> "Just as we’re coming out of the bar, here comes Ann, running across Route 66 toward me. She puts her arm in mine, and says, “Come on, let’s go over to my place.”"
the other with
> "We went into the bar, and before I sat down, I said, “Listen, before I buy you a drink, I want to know one thing: Will you sleep with me tonight?”
> “Yes.”"
These interactions seem like voluntary, enthusiastic consent by rational adults. Maybe I'm seeing a contradiction where there is none, but if a woman who left and never had any need to see him again ran back to initiate physical interaction and invite him to her place, is it possible she knew more about the situation than you and didn't consider his behavior quite bad?
There are other allegations [1]. But that isn’t the central point really, the point is, why idolize someone who did some good work in one area and expect everything they do to be a work of genius? He was imperfect (or are you arguing otherwise?) his work in Biology is not very interesting...
[1] https://galileospendulum.org/2014/07/13/the-problem-of-richa...
The work discussed in the paper, is not particularly interesting in isolation.
Reading that excerpt, I got the sense he was writing from the perspective of his past-self, in an almost self-deprecating way. He’s citing that incident of an extreme example of how literally he would follow instructions. By choosing it as an extreme example, he’s effectively acknowledging that the attitude was disrespectful / wrong.
Granted I haven’t read the whole book, but I wouldn’t be surprised if there is some crucial context missing from those excerpts.
Feynman did, after all, write the words himself.
What I’m saying, is that it’s unwise to idolize people because of their work in one area and then elevate (or more worryingly emulate) there work in other areas.
Like his treatment of women, Feynman’s work in Biology is not really very interesting. It wouldn’t stand up on its own merits... the only reason to talk about it is if you treat Feynman as some kind of Hero/ideal. Feynman is not really a wonderful person to idolize (not that anybody is)...
The work Feynman did in Biology that’s discussed here doesn’t seem to be particularly ground breaking, or interesting. It feels like it’s only being treated as such because Feynman did interesting work in other areas and is somewhat idolized for this.
Probably not, but I don't think being interested in an individual necessarily means idolizing them. In fact, sometimes the actions that we consider abhorrent is what makes them interesting. That's not the case here, but still, I think there's potential value in studying how a very good physicist approached a foreign subject matter.
Feynman no doubt did some interesting work in Physics. But the work discussed here doesn’t appear to be particularly distinguished. It does not follow that someone did interesting work on X therefore everything they did must be valuable and interesting.
I suppose what I’m trying to say is that individuals are a complex mixture of good and bad. And that there’s a danger that an individual who has done interesting work in one area is seen as a universal genius, and an ideal to be emulated. This unfortunately is not the case.
[1] https://restructure.wordpress.com/2009/08/07/sexist-feynman-... for example...