News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Has wine gone bad? by api_or_ipa on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @03:36PM (#17077089)
I have to say I hope the wine industry goes the same way as the craft beer industry: towards innovative techniques to differentiate brands by distinct taste and sourcing. Walk into any liquor store and half the store is filled with wine labels that most people can't differentiate. Compare this to the beer aisle: A wild yeast lambic is only similar to a Bud Light in that they are both beers. I'd be hard pressed to ever debate drinking one or the other because they are so distinct. Not that either of them are bad, but they serve different times and places. I'd love to see the same with wine. Give me bold, ambitious wines that either use long-forgotten techniques or pioneer new ones. Give me as much variety as possible, and hell, wrap it up in feel good micro-winery stories.

Let consumers choose what they like, just like how the Craft Beer industry has done for the last couple of years. If there's one lesson to learn, it's that consumers love to try new varieties, and there's a lot of money to be made for being ambitious.

For everyone in the Bay Area, it's worth your time to go up to Sonoma county and hangout at Lagunitas and Russian River Breweries. Both are famous for not holding back and brewing whatever beer comes to their mind, and it's delicious.

Re:Has wine gone bad? by barrkel on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @03:54PM (#17077263)
Wines also taste completely different from one another. E.g. taste a vin jaune, a vin doux naturel, an eiswein, an orange wine - you'd never mistake any of these for one of the others, and none of them for any normal red or white off a restaurant wine list.

Similarly, it's hard to mistake an aged Burgundy for a Cote Rotie, or a Sauvignon Blanc for a Reisling.

Wine stores without Enomatic machines or equivalent are a mostly waste of time, IMO, unless you already know the maker's style and it's what you're looking for; or the owner has excellent taste. Dispensers give you the ability to taste a dozen or two wines with ease in a single evening.

Re:Has wine gone bad? by unethical_ban on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @04:06PM (#17077397)
I don't think the variety in flavor is as obvious in wine as in beer. For someone with practice, the difference (and ability to describe the difference) between a Sauvingon Blanc and Chardonnay isn't difficult. I think anyone off the street can taste the difference between a chocolate stout, a hefeweizen and a pale lager.

Sometimes I think wine could be dumbed down. My best example: Sauv Blanc tastes like grass and bell pepper. Is that universal? No. Does that capture every subtlety? No. But it is the defining characteristic.

Re:Has wine gone bad? by typomatic on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @04:39PM (#17077674)
> the difference (and ability to describe the difference) between a Sauvingon Blanc and Chardonnay isn't difficult. I think anyone off the street can taste the difference between a chocolate stout, a hefeweizen and a pale lager.

I'd like to observe that when you wanted to claim that wines were indistinguishable, you picked two wines that were quite similar. When you wanted to claim beers were distinguishable, you picked chocolate stout vs hefeweizen, which is clearly not the same sort of example.

Re:Has wine gone bad? by unethical_ban on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @05:53PM (#17078217)
I don't know what I don't know. I guess what I'm saying is, to the non-discerning wine drinker, there is red and white. Perhaps sweet vs. dry in there. It is much more difficult to taste the "dark fruit" and "light fruit" differences in particular reds than it is to taste the presence of certain overpowering notes in almost every beer. Wine is more subtle.

With beer, everything except pale lager tends to have a distinct flavor of some kind, that can be named easily. Chocolate, wheat, fruit, corn (Keystone), etc.

Re:Has wine gone bad? by typomatic on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @12:36AM (#17080036)
You have quite a lot of opinions on a topic which you admittedly don't know.
Re:Has wine gone bad? by unethical_ban on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @09:42AM (#17082279)
I was actually trying to be polite and humble, since I've tasted at least 700 distinct beers and probably about 80 wines. I do have my opinions, and the servers in any decent establishment will not insult the person who likes a drink "because it tastes good".

You have quite an offputting smugness, triggered by such a light and otherwise friendly discussion.

Re:Has wine gone bad? by cycrutchfield on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @11:33AM (#17083213)
And you have quite an offputting ignorance, which you show no qualms about putting on display for everybody to see.

Seriously? Comparing sauvignon blanc and chardonnay to a chocolate stout and a pale lager? Are you intentionally trying to be disingenuous?

