This touches on one other thing that large consulting firms have, and that is global reach coupled with great internal networking and knowledge management. Bank A needs to comply with new government regulation which is similar to that passed 6 months ago in country B where we did a similar engagement. No point re-inventing the wheel a dozen times when that country B team is a few clicks away and can guide you through what they did (and more importantly what they learnt along the way).
Put another way, it's the consultant's job to tell you what you might not want to hear. In plenty of orgs / cultures this isn't the case. In such cases, staff doesn't like consultants because from the front line the consultant is stating the obvious. However, it really management and leadership who should get the heat because they are the ones who define the culture where info doesn't easily transfer across the layers from see'ers and do'ers to the decision makers.
The problem for many of the pure strategy firms is that clients just bring them in for 2 weeks at the end of a project to “rubber stamp” the strategy. Of course, corporate boards got keen to this strategy and realized they didn’t really need MBB at all and should trust their people more — which is the whole reason the article was written.
Everyone in the industry has seen the writing on the wall for at least a decade. There is a reason the big 4 all went around buying up mid-market strategy firms 5-10 years ago; the market losers were on fire sale and the winners were vulnerable. But the wars there are over; everyone is focused on partnering with software companies for the next round of cloud ERP implementations.
The problem is the company can't judge work quality if they don't understand the domain. So, it boils down to most companies over billing and under delivering.
The problem is that the company can’t judge the size of the problem they have. When you don’t know what you’re asking you are very likely to get sticker shock.
If two agencies put in a bid on your job, where one is planning to profit on rework (dishonesty) and the other is estimating for all the unknowns, you’re going to go with the first guy because you like his price better. And then you’re gonna get taken to the cleaners.
The right call is the right call, even if the client dislikes the price. But sometimes you have to let the client fail before they’re willing to listen to you (the bigger the implementation, the more true this tends to be).
The consultants can cover the scope and do their job, but if the client doesn't listen and exectute then it's like the long gone consultants will be blamed. The status quo persists, etc.
We try to staff experienced people on engagements, but they get bored and leave the company because all we do are bullshit implementations. You have to give people career progression opportunities, which in consulting means managing teams through execution and training them up.
1. A particular company will need the service infrequently
2. Many different companies will benefit from the service
3. The service requires a lot of manpower
4. The service is complicated and has a learning curve
So, to provide a concrete example, suppose you want to re-negotiate all your contracts with all your suppliers. This is the bread and butter of many large firms. However, you can't do it all the time, you only want to do it once every 10 years or so. It is quite complicated and requires a lot of people with experience doing it, and almost any company will benefit from doing it.
This is exactly when you would hire a consultant that is known and respected in this area.