuing on about tooling I have to mention that for IDE's / Text Editors: CLion w/ Rust Plugin is fantastic, but if you want something fully free the VS Code plugin is also amazing for Rust. There's a great effort towards building the Rust Language Server, which thanks to Microsoft is a generic spec that once implemented for one language can be used by any editor / IDE that supports langserver[1].

I will say depending on what you want to do with Rust there can be a bit of a learning curve. I'm still just bleeding my way through some parts because I don't know what everything means in Rust just enough to try different things.

I will say Rust is nowhere near where it could be, but it's at a stage where I think it's definitely usable. They definitely took their time to make sure they got things right, and they got plenty right.

[0]: https://crates.io/ [1]: http://langserver.org/

Re:Rust programs versus Go by Thaxll on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @09:46AM (#17082296)
You mention tooling and IDE where Go is better than Rust in that space and as for Cargo just use go dep problem solved.
Re:Rust programs versus Go by senorsmile on Thursday May 17, 2018 @02:01AM (#17089098)
Honestly, the tooling in go seems very poor to me. There are lots of potential solutions, none of which remotely compare to the efficiency and ease of use of cargo. Golang needs a project independent manager, a la carton,bundler, or pipenv (although cargo is the best imho).
Re:Rust programs versus Go by steveklabnik on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @11:25AM (#17083139)
What tooling do you prefer in Go and why? Just curious!
Re:Rust programs versus Go by skywhopper on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @09:26AM (#17082170)
I disagree that the comparison as presented on this page is useful for you. If there were any context or discussion of the results and what they mean in terms of differences between the languages, then maybe it could be. But raw benchmarks collected with no indication of why or how is not. In the regex test, for example, all the patterns are very similar to each other and don’t really cover the breadth of what a regex engine can do (specific patterns may influence the results greatly—there are some very simple patterns that send the default Java regex engine into O(n^n) fits). And regex in particular is a very well understood problem space. So something very interesting is going on there for the golang result to be so far off. What is happening? Well, we’ll never know from this page. Oh well?
Re:Rust programs versus Go by chatmasta on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @10:26AM (#17082637)
Agreed... which is why I posted it here and it got 80+ comments. So there is a discussion now!
Re:Rust programs versus Go by igouy on Monday May 21, 2018 @10:18AM (#17118536)
>> Well, we’ll never know from this page.

Apparently, you now know that there's "something very interesting" to investigate! So, investigate?

Re:Rust programs versus Go by PopsiclePete on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @12:41PM (#17083854)
No reason to learn Rust or Go - learn Rust and Go. I use Go for most "network service" type stuff at my job. I would probably not choose Rust for those, even if I was as comfortable with it as I was with Go (which I'm not, since Go is much, much simpler).

There's many variables when considering what language to pick for a problem and if speed was the only thing we cared about, we'd just do raw assembly always.

Re:Rust programs versus Go by steveklabnik on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @01:00PM (#17084071)
We're even seeing production deployments that combine the two directly; Conduit and Dropbox both come to mind.
Re:Rust programs versus Go by vonseel on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @06:22AM (#17081254)
> suspect the only true end of this benchmarking exercise is to make people comment vigorously on HN and similar forms.

I suspect you are right and some of the posters suffer from “watching the likes roll-in” addiction

Re:Rust programs versus Go by some_account on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @07:09AM (#17081454)
Benchmarks are important actually. Maybe they are not 100% accurate but they do tell you that rust is faster than go. Since rust is also more complex than go, you have to decide if it's worth complexity and learning curve for the speed.

Without benchmarks, we all would use python for everything right? :)

Re:Rust programs versus Go by _ph_ on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @07:12AM (#17081472)
Well, no. Some of the presented benchmarks prevent the Go solution to be as efficient as the Rust one by their rules, e.g. prohibiting object pools in Go, but not in other languages. Same with hash tables. They benchmark the default Go hash tables vs. custom implemented ones for the benchmark in C.
Re:Rust programs versus Go by seba_dos1 on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @07:45AM (#17081606)
Which, at least for hash tables, seems completely reasonable and representative of most actual experiences with both languages?
Re:Rust programs versus Go by _ph_ on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @07:52AM (#17081645)
No. Standard libraries are a good thing, but if you want to write performant code, you definitely should consider a more specific implementation which is tuned to your actual problem. This is good practise in any programming language.

But the rules of this benchmark page explicitly prohibit that, so languages, which don't have hash tables in their "standard" library have a strong advantage, which isn't a good representation of the speeds of well writting programs in those languages.

Re:Rust programs versus Go by seba_dos1 on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @08:26AM (#17081811)
In terms of performance, languages which don't have has tables in their standard library have an advantage in real life too, not just in the benchmark. While what you say is true, in great majority of the real life cases, if there's hash table implementation in the library, the developer will use that. If there's none, then they will start looking for one, making it more likely that they will choose a more fine-tuned to their needs implementation than if they already had generic one provided in the standard library.
Re:Rust programs versus Go by dullgiulio on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @08:46AM (#17081928)
Or, more realistically, the first answer on Stack Overflow that, as we all know, is the wrong one. The right one is always under the fold, with more upvotes but not selected as right by the asker.

A standard library for a language will most probably get more attention from developers than any external library.

Re:Rust programs versus Go by igouy on Monday May 21, 2018 @10:28AM (#17118603)
No, a "custom implemented" hash table is not used for the benchmark in C.

A generic hash table from a third-party library is used -- something written to be generally useful, not compromised to look good on a toy benchmark.

https://github.com/attractivechaos/klib/

Re:Rust programs versus Go by vanderZwan on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @09:30AM (#17082198)
Yes, benchmarks are important, which is why we should use proper ones. The Benchmarks Game is not one of those.
Re:Rust programs versus Go by igouy on Tuesday May 22, 2018 @11:32AM (#17126654)
>> in Go vs Java the use of threads is almost never the same

Seems like you might be suggesting the Go programs don't use multicore but the Java programs they are compared against do use multicore, or vice versa, or …?

Currently just 1 comparison (reverse-complement) shows a sequential Go program and a threaded Java program.

Re:Rust programs versus Go by bananarepdev on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @06:34AM (#17081306)
Probably going to get downvoted for that, but could you recommend me some similar forums? :)
Re:Rust programs versus Go by dx034 on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @06:48AM (#17081362)
Reddit can be decent IMO (e.g. reddit.com/r/golang)