Similarly, it's hard to mistake an aged Burgundy for a Cote Rotie, or a Sauvignon Blanc for a Reisling.
Wine stores without Enomatic machines or equivalent are a mostly waste of time, IMO, unless you already know the maker's style and it's what you're looking for; or the owner has excellent taste. Dispensers give you the ability to taste a dozen or two wines with ease in a single evening.
Sometimes I think wine could be dumbed down. My best example: Sauv Blanc tastes like grass and bell pepper. Is that universal? No. Does that capture every subtlety? No. But it is the defining characteristic.
I'd like to observe that when you wanted to claim that wines were indistinguishable, you picked two wines that were quite similar. When you wanted to claim beers were distinguishable, you picked chocolate stout vs hefeweizen, which is clearly not the same sort of example.
With beer, everything except pale lager tends to have a distinct flavor of some kind, that can be named easily. Chocolate, wheat, fruit, corn (Keystone), etc.
You have quite an offputting smugness, triggered by such a light and otherwise friendly discussion.
Seriously? Comparing sauvignon blanc and chardonnay to a chocolate stout and a pale lager? Are you intentionally trying to be disingenuous?
For someone with practice (and not a lot of practice), the difference between different wines made from the same grape isn't difficult. A "typical" Australian Chardonnay tastes buttery, while a Chablis is like sucking flint. And years ago I had a Texan Chardonnay that stank like rotting cabbages, yet tasted ... well, more or less the same, but in a good way.
Try a red Bordeaux then a red Cahors.
Sure, but I won't find any of those in my local supermarket, and even at an actual wine merchants they'll probably be tucked away in the corner at best. Most of the shelves will be taken up with a bunch of very similar reds and a bunch of very similar whites, categorised primarily by country of origin which I'm pretty sure the person in the street would struggle to taste. Whereas the beer aisle will probably have at least sections for lagers, IPAs, session ales/saisons, stouts/porters, maybe fruit beers...
Well they are clever, but traditional merchants in the UK always have open bottles to taste from, but also offer tasting events where you can be taught by an expert, or even the winemaker themselves. A lot more fun than the machines I think!
If you're in London, I recommend Vagabond Wines. Not only do they have a good selection in tasting machines rotated frequently, they also do tasting evenings. I've been going to the Fulham branch for years, but they've expanded.
Hedonism Wines is also a mandatory visit, of course.
I would argue that this says more about you and the “canonical consumer” than it does about wine. If you don’t find anything distinct about an Australian Shiraz versus a German Riesling, then I don’t know what to tell you.
There are trends (just as everyone in beer spent 15 years trying to make hoppier, higher ABV IPAs) but if anything beer is following wine, not the reverse.
(Just know what you want to order ahead of time and always leave a tip. The place has a heavy local vibe and the bartenders can be a little scary.)
But the craft beer saturation point can't be too far into the future. Same for coffee roasters. In the Boston to W DC corridor both of these are everywhere; points of differentiation fewer and further between.
Like any fad, these things cycle and burst. Boutique beer and coffee are on that path.
In the same way, I am just hoping that the transition towards Bio wines won't lead to a predominance of a new single style that would come to replace Bordeaux-like reds.
Indeed, I'm right there with you.
All these IPA's taste the same to me: incredibly bitter. There's no subtlety.
Hop Stoopid is one of the few IPAs I can stand, actually, which I find particularly bizarre because I normally don't like hops (I normally go for thick malty beers).
Anyway, my point is that at least there is some choice around - you are not restricted to Miller and Bud or Sam Adams (the last is not a bad brew) and I am not restricted to Carling and Fosters or shudder "creamflow" bitters.
Try to imagine what marketing would come up with in this scenario:
You brew a pretty non descript British ale that has been guzzled for years, in vast quantities for decades. Your competition is a few other huge breweries that do exactly the same. You experimented with a stout (in England - hah!) a few years back and looked stupid. Your ale is served at a few degrees below room temperature, it is completely flat, it is very brown. It tastes like err brown coloured ale. Cider is also available.
Then lager arrives, and then Pils and all sorts of other things (wine is invented as well at this point by a plucky chef called Floyd) and at about the same time Britons develop tastebuds on their tongues.
====== Marketing and Product Development come up with "Cremeflow". As far as I can tell the idea is to turn a decent hoppy bitter into a sort of pseudo lager with a creamy head. Weird and unsurprisingly unsatisfying on a lot of levels. What is even odder is that this abomination is served everywhere that a corporate logo is involved. Oh and let's freeze the bloody thing. Even worse: Guinness "fucking stupidly cold". ======
OK, in the UKoGBnNI we have come up with some absolute belting beers/ales - we have a very long tradition on this in common with many other countries. We have an organisation called CAMERA (CAMpaign for Real Ale) that tries to keep the firm straight.
IPA is really a Britain specific concept and belongs to our Empire days. India Pale Ale was brewed to be strong enough to survive being transported to India (the Raj) which took a fair old while. More alcohol == less bacteria. Back then there was no refrigeration and bizarrely, the locals didn't produce beer (fancy!)
Trust me, whatever you see printed on the bottle in the US - it is not an IPA. Drink that stuff and you will turn into a Redcoat and become a Brit, so unless you find yourself wearing a big wig after a serious quaff it isn't. Get your own name for your stuff - this awful chapter in history is taken already.
And no, Guinness doesn't count. Except for their Antwerpen stout--that one is actually really good...but I think it's only available in their 200 Years of Stout in America pack. Their foreign extra stout is okay too.
Perhaps they're a proponent of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reinheitsgebot
Nevertheless I wouldn't call any of them good beer. Impressively consistent flavoring for the volume they make, sure, but that's the only thing interesting about them.
I'm not against innovation in brewing. I like Alvarado Street Peninsula Pilsner a lot, despite the fact that brewery makes dozens of beers, most of which are terrible. I only think if a brewery can't make a pilsner or lager or other standard beer, then I'm not interested in trying their joke beers either.
Let consumers choose what they like, just like how the Craft Beer industry has done for the last couple of years. If there's one lesson to learn, it's that consumers love to try new varieties, and there's a lot of money to be made for being ambitious.
For everyone in the Bay Area, it's worth your time to go up to Sonoma county and hangout at Lagunitas and Russian River Breweries. Both are famous for not holding back and brewing whatever beer comes to their mind, and it's delicious.