News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Sound of Madness by TeMPOraL on Sunday May 13, 2018 @05:01AM (#17057993)
It seems to be similar with mental pictures.

https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/baTWMegR42PAsH9qJ/generalizi...

"The debate [over mental imagery] was resolved by Francis Galton (...). Galton gave people some very detailed surveys, and found that some people did have mental imagery and others didn't. The ones who did had simply assumed everyone did, and the ones who didn't had simply assumed everyone didn't, to the point of coming up with absurd justifications for why they were lying or misunderstanding the question. There was a wide spectrum of imaging ability, from about five percent of people with perfect eidetic imagery to three percent of people completely unable to form mental images."

Personally, I'm someone with small-talk module running almost constantly, verbalizing most of my thinking and reading. On the other hand, I have very low capability of forming mental images.

I wonder how many other things in brain are like that, widely differing between people.

Re:The Sound of Madness by danieltillett on Sunday May 13, 2018 @05:37AM (#17058088)
I suspect that there is quite a large variation between people, but it has not really been studied because it is almost impossible to get funding to study differences that don't cause a problem to an individual. It is a shame because I find this topic fascinating.

I have a pet theory that more visual thinking is something that has come in from our Neanderthal ancestors. We know they had a brain more specialised around visual processing, but very little beyond this. It is almost certain that some people today think in a similar way to Neanderthals given how much of the Neanderthal genome is still present in the human population, but who they are and what they think like is unknown.

Re:The Sound of Madness by haZard_OS on Sunday May 13, 2018 @11:57AM (#17059551)
>I have a pet theory that more visual thinking is something that has come in from our Neanderthal ancestors.

That is an interesting proposal. One thing I like about it is its easy testibility. Given how easy it is to find people without Neanderthal DNA, the effort needed to conduct a study on this question would be minimal.

Re:The Sound of Madness by danieltillett on Sunday May 13, 2018 @05:52PM (#17061231)
Yes it is very testable, but probably too controversial to be studied in practice.
Re:The Sound of Madness by mirimir on Sunday May 13, 2018 @07:07PM (#17061516)
That's understandable, given how racial differences have so frequently been exaggerated and misused. Especially mental differences. Partly because they're so hard to measure objectively, being so tied with life experience.

And still, being part Neanderthal, I am curious.

Re:The Sound of Madness by danieltillett on Sunday May 13, 2018 @09:52PM (#17062139)
Yes it is a shame we can’t study this topic as it is such a interesting area. It would be nice if people understood different doesn’t mean inferior.

The thing many people forget about those of us that are Neanderthal hybrids is that all us hybrids carry different parts of the Neanderthal genome. Pinning down what genes are linked to what phenotypes would be very, very interesting.

Re:The Sound of Madness by LoSboccacc on Sunday May 13, 2018 @06:52AM (#17058284)
I wonder instead if it comes from early development, like having a preponderance of picture vs written books as a toddler and at what point of development getting read stories has an influence if any
Re:The Sound of Madness by danieltillett on Sunday May 13, 2018 @07:12AM (#17058349)
It is possible, but I suspect that any difference is formed earlier than this. I know I thought the way I think long before I learned to read.

I remember very clearly learning about the concept of the written word. Once it clicked suddenly I noticed the whole world was filled with words (not that I knew what most of them meant). The world was now very different to how I saw it before and I became fascinated with knowing what they all were (I used to drive my mother crazy asking her what every sign said).

I am also not sure if this is also related, but I was apparently quite a late talker (around 24 months), but once I started talking I was far ahead of other children of my age.

Re:The Sound of Madness by WalterSear on Sunday May 13, 2018 @02:58PM (#17060361)
It comes from practice. You can learn it today - start reading books using an RSVP reader and slowly dial up the speed until you can follow the story without saying the words in your head.
Re:The Sound of Madness by mirimir on Sunday May 13, 2018 @07:00PM (#17061491)
Back in the day, I loved The Clan of the Cave Bear and sequels by Jean M. Auel. As I recall, she characterized Neanderthals as having better memories, and more dependent on stored procedures. But I have no clue whether there was any basis for that.
Re:The Sound of Madness by danieltillett on Sunday May 13, 2018 @10:00PM (#17062170)
Neanderthal were certainly no less intelligent than their East African cousins, but they were different.
Re:The Sound of Madness by Broken_Hippo on Sunday May 13, 2018 @07:34AM (#17058407)
I, too, have a small-talk module running nearly constantly. It is English-based, but sometimes doesn't translate over to actual words.

However, I'm different: I form mental images all the time. I create them too. I might be putting a mountain here or there, all narrating it with my spoken inner monologue. I'm like this when making art (visual art) as well - I narrate the motions, making noises with pen strokes and finishing paint brush strokes with something akin to a sports presenter on the radio.

The combination of these two means I can get a mental image in my head that I've narrated to myself to build it, yet cannot describe it aloud in words without changing thought modes.