Re:Varieties of Argumentative Experience
by DonbunEf7 on Thursday May 10, 2018 @09:59AM
(#17038890)
This is because the one-liner is actually (sorry SSC) a valid logical template, relying on assumptions about rule of law to draw a deductive inference. We can see the template itself:
SSC probably doesn't like this one because it's definitional. People like to use "criminal" is a qualitative label for people who they feel have broken the law, but it is in fact definable as a quantitative label for people who have committed acts which are unacceptable as a fact of law.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Varieties of Argumentative Experience
by mannykannot on Thursday May 10, 2018 @12:27PM
(#17040359)
We don't have to guess why Alexander disapproves the one-liner, as, after presenting the more thoughtful version, he writes:
"The original is a gotcha exactly because it doesn’t invite this level of analysis or even seem aware that it’s possible. It’s not saying “calculate the value of these parameters, because I think they work out in a way where this is a pretty strong argument against controlling guns”. It’s saying “gotcha!”."