The Expanse is better.
The first episode has minimal camp, as does the film. The other episodes vary. You have to admit, compared to the camp of the 70s and 80s, Whedon's camp is quite nice.
But I'm trying to be objective and note the lack of correlation between a shows percevied quality and how that does/not translate into ratings.
While S1 did have its fair share of space battles, it was so nice watching something that wasn't all guns and fist fights and did so without having to resort to hours of dull pseudo-emotional monologues and barely relevant flashbacks.
Usually that kind of highbrow writing is reserved for "who done it" style crime dramas. It was refreshing to watch that same formula applied to the sci-fi genre given how cheesy or needlessly "emo" the genre has been of late.
I really like the show. It is quite dense.
I’ve only read the first 3 but thats definitely not true. FTL communication, physics-defying space maneuvering, the giant space ring thing controlling the speed of the surrounding armadas...
Even if there are attempts to create some explanation for it, in a hard sci-if story, it’s basically paranormal in all but name.
Paranormal are things that are by definition outside the explainable universe. It's not that we don't have an explanation, it's that they are by their very nature unexplainable.
The proto-molecule isn't paranormal, except for one aspect - the FTL communication. It's basically just a species-generic virus with an embedded AI.
(BTW. I found myself to prefer reading source books after watching a movie/series. In this order, my imagination is already primed by the show, so I don't experience the clash between how I imagined the characters vs. how the producers imagined them.)
Citing Wikipedia: Paranormal events are phenomena described in popular culture, folk, and other non-scientific bodies of knowledge, whose existence within these contexts is described to lie beyond normal experience or scientific explanation.
I think it's also worth remembering that the "fi" part of "sci-fi" actually stands for "fiction" and not "factual information" :P
"Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic. - Arthur C. Clarke -"
Syfy specializes in lcd barely-watchable crap. They get nervous when purchasing shows outside their specialty.
That seems really high to then cancel the show?
I'm guessing the problem is it is highly loved by a small group of individuals? But given Sci-Fi in general is a wide enough demographic for many other shows - it seems strange this is not drawing in the ratings?
[1] https://www.rottentomatoes.com/tv/the_expanse/