I'm just starting with what a particular thing would cost me elsewhere, and offering to pay that to someone else.
Also, I'm trying to avoid going into specifics because they won't help us understand why coffee shops should work on their customer interaction, but I can assure you that our local co-working space has much higher monthly expenses than any of our coffee shops.
On the first floor of my building is a coffee shop. It pays more than 3x per rentable square foot than we do. Retail space is priced differently from office space. Attractive retail space is far more expensive than good office space.
No, I don't think phones and Internet makes it a toss-up. I think you're way off.
Also, FWIW, I've seen enough co-working spaces come and go that I find it hard to believe that they are running a massively profitable business relative to coffeeshops (& retail in general).
(1) Pays for commercial retail space, which is (in many cases) more than 3x more expensive than commercial office space (which is far more plentiful).
(2) Pays for multiple people's fully loaded headcount cost to staff the shop.
I didn't point out, but should have, that the shop also:
(3) Pays the wholesale price for the coffee (which is cheap but not free) and food (which is extremely expensive) and so has worse margins than the coworking space.
As for headcount, coworking spaces need to employ office managers. A single barista can serve hundreds of customers in a day. Per customer, a coworking space might actually need more employees.
* Your co-working space doesn't need to factor in the cost of baristas and managers into the value of a table/hour.
* Your co-working space isn't set up in a super-expensive retail property, so the inherent value of a table/hour their is lower.
You've been underpaying your coffee shop.