Re:Fieldbook is shutting down
by brotherjerky on Saturday May 12, 2018 @07:15AM
(#17053508)
> 1. Raised $2.9m, 4 employees, 5 years. Let's say 2/3 of overhead was salary, which seems reasonable. So that's 500k each, or 100k/yr. This seems excessive? Were the founders paying themselves too much? Or where did the money go?
This comment is so naive that I don't know where to begin. You can't hire any quality people at $100k / yr fully loaded in SF Bay area.
For a seed stage company, 100k is not at all unreasonable. Extremely early employees get hefty stock grants to compensate for this.
Re:Fieldbook is shutting down
by user5994461 on Saturday May 12, 2018 @08:06AM
(#17053654)
That's looking for a co-founder or unpaid labor, not an employee.
Out of interest - what is considered a hefty stock grant?
100k/yr excessive? When Facebook's median compensation is 240k? The economics of working for a startup seem worse than ever these days.
Re:Fieldbook is shutting down
by TAForObvReasons on Saturday May 12, 2018 @01:51AM
(#17052661)
I wouldn't be surprised if the recent massive funding round for AirTable ($52M) forced some introspection and possibly created some external pressure.
The actual reason for closing down was laid out in the article. They got a talent acquisition offer and took it.
Flexport is an interesting place for Fieldbook to land, but I do see some synergies. I wonder if the team will focus on improving Flexport's internal operations or building a platform for Flexport's customers.
1. Raised $2.9m, 4 employees, 5 years. Let's say 2/3 of overhead was salary, which seems reasonable. So that's 500k each, or 100k/yr. This seems excessive? Were the founders paying themselves too much? Or where did the money go?
2. Difficulty in hiring. This seems very much attributable with the company's proximity to the SF black hole. Was relocation never even considered? And why was remote not considered? I would have liked to hear the reasons for those decisions.
All the points about potential recruits demanding "sexy" jobs or wanting to see high growth and large rounds seem pretty much exclusively SF problems. It seems like moving literally anywhere else would have solved this.
3. What is the actual reason for closing down? Out of money, or out of confidence? If my salary numbers above are wrong - and I should hope they are - maybe they still have a mil or so left, which seems like enough runway to take a stab at least some of the problems.
There were two seemingly contradictory considerations: lack of ability to iterate fast enough, and a realisation that the product was not viable. I would have liked to hear more about this too - iterating faster on the wrong thing would not have helped.
4. I know it's too late but even as an IT type when I look at the landing page I have very little idea what the product even does. A lot of features and use cases listed but what is the product and how does it solve any problem? There's a single screenshot four page heights down which looks like some kind of spreadsheet. It's not nearly enough.
Still, an honest, insightful and heartfelt piece and I wish the team good luck.