There is a middle ground between "we don't test for diseases" and "your kid's DNA is now public knowledge".
Please explain how keeping your daughter blood sample forever and selling it helped in any way ?
Running a detection test is what helped your daughter and is not the issue at hands, it's keeping samples indefinitely and selling them that's problematic.
I totally agree that there's a more privacy-respecting solution. I was asking why people were downvoting this comment.
Nobody objects to testing newborns for diseases. That’s awesome. Keep doing it. We all support that program, so there’s not much point in telling us how good it is.
Almost entirely unrelated to that is the storage of samples after they’re taken. That’s the actual problem, and solving it has not effect on the first issue there.
Down voting a comment like the parents is, at best, insulting the very premise of good HN discussions.
In this case I'm pretty disappointed by the replies I got to my question.
It's the quintessential example of authoritarianism defense. One instance of good justifies authoritarianism and violation of individual liberties and freedom.
The archival is Machiavellian.
https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/cystic-fibros...
So I'm fairly positive on this program...