Re:Memory transfer between snails challenges view of how bra...
by mozumder on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @02:14PM
(#17076242)
Also also, treating life as a fifth fundamental force of the universe when chemistry explains all the components just fine is… well, literally pretentious.
No. Stating that chemistry explains all the components of life just fine is literally pretentious.
Maybe chemists should stop researching since they already explained everything?
Re:Memory transfer between snails challenges view of how bra...
by simonh on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @04:07PM
(#17077398)
Now you’re just nitpicking. So far every single process we have analysed occurring in living things has worked exactly as we expect from our understanding of chemistry. There just isn’t any reason to expect we will find anything chemistry can’t explain, and you haven’t given us any reason to do so or a way to test for such a thing.
To put it another way, what leads you to your conclusion? What evidence is it based on? What phenomena that we currently observe might such a thing explain, and how?
Re:Memory transfer between snails challenges view of how bra...
by ben_w on Tuesday May 15, 2018 @03:13PM
(#17076839)
> Stating that chemistry explains all the components of life just fine is literally pretentious.
Name one biological proces which defies the laws of chemistry.
Saying:
> Maybe chemists should stop researching since they already explained everything?
Is like saying “Computer scientists should stop researching since they already explained everything in terms of NAND gates”.
> Sorta pretentious to just define life to fit existing narratives when you don't have an explanation.
I’m having trouble understanding where you’re going with this sentence.
I’m not defining life, I’m saying there isn’t a definition of life (that I know of) which seems satisfactory.
Also, I don’t think it would be pretentious to start with a definition that fits existing narratives, because that’s how most words work: a label for a bunch of examples, followed by a rule — a definition — which creates a pattern for those examples. Like fire “metabolising” oxygen and fuel to reproduce and “move”, but not being alive. When you find edge cases, either change the definition to fit the new data or create a new category for the new data [1]. I know that domain experts don’t use that previous definition of life for exactly the reason I gave, but last I checked “are viruses alive?” still got arguments.
Also also, treating life as a fifth fundamental force of the universe when chemistry explains all the components just fine is… well, literally pretentious.
[1] That’s just an IMO about language, of course: if language was that simple then NLP would be a solved problem.