The problem with WiFi Direct is that all its local mobile-to-mobile capabilities are disabled if the group doesn't have a node connected to a tower at all times. For example, you can't have three devices up in the mountains exchange files or messages, unless one of them can get the OK from a service provider's tower. WiFi Direct stops as soon as you lose cellular signal or experience a service timeout. It's crippled by design.
EasyMesh doesn't seem to offer any neighbor-to-neighbor utility; It appears to be focused solely on expanding coverage of single-point-of-control networks which are already overcrowded (hence the need for so many range extenders). When are we not in range of half a dozen or more WiFi networks?
I see adding more APs as an exercise in futility. The primary issue is overcrowding, not signal strength. Remove all the other nearby networks & one router easily reaches across most buildings.
Sorry, I guess that's two topics in one comment, but I'll repeat my primary question: In what way are these different approaches "completely" different? They seem to all be chasing roughly the same goal. I also feel that "mesh" has stagnated due to lack of hardware support (& accompanying lack of open source firmware).
I'M SORRY! I was thinking of LTE Direct, which is crippled by design. Please disregard my statement about "WiFi Direct" needing a cellular tower.
Wi-Fi Direct is nothing more than running (e.g., 802.11n) software AP with WPS on one device ("Group Owner") and having (multiple) peers connect to it to form a "group" -- it's just a normal AP, you can even connect legacy Wi-Fi devices to it. It does add functionality to automatically negotiate which device becomes the access point and to do some service discovery on the link layer before connecting.