Re:Has wine gone bad? by typomatic on Thursday May 17, 2018 @01:50PM (#17093616)
Well, forgive me for being smug to someone that deserves it.
Re:Has wine gone bad? by jimnotgym on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @04:15PM (#17077498)
Try a Sauternes against a sauvignon blanc and you may change your mind.
Re:Has wine gone bad? by dghf on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @06:34AM (#17081305)
> For someone with practice, the difference (and ability to describe the difference) between a Sauvingon Blanc and Chardonnay isn't difficult.

For someone with practice (and not a lot of practice), the difference between different wines made from the same grape isn't difficult. A "typical" Australian Chardonnay tastes buttery, while a Chablis is like sucking flint. And years ago I had a Texan Chardonnay that stank like rotting cabbages, yet tasted ... well, more or less the same, but in a good way.

Re:Has wine gone bad? by arkh on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @10:33AM (#17082698)
> I don't think the variety in flavor is as obvious in wine as in beer.

Try a red Bordeaux then a red Cahors.

Re:Has wine gone bad? by lmm on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @06:02AM (#17081183)
> Wines also taste completely different from one another. E.g. taste a vin jaune, a vin doux naturel, an eiswein, an orange wine - you'd never mistake any of these for one of the others, and none of them for any normal red or white off a restaurant wine list.

Sure, but I won't find any of those in my local supermarket, and even at an actual wine merchants they'll probably be tucked away in the corner at best. Most of the shelves will be taken up with a bunch of very similar reds and a bunch of very similar whites, categorised primarily by country of origin which I'm pretty sure the person in the street would struggle to taste. Whereas the beer aisle will probably have at least sections for lagers, IPAs, session ales/saisons, stouts/porters, maybe fruit beers...

Re:Has wine gone bad? by cycrutchfield on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @11:34AM (#17083218)
I think that says more about supermarkets and their choice of selection than it does about wines in general.
Re:Has wine gone bad? by lmm on Thursday May 17, 2018 @03:38AM (#17089507)
It's fair to judge "the wine industry", which was the grandparent's original phrasing, by what I experience when buying wine as a consumer. (It's not like it's just supermarkets - in a typical restaurant it will be the same thing).
Re:Has wine gone bad? by jimnotgym on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @04:14PM (#17077480)
> Wine stores without Enomatic machines or equivalent

Well they are clever, but traditional merchants in the UK always have open bottles to taste from, but also offer tasting events where you can be taught by an expert, or even the winemaker themselves. A lot more fun than the machines I think!

Re:Has wine gone bad? by barrkel on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @06:06PM (#17078329)
Tasting events are cool, but they often have a commercial edge, focusing on a particular distributor. You also need to make time for them - you can't just turn up any evening on your own demand.

If you're in London, I recommend Vagabond Wines. Not only do they have a good selection in tasting machines rotated frequently, they also do tasting evenings. I've been going to the Fulham branch for years, but they've expanded.

Hedonism Wines is also a mandatory visit, of course.

Re:Has wine gone bad? by jimnotgym on Friday May 18, 2018 @05:27PM (#17105086)
Turn the clock back a hundred years and try some of these other merchants.

http://www.bunchwines.co.uk/

Re:Has wine gone bad? by cycrutchfield on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @04:08PM (#17077420)
>Walk into any liquor store and half the store is filled with wine labels that most people can't differentiate. Compare this to the beer aisle: A wild yeast lambic is only similar to a Bud Light in that they are both beers. I'd be hard pressed to ever debate drinking one or the other because they are so distinct.

I would argue that this says more about you and the “canonical consumer” than it does about wine. If you don’t find anything distinct about an Australian Shiraz versus a German Riesling, then I don’t know what to tell you.

Re:Has wine gone bad? by AndrewBissell on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @03:45PM (#17077181)
Allow me to plug our winery here, only because I think we're aiming for just what you're asking :-)

https://www.inconnuwine.com/

Re:Has wine gone bad? by mattmaroon on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @03:57PM (#17077299)
The wine industry always was that way. It really took off in America in the 70s and the number of small craft producers has been on an upward slope ever since. While the beer industry consolidated into a small number of large producers, wine has done the opposite.

There are trends (just as everyone in beer spent 15 years trying to make hoppier, higher ABV IPAs) but if anything beer is following wine, not the reverse.

