News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Killing Strategy: The Disruption of Management Consulting by Retric on Monday May 14, 2018 @11:19AM (#17066232)
Logically that sounds good, but in practice most of the work is done by people without specific related backgrounds.

The problem is the company can't judge work quality if they don't understand the domain. So, it boils down to most companies over billing and under delivering.

Re:Killing Strategy: The Disruption of Management Consulting by hinkley on Monday May 14, 2018 @12:23PM (#17066776)
Have you ever done consulting?

The problem is that the company can’t judge the size of the problem they have. When you don’t know what you’re asking you are very likely to get sticker shock.

If two agencies put in a bid on your job, where one is planning to profit on rework (dishonesty) and the other is estimating for all the unknowns, you’re going to go with the first guy because you like his price better. And then you’re gonna get taken to the cleaners.

Re:Killing Strategy: The Disruption of Management Consulting by exelius on Monday May 14, 2018 @12:27PM (#17066816)
Rework is often the profit strategy when the client comes to us with a lowball price in mind. Don’t chalk it all up to dishonesty; many times we have to do exactly what the client asks us to first, watch it fail, then suggest a more expensive path for rework.

The right call is the right call, even if the client dislikes the price. But sometimes you have to let the client fail before they’re willing to listen to you (the bigger the implementation, the more true this tends to be).

Re:Killing Strategy: The Disruption of Management Consulting by chiefalchemist on Monday May 14, 2018 @12:38PM (#17066908)
Yeah, the ugly baby problem, often combined with the desire for best practices results but a complete aversion to best practices.

The consultants can cover the scope and do their job, but if the client doesn't listen and exectute then it's like the long gone consultants will be blamed. The status quo persists, etc.

Re:Killing Strategy: The Disruption of Management Consulting by exelius on Monday May 14, 2018 @12:24PM (#17066797)
Sure, the work is done by inexperienced staff — that’s how we train them. But the work is reviewed by someone with experience, who should correct any mistakes before the client sees them.

We try to staff experienced people on engagements, but they get bored and leave the company because all we do are bullshit implementations. You have to give people career progression opportunities, which in consulting means managing teams through execution and training them up.