News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Emails Show FDA Chemists Have Been Finding Glyphosate in ... by fncypants on Thursday May 10, 2018 @07:43PM (#17043836)
I've noticed that Monsanto appears to be on an astroturfing campaign. Half of the ads appearing in my Reddit front page are promoted posts that are pro-glyphosate. They point to legitimate news articles, for example, that report on a study finding that glyphosate is not a carginogen. Of course, these studies contradict other studies that glyphosate is a carcinogen or otherwise a concern.

In truth, I was ready to believe the pro-glypsophate studies until a contrary consensus formed. Because of this astroturfing campaign, I now have doubts.

Re:Emails Show FDA Chemists Have Been Finding Glyphosate in ... by alexandercrohde on Thursday May 10, 2018 @08:41PM (#17044147)
You are correct. Court documents have shown Monsanto has paid online commenters to advocate on behalf of glyphosate in a program called "Let nothing go" (including facebook). These individuals, importantly, did NOT identify themselves as being paid advocates.

[1 - actual court documents] https://usrtk.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/MDLLetNothingGo...

[2 - summary article ] https://www.organicconsumers.org/newsletter/organic-bytes-55...

Re:Emails Show FDA Chemists Have Been Finding Glyphosate in ... by tptacek on Thursday May 10, 2018 @07:53PM (#17043887)
There are no credible studies indicating that glyphosate is a carcinogen, and it would be a little bit surprising it if was, since it targets a metabolic pathway not present in animals. Meanwhile, many of the herbicides that glyphosate displace, plenty of which remain in use, are known human carcinogens.

The most widely reported declaration of glyphosate's carcinogenicity, by IARC, was disavowed by the WHO, IARC's parent organization.

Re:Emails Show FDA Chemists Have Been Finding Glyphosate in ... by philipkglass on Thursday May 10, 2018 @09:42PM (#17044410)
Yes, I agree that evidence to date does not show glyphosate is a carcinogen. But this:

There are no credible studies indicating that glyphosate is a carcinogen, and it would be a little bit surprising it if was, since it targets a metabolic pathway not present in animals.

is not a very strong argument. Harmful "off-target effects" are a very common cause of drug development program failures. Most chemicals that are probable human carcinogens weren't developed with the intention to target metabolic pathways in any living thing.

Re:Emails Show FDA Chemists Have Been Finding Glyphosate in ... by tptacek on Thursday May 10, 2018 @09:46PM (#17044424)
The evidence seems to suggest that glyphosate is basically inert in humans, doesn't it?
Re:Emails Show FDA Chemists Have Been Finding Glyphosate in ... by philipkglass on Thursday May 10, 2018 @09:59PM (#17044469)
I've read enough literature about the carcinogenicity to assure myself that it is very probably not a carcinogen. And to my chemist's eye it looks fast to degrade, pretty benign overall. But biology is surprisingly complicated. That's why I think that the "it targets" argument means little. That's the only part I took issue with.
Re:Emails Show FDA Chemists Have Been Finding Glyphosate in ... by cryoshon on Friday May 11, 2018 @10:22AM (#17047468)
no? that isn't the way biology works whatsoever.

here is an example.

think of glyphosate as a key.

the key is designed to unlock a certain type of lock with a certain arrangement of pins. when the key unlocks the lock, the target dies. this is intended behavior.

but given the way that locks work -- patterns of pins -- it could very easily coincidentally work on other locks that it was not designed to unlock.

it won't be most other locks. it will be a small minority. it won't necessarily have the same result when that lock is opened as it does under its intended use. in fact, it might not even open the lock -- it might just get stuck in there real good and be impossible to remove. it might even have a beneficial effect (but probably not).

the details of this play out on the biochemical / enzyme-substrate level. another commenter pointed out how glyphosate is an estrogen-equivalent. this would not surprise me whatsoever. it wouldn't have to be a carcinogen to be wildly destructive in that context.

any time -- any time -- you have a chemical which is known to be bioactive, it's going to have an effect.

i just want to make it very clear that there is no excuse to have these chemicals in our food. they are not harmless. at best, they are an added inconvenience for the host's body to deal with.

Re:Emails Show FDA Chemists Have Been Finding Glyphosate in ... by pera on Thursday May 10, 2018 @10:18PM (#17044540)
> it would be a little bit surprising it if was, since it targets a metabolic pathway not present in animals

Maybe I'm misreading your comment, but for instance the following study (and some of its references) seems to contradict your assertion:

Glyphosate exposure in pregnancy and shortened gestational length: a prospective Indiana birth cohort study

https://ehjournal.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12940-...