Re:Has wine gone bad? by cycrutchfield on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @04:15PM (#17077489)
On the other hand, one could argue that the addition of American producers and American consumers has made wine significantly worse over the years as well. Robert Parker has been America’s worst wine export in the past few decades.
Re:Has wine gone bad? by gerdesj on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @05:51PM (#17078196)
One could argue that but I wont. I recall what wine looked like in the UK 30 odd years ago. Nowadays we have an embarrassment of choice including some pretty decent wines from the US.
Re:Has wine gone bad? by kd0amg on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @04:14PM (#17077482)
Just having a large number of small producers does not imply that the market has the amount of product differentiation GP is asking for. Wine I see on shelf does not make much attempt to distinguish itself stylistically from the other products sitting next to it. Going the other way, having a small number of producers does not imply product uniformity. A single brewing company is perfectly capable of making a wide variety of beers.
Re:Has wine gone bad? by archagon on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @09:01PM (#17079196)
Or go to Toronado in SF, which is basically Russian River Annex! I think I've tried pretty much every notable RR beer there since I started going in 2016, including things like Beatification.

(Just know what you want to order ahead of time and always leave a tip. The place has a heavy local vibe and the bartenders can be a little scary.)

Re:Has wine gone bad? by chiefalchemist on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @06:00PM (#17078282)
Perhaps. Now pardon me for getting slightly off topic...

But the craft beer saturation point can't be too far into the future. Same for coffee roasters. In the Boston to W DC corridor both of these are everywhere; points of differentiation fewer and further between.

Like any fad, these things cycle and burst. Boutique beer and coffee are on that path.

Re:Has wine gone bad? by Niksko on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @07:51PM (#17078876)
Oh for sure, the current rate of aggressive expansion and new breweries both in the US and Australia is unsustainable. My armchair assessment is the Australia will start to see an uptick in small brands folding because they're unsustainable in the next 2-3 years
Re:Has wine gone bad? by a_136_chiffa on Thursday May 17, 2018 @01:29PM (#17093385)
Hope not. In the US, at least, the craft beer came to be dominated just by a couple of types that are easy to make - notably the IPAs. Some other types are present as well, but the selection and the quality are nowhere near. While it is a welcome change from a quasi-universality of the American Pilsner (Bud-cough-weiser-cough), a bit more diversity and more forays into more technical and difficult to succeed wines would do a world of good.

In the same way, I am just hoping that the transition towards Bio wines won't lead to a predominance of a new single style that would come to replace Bordeaux-like reds.

Re:Has wine gone bad? by stochastic_monk on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @05:46PM (#17078150)
Rare Barrel in Berkeley is a worthy pilgrimage for any craft beer connoisseur.
Re:Has wine gone bad? by archagon on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @09:09PM (#17079231)
I'm not always a fan of sour beers — too many wild ale producers err on the side of vinegariness these days, IMO — but I think RB gets the balance right more often than not, and their adjuncts tend to be amazing. (Plus, great venue and excellent guest taps on most nights!)
Re:Has wine gone bad? by api_or_ipa on Wednesday May 16, 2018 @02:17PM (#17084972)
So I've been told! I need to commit to checking it out one weekend-- Berkeley as a whole is such a gem.
Re:Has wine gone bad? by jakobegger on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @04:13PM (#17077474)
I’m also a fan of the craft beer hype. I never really tasted a difference between all our local beers, they’re all the same to me... but an IPA, that’s something very different!
Re:Has wine gone bad? by emodendroket on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @04:48PM (#17077751)
I don't really care for IPAs and I am a little annoyed that making a beer as bitter as possible is now what constitutes making a high-quality beer for so many people. But I realize my own preference, really sour beers, isn't exactly pleasing to everyone either.
Re:Has wine gone bad? by lutorm on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @05:16PM (#17077941)
I am a little annoyed that making a beer as bitter as possible is now what constitutes making a high-quality beer for so many people.

Indeed, I'm right there with you.

All these IPA's taste the same to me: incredibly bitter. There's no subtlety.

