Re:Fitzgerald Officer of the Deck Pleads Guilty at Court-Mar...
by exabrial on Friday May 11, 2018 @01:05AM
(#17045075)
I can't believe a giant merchant vessel could collide with a modern warship... doesn't establish a lot of confidence. How did you not see that coming?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Fitzgerald Officer of the Deck Pleads Guilty at Court-Mar...
by bdamm on Friday May 11, 2018 @02:42AM
(#17045387)
Just one occasion would leave me shaking my head at the chain of failures that must have led up to that collision. But two similar collisions? Now it starts to seem like systematic conspiracy, or an attitude of expecting all other ships to maneuver away. How many commercial ships in the south China sea or sea of Japan have had to change course because of US Navy vessels over the last year? State ought to find out.
Re:Fitzgerald Officer of the Deck Pleads Guilty at Court-Mar...
by jabl on Friday May 11, 2018 @08:18AM
(#17046692)
Just as an anecdote, I was recently taking the ferry (as a passenger mind you), and the ferry encountered a Burke-class DD (which would be slightly unusual around here, but I later learned it was on its way to a friendly visit to my country). The Burke was ahead of us, to starboard, going in roughly the same direction, although slightly converging (lets say around 45 deg difference in heading, maybe?). When I got up, it was at maybe 1 nm distance, at 2 o'clock. So I go to another area of the ship, and the next time I look out of the window the Burke is on our port side at maybe 300m distance. Which, if my interpretation of events is correct, means the Burke cut in front of the ferry at frickin close range. For no effing reason whatsoever, considering there was plenty of open sea around both ships. This is the kind of macho BS attitude that gets people killed. Sure, nothing happened, but what if they would have had some kind of machinery or bridge communication malfunction? The ferry would have plowed the Burke in half.
Re:Fitzgerald Officer of the Deck Pleads Guilty at Court-Mar...
by slededit on Friday May 11, 2018 @05:53PM
(#17051034)
If the Burke was starboard then the ferry was the one who had to give way. You should be blaming them in this scenario.
The Fitzgerald was hit on the Port side which indicates it should have given way.
Re:Fitzgerald Officer of the Deck Pleads Guilty at Court-Mar...
by toomanybeersies on Friday May 11, 2018 @02:10AM
(#17045270)
The problem was more that they did see it coming buy wilfully, through a failure of command, sailed into it.