Re:Emails Show FDA Chemists Have Been Finding Glyphosate in ... by dbasedweeb on Thursday May 10, 2018 @08:12PM (#17043976)
My concern is best summed up by this comment from above:

Every time the jury is out on a topic where one side has a vested interest and a billion dollar budget to protect it, you can be reasonably sure what the outcome will be. See: pesticides and bees, fossil fuels and climate change, food packaging plastics and cancer, pain treatment meds and addiction. The answer in all those cases is the harmful effects eventually became known, but the jury was out long enough for the vested interests to make a ton of profit and cause a ton of damage which they'll never pay for repairing. All made possible with a series of comparatively small investments to buy scientific research to keep the jury out.

Even in non-borderline cases like tobacco, lots of money and power can really confuse the issue. This is definitely not as clear cut as tobacco, and I’d like the option to opt out of the lengthy, massive “trial period” in which the public gets to play guinea pig. The problem with this is that it’s very difficult to do that when the compound in question is unexpectedly ubiquitous.

Re:Emails Show FDA Chemists Have Been Finding Glyphosate in ... by tptacek on Thursday May 10, 2018 @08:17PM (#17043989)
This isn't so much an argument as it is innuendo. If you get glyphosate carcinogenicity wrong, you increase carcinogenic agriculture, because that's what the market alternatives to it are: clearly known human carcinogens.
Re:Emails Show FDA Chemists Have Been Finding Glyphosate in ... by the-pigeon on Thursday May 10, 2018 @08:26PM (#17044038)
This is actually somewhat common too.

Like chlorine being replaced by other disinfectants in drinking water. https://www.npr.org/2011/01/07/132743638/disinfectant-to-cle...

Basically you have some popular chemical so it gets studied extensively and we learn about the bad things it does. It then starts being replaced by things that have been less studied, so there's less evidence of the bad things they do but could be equally bad, better or worse.

Re:Emails Show FDA Chemists Have Been Finding Glyphosate in ... by buvanshak on Friday May 11, 2018 @03:30AM (#17045554)
A very good recent example being Vaping replacing smoking as a "healthier alternative"....
Re:Emails Show FDA Chemists Have Been Finding Glyphosate in ... by dbasedweeb on Thursday May 10, 2018 @08:22PM (#17044021)
That isn’t so much an argument as a false dichotomy, predicated on a system of agriculture which allows a near 50% rate of wasteage in the West. The alternatives include less productive, yet still sufficiently productive methods which do not include carcinogenic compounds.

Edit: Your state of being persuaded is immaterial, because what I said isn’t really controversial. One known alternative to herbacides is tilling, hardly a radical new invention and notably not carcinogenic. As I said up front, it would take more effort to produce crops, but simply by reducing waste you can more than make up for that. The use of ground cover, litter, and other established techniques all allow for large scale farming without herbacides.

There are other alternatives, and adjunct techniques as well, for example:

http://plen.ku.dk/english/news/2015/crops/

Stop wasting so much food because it isn’t pretty enough, and you can stop truffing carcinogens. That seems fair.

Re:Emails Show FDA Chemists Have Been Finding Glyphosate in ... by tptacek on Thursday May 10, 2018 @08:27PM (#17044045)
It would be a false dichotomy if glyphosate hadn't literally displaced herbicides that were known to be human carcinogens and allowed anyways, but it did, so your logic isn't persuasive.
Re:Emails Show FDA Chemists Have Been Finding Glyphosate in ... by tropo on Thursday May 10, 2018 @08:55PM (#17044209)
I like tilling, but it requires lots of diesel fuel and it increases evaporation.

The future is probably robotic weed picking. That still requires fuel, but perhaps not as much.