Re:Has wine gone bad? by dagw on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @06:07PM (#17078337)
Are you in the US? American IPAs are quite different from British or other European IPAs in style and flavour. Could be worth trying if you can find some as the British IPAs tend to be much less heavy on the bitter notes and have a rounder flavour.
Re:Has wine gone bad? by lutorm on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @09:49PM (#17079379)
I am more positively inclined to British beers like Spitfire and Bishop's Finger which, although I'm not sure they're technically IPA, are definitely quite bitter. I don't think I've ever seen them in the US, though.
Re:Has wine gone bad? by astura on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @08:39PM (#17079113)
I would have agreed with you a year ago, however, some of the "New England style" IPAs have been quite good lately. New England style has less hops and tastes really "juicy."
Re:Has wine gone bad? by emodendroket on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @05:19PM (#17077965)
I mean, prominently advertising their IBUs would suggest that's even what they're going for.
Re:Has wine gone bad? by amyjess on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @05:59PM (#17078278)
Interestingly enough, some of the ultra-high-IBU beers come out the other end and don't taste nearly as bitter as mid-IBU IPAs, and they tend to have more actual flavor even. Something like, for example, Lagunitas Hop Stupid with 100 IBUs doesn't taste half as bitter as your typical 60-70 IBU IPA.

Hop Stoopid is one of the few IPAs I can stand, actually, which I find particularly bizarre because I normally don't like hops (I normally go for thick malty beers).

Re:Has wine gone bad? by emodendroket on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @08:19PM (#17079013)
There is a limit past which you can't taste the difference (I mean like humans are physically incapable), I think.
Re:Has wine gone bad? by rmcpherson on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @05:39PM (#17078100)
While that was true to some extent 5-10 years ago, that is not the trend now nor has it been for several years. Hop flavor and aroma are the focus now of craft beer breweries, with significantly less bitterness.
Re:Has wine gone bad? by emodendroket on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @05:49PM (#17078178)
I can't tell the difference.
Re:Has wine gone bad? by gerdesj on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @06:00PM (#17078286)
Viva la difference! (I'm a Brit btw). An IPA (India Pale Ale) in the US is not the same as here, however I have noticed that our IPAs are rapidly heading in the same direction as the US version. That includes serving it rather colder ... I am also seeing a lot more "craft" beer here again - yay!

Anyway, my point is that at least there is some choice around - you are not restricted to Miller and Bud or Sam Adams (the last is not a bad brew) and I am not restricted to Carling and Fosters or shudder "creamflow" bitters.

Re:Has wine gone bad? by emodendroket on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @08:20PM (#17079017)
That's true, but if I go to a restaurant and they only have a couple "craft" beers, the odds are extremely high that they're all IPAs, which is kind of a bummer if you're into beer but don't really like IPAs.
Re:Has wine gone bad? by gerdesj on Thursday May 17, 2018 @07:12PM (#17097003)
Look on the bright side mate, you don't have to put up with creamflow. British ale is generally considered a bit weird by non Brits at the best of times but that thing is an abomination.

Try to imagine what marketing would come up with in this scenario:

You brew a pretty non descript British ale that has been guzzled for years, in vast quantities for decades. Your competition is a few other huge breweries that do exactly the same. You experimented with a stout (in England - hah!) a few years back and looked stupid. Your ale is served at a few degrees below room temperature, it is completely flat, it is very brown. It tastes like err brown coloured ale. Cider is also available.

Then lager arrives, and then Pils and all sorts of other things (wine is invented as well at this point by a plucky chef called Floyd) and at about the same time Britons develop tastebuds on their tongues.

====== Marketing and Product Development come up with "Cremeflow". As far as I can tell the idea is to turn a decent hoppy bitter into a sort of pseudo lager with a creamy head. Weird and unsurprisingly unsatisfying on a lot of levels. What is even odder is that this abomination is served everywhere that a corporate logo is involved. Oh and let's freeze the bloody thing. Even worse: Guinness "fucking stupidly cold". ======

OK, in the UKoGBnNI we have come up with some absolute belting beers/ales - we have a very long tradition on this in common with many other countries. We have an organisation called CAMERA (CAMpaign for Real Ale) that tries to keep the firm straight.

IPA is really a Britain specific concept and belongs to our Empire days. India Pale Ale was brewed to be strong enough to survive being transported to India (the Raj) which took a fair old while. More alcohol == less bacteria. Back then there was no refrigeration and bizarrely, the locals didn't produce beer (fancy!)

Trust me, whatever you see printed on the bottle in the US - it is not an IPA. Drink that stuff and you will turn into a Redcoat and become a Brit, so unless you find yourself wearing a big wig after a serious quaff it isn't. Get your own name for your stuff - this awful chapter in history is taken already.

