Re:Completely Silent Computer
by ckastner on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @04:25PM
(#17077569)
Funnily enough, my MacBook Air 2013 produces a buzzing sound on SSD access. It's barely audible, but it's there.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
My MacBook Air 2013 is routinely the loudest machine in the room when it's compiling or similar.
Does it have fans? If not, what kind of noise is this ?
MBAs have fans, the 12" MacBook doesn't.
Possibly inductors vibrating.
Re:Completely Silent Computer
by SmellyGeekBoy on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @04:16AM
(#17080777)
"Coil whine".
No, the sound comes mostly from the fans, which when at their maximum start to get loud.
Re:Completely Silent Computer
by tigershark on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @06:38PM
(#17078531)
Oh...it’s not just me then..
Every couple of months I check my 2015 MacBook Pro system info because I’m utterly convinced that it has an hard drive because of the SSD noise.
It’s quite frustrating actually..
Imagine being a kid in the 80s or 90s at school and hearing the distinctive 20k tone of a CRT Television humming and wondering if you were going to be watching TV in one of your classes that day. It was like a dog whistle for kids.
If you're in the US or anywhere else with NTSC, the horizontal scan rate (and thus the whine of the flyback transformer) is 15.75 kHz :)
525 lines / 2 for interlacing * 60 fields per second = 15750
times 1000/1001 ever since color was introduced, so about 15734 Hz
Re:Completely Silent Computer
by toomanybeersies on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @08:45PM
(#17079136)
For me that was a thing until the late 2000's.
They were still using CRT TVs in 2012 when I finished high school. I wouldn't be surprised if there were still plenty of schools with CRT TVs and VCRs for educational material.
I still have a 19" CRT[0] as 2nd monitor at work because... why not?? It still works most of the time and supports a decent resolution (1400x1050 - 1600x1200 flickers). And it's a nice nostalgic conversation piece :)
[0] https://www.cnet.com/products/compaq-s910-crt-monitor-19-ser...
Re:Completely Silent Computer
by pcarmichael on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @07:47PM
(#17078860)
Back around 2001 I took my desktop build (Celerin 300A oveeclocked to 450MHz), installed a giant passive heat sink on the CPU and PSU, put in an 8MB IDE flash drive, and network booted off a server in my laundry room. I thought I was finally noiseless. But the end result was worse. I had coil whine out of my power supply any time CPU usage ramped up. If I was in the same room, I could tell whenever my email pinged the server or if a cron job ran. It was both instructional (why is my cpu ramping and I’m not even logged in?) and really annoying.
I had one of those, I think it may have overclocked to 550MHz, I can't remember for sure. The cooling fan was audible outside of my house!
Re:Completely Silent Computer
by techdragon on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @08:06PM
(#17078955)
I’m routinely annoyed by what I am reasonably sure is the sound of my MacBook Pro’s heat pipes and other warm components expanding and contracting, making creaking noises shortly after starting it up on a winter day. Then there’s the gentle gaseous hissing I would swear is the heat pipes condensing and evaporating (based on workload and laptop temperature concurrent with the noise) if I could think of a practical reason for them to be audible.
No, it's not just you. I can hear the SSDs in two of my laptops.