Re:Emails Show FDA Chemists Have Been Finding Glyphosate in ... by GW150914 on Thursday May 10, 2018 @09:25PM (#17044338)
Is there some reason that EV’s can’t till? If you’re farming there’s lots of sunlight for solar, and nuclear is a good option too.
Re:Emails Show FDA Chemists Have Been Finding Glyphosate in ... by sooheon on Thursday May 10, 2018 @08:32PM (#17044074)
And what you're proposing is letting perfect be the enemy of the good. No matter how sustainable and green your alternative is, "less productive" anything won't fly in today's world economy. Until we change 8 billion humans' economic motives, maybe we can start with getting the facts straight on one substance.
Re:Emails Show FDA Chemists Have Been Finding Glyphosate in ... by r00fus on Thursday May 10, 2018 @11:39PM (#17044813)
False equivalence. There are non carcinogenic methods of farming.
Re:Emails Show FDA Chemists Have Been Finding Glyphosate in ... by airstrike on Thursday May 10, 2018 @10:32PM (#17044580)
The other market alternative is eating organic.
Re:Emails Show FDA Chemists Have Been Finding Glyphosate in ... by TeMPOraL on Friday May 11, 2018 @03:12AM (#17045494)
"Organic" usually means even worse chemicals were used so no, that's not better.
Re:Emails Show FDA Chemists Have Been Finding Glyphosate in ... by airstrike on Friday May 11, 2018 @10:43AM (#17047616)
Not all organic food fits that description.
Re:Emails Show FDA Chemists Have Been Finding Glyphosate in ... by matte_black on Friday May 11, 2018 @09:02AM (#17046973)
Like what?
Re:Emails Show FDA Chemists Have Been Finding Glyphosate in ... by Black-Plaid on Friday May 11, 2018 @01:00AM (#17045059)
There are also no credible studies showing that chlorine gas is carcinogenic, so it must be safe!
Re:Emails Show FDA Chemists Have Been Finding Glyphosate in ... by buvanshak on Friday May 11, 2018 @03:36AM (#17045578)
Another manifestation I have seen of this behavior is this.

The claim "vaccines does not cause autism" is often made to implicitly imply "All vaccines are very safe". I mean, this belief is harbored by every single one of the "Educated" "science-believers" out there. It is so damn ridiculous that people (who often consider themselves intelligent) can be so easily misguided.

Re:Emails Show FDA Chemists Have Been Finding Glyphosate in ... by exp1orer on Thursday May 10, 2018 @07:52PM (#17043882)
I recently read the great line: "Good ideas do not need lots of lies told about them in order to gain public acceptance."

http://blog.danieldavies.com/2004/05/d-squared-digest-one-mi...

Re:Emails Show FDA Chemists Have Been Finding Glyphosate in ... by gowld on Thursday May 10, 2018 @09:03PM (#17044238)
Policy by aphorism is fraught:

"Don't worry about people stealing your ideas. If your ideas are any good, you'll have to ram them down people's throats."

https://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Howard_H._Aiken

Re:Emails Show FDA Chemists Have Been Finding Glyphosate in ... by Gibbon1 on Thursday May 10, 2018 @08:33PM (#17044090)
I think this is the guy that gave me the gem.

    If a source is known to lie then the proper weight to place on information from that source is zero.
AKA: You don't try and second guess anything that say, you ignore everything they say.
Re:Emails Show FDA Chemists Have Been Finding Glyphosate in ... by perl4ever on Thursday May 10, 2018 @09:25PM (#17044336)
But it's tempting to assume the information is false, and if you do that, you could be making a big mistake. I assume by "zero weight" you mean you don't assume it's true or false, which is quite distinct.

One way to look at it is that every statement is true, given sufficient context. The question is, how should it be interpreted, and what is it a true statement about? Generally, when a liar says something, it is intended to either make you believe it is true, or make you believe it is false, or confuse you. So there is true information being provided, it's just not the face value of the statement.

Re:Emails Show FDA Chemists Have Been Finding Glyphosate in ... by Gibbon1 on Friday May 11, 2018 @05:40AM (#17045986)
By weight I mean the multiplier used when summing it with all the other things you know.

Meaning you don't use information from sources that lie to make decisions. Full Stop.

Re:Emails Show FDA Chemists Have Been Finding Glyphosate in ... by PantaloonFlames on Thursday May 10, 2018 @08:44PM (#17044161)
> Because of this astroturfing campaign, I now have doubts.

Wouldn’t it be ironic if the campaign were actually promoting the truth, and yet the effect it had on you was to persuade you of the opposite?

Not trying to change the subject but I see a parallel in US politics. This is how Trumpers harden their beliefs. So much true reporting about Trump’s lies, results in people becoming more loyal to him. Confounding.

Re:Emails Show FDA Chemists Have Been Finding Glyphosate in ... by vertexFarm on Friday May 11, 2018 @12:03AM (#17044894)
Reddit is a fantastic place for astroturf to sprout. It's almost designed explicitly for it. I don't know why people trust that place or mimic their awful system (such as this forum for instance)