Re:Has wine gone bad? by LambdaComplex on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @06:47PM (#17078584)
Agreed. It really annoys me that I can go to the grocery store and get all sorts of IPAs (and some brewers have more than one!) yet I can only find a handful of stouts.

And no, Guinness doesn't count. Except for their Antwerpen stout--that one is actually really good...but I think it's only available in their 200 Years of Stout in America pack. Their foreign extra stout is okay too.

Re:Has wine gone bad? by ebikelaw on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @03:49PM (#17077215)
A lot of those innovative West Coast beers are, at best, hoaxes. I think maybe the craft brewers could swing back slightly to tradition. I seek out craft pilsners and lagers because a clear, tasty pilsner is very difficult to produce in quantity. It's a sign of a decent brewery, whereas a cloudy barrel-aged grapefruit sour is a sign of mental illness.
Re:Has wine gone bad? by pavel_lishin on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @03:51PM (#17077226)
What makes a beer a hoax?
Re:Has wine gone bad? by eric_h on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @04:15PM (#17077494)
Just a guess, but I think s/he means it's got more than barley, hops and water in it, given their stated preference for pilsners and lagers.

Perhaps they're a proponent of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reinheitsgebot

Re:Has wine gone bad? by emodendroket on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @04:40PM (#17077678)
In that case Miller, Coors, Budweiser, and friends are also all "hoaxes."
Re:Has wine gone bad? by eric_h on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @04:42PM (#17077698)
I wouldn't necessarily disagree with that ;)
Re:Has wine gone bad? by emodendroket on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @04:44PM (#17077715)
I'll stand up for Miller High Life as a decent beer. It's not knock-your-socks-off incredible but it's a reliable choice you can find pretty much anywhere.
Re:Has wine gone bad? by eric_h on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @04:54PM (#17077791)
I mean I'd put all of the beers you listed under the drinkable category - with Miller High Life marginally more flavorful than its compatriots in that list.

Nevertheless I wouldn't call any of them good beer. Impressively consistent flavoring for the volume they make, sure, but that's the only thing interesting about them.

Re:Has wine gone bad? by emodendroket on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @05:20PM (#17077972)
They're also pretty much agreeable to everyone in a way that whatever favorite beer you have probably isn't. My favorite beer is Cuvee des Jacobins but it's a very love-it-or-hate it kind of thing and probably wouldn't be a great choice for a party.
Re:Has wine gone bad? by eric_h on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @05:29PM (#17078019)
Ah, a sour :) I haven't tried that one, but I certainly approve.
Re:Has wine gone bad? by astura on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @08:46PM (#17079140)
It's not distributed everywhere, but places it is available, Yuengling is the generic go-to lager for me.
Re:Has wine gone bad? by cycrutchfield on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @04:12PM (#17077462)
Maybe not a hoax, but perhaps what the person above meant is “gimmicky”. How else do you explain beer that tastes like peanut butter or whatever other crap these breweries put out?
Re:Has wine gone bad? by ebikelaw on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @06:39PM (#17078539)
A beer is a hoax if it tastes terrible but beer critics fawn all over it and it costs $9 for a pint. Hazy/cloudy beers are the recent pinnacle of this style. They are the all-white paintings of the beer world. Brewers spent centuries learning to clarify beer, for a reason. Coffee stouts are another example of a dumb joke that many brewers have copied.

I'm not against innovation in brewing. I like Alvarado Street Peninsula Pilsner a lot, despite the fact that brewery makes dozens of beers, most of which are terrible. I only think if a brewery can't make a pilsner or lager or other standard beer, then I'm not interested in trying their joke beers either.

Re:Has wine gone bad? by stagger87 on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @04:05PM (#17077389)
Can you tell me who makes the barrel-aged grapefruit sour? That sounds good!
Re:Has wine gone bad? by scruple on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @04:41PM (#17077683)
If you're ever passing through the California central coast area, I absolutely recommend a stop at the Firestone Walker Barrelworks in Buellton. They don't, to my knowledge, have a 'barrel-aged grapefruit sour' but they absolutely have very interesting small-batch barrel-aged brews on tap and my wife and I always stop in when we pass through.
Re:Has wine gone bad? by emodendroket on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @04:39PM (#17077673)
I like a good pilsner, but I really love the cloudy sour beers more than any other style.