News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The YIMBYs lost in California but they’re just getting st... by rayiner on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @08:17PM (#17035486)
It’s the government’s job to ensure adequate infrastructure. The people that buy from the developer will be paying for their proportionate share of that new infrastructure with taxes. Forcing the developer to cover the costs of infrastructure is just a sneaky way to shift the tax burden from existing residents to new residents.
Re:The YIMBYs lost in California but they’re just getting st... by singingboyo on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @08:40PM (#17035593)
The maintenance cost of existing infrastructure is paid for by existing residents. It seems sensible to have the up-front cost of adding new infrastructure covered by new residents/developers (who are later considered existing residents covering maintenance for the new, now-existing infrastructure).

Why would existing residents ever agree to new development if they have to pay for it? (Either through taxes to upgrade infrastructure, or by needing to deal with insufficient infrastructure that doesn't get improved as needed) Maybe instead of directly performing the upgrades, developers should be paying extra to the government (either lump sum, or over N years) because in theory the government can then do a few large upgrades rather than developers doing many small ones, but the cost of new capacity should really be the responsibility of the people who need it (developers/new residents).

Re:The YIMBYs lost in California but they’re just getting st... by rayiner on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @09:24PM (#17035772)
That’s not how taxes work. People pay a proportionate share of the services everyone agrees the community should have, not for services they use specifically. By you reasoning, new residents shouldnt have to pay to replace infrastructure old residents wore out, or to pay pensions for teachers that retired before they moved their kids into the local school.

As to why people would agree to new development—they shouldn’t be allowed to veto it. They should get to decide what level of infrastructure the government will provide to the community. But omce they do that, theh shouldn’t get to discriminate against new residents by forcing those residents to pay a disproportionate share of the common infrastructure.

Re:The YIMBYs lost in California but they’re just getting st... by stinkytaco on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @09:33PM (#17035816)
Who is "everybody" in this scenario? Who gets to decide who agrees on what the level is? Existing residents? The state? The federal government? At some point the decision making authority needs to exist.

Part of the problem of this proposal is that you are treating everyone equally in this scenario, but not all development is equal. A single family dwelling creates a different impact than an apartment building. It requires different sewers, road frontage and utilities. Its cost is different. What you are proposing encourages expensive development. If a person pays the same whether they build high density housing or a McMansion, what motivation is there to actually solve the housing problem? If residents can't veto development, and communities can't put limits on it, you're left with very few tools to actually resolve important issues like urban sprawl that got us into this mess in the first place.

If you propose levying different taxes based on the type of development, then we're back around to where we started: shifting the burden of infrastructure to the owners and developers that are utilizing it.

Additionally, I would argue that's not how taxes work at all. There are many "use" based taxes: utilities, sales tax, special assessments, gas tax, toll roads, and so on.

EDIT: Additionally, when you say "proportionate share", I think many would argue that's what charging developers and new residents for new infrastructure is. They benefit from the new infrastructure, thus they pay for it.

Re:The YIMBYs lost in California but they’re just getting st... by rayiner on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @09:59PM (#17035890)
> Who is "everybody" in this scenario?

Everyone that comprises the tax base that pays for the relevant infrastructure. In this case, state and local government.

> A single family dwelling creates a different impact than an apartment building. It requires different sewers, road frontage and utilities. Its cost is different. What you are proposing encourages expensive development.

On a per tax unit basis, apartments create much lower infrastructure cost that single family homes. An condo building with 100 units requires more sewer and road infrastructure than a single family home. But it’s got 100x the number of taxable units, and requires far less than 100x the infrastructure of a single family home.

> If a person pays the same whether they build high density housing or a McMansion, what motivation is there to actually solve the housing problem?

There is a natural incentive to build high density units in response to rising real estate prices, because you can make much more revenue per unit land. The market, unsurprisingly, provides the right incentives.

> If residents can't veto development, and communities can't put limits on it, you're left with very few tools to actually resolve important issues like urban sprawl that got us into this mess in the first place.

Urban sprawl was caused by existing residents legally requiring sprawl. For example, in my county, it’s illegal to build a house in most areas on less than 1/3 of an acre. I live in a pre-zoning law neighborhood where the lots are 1/5 that size. Even with the variances grandfathered in, a local developer had to fight for years to build three new houses conforming to the existing lot plan.

> Additionally, I would argue that's not how taxes work at all. There are many "use" based taxes: utilities, sales tax, special assessments, gas tax, toll roads, and so on.

Having a use-based tax that everyone pays is quite different than forcing new residents to foot the entire bill for shared infrastructure.

> EDIT: Additionally, when you say "proportionate share", I think many would argue that's what charging developers and new residents for new infrastructure is. They benefit from the new infrastructure, thus they pay for it.

Those people would be wrong. For example, people in my dense pre-zoning neighborhood pay our “proportionate share” for shared sewer mains and county roads. But 50 houses in my neighborhood pay about the same in taxes as 50 houses in a less dense area, but it cost the county way less to build sewer and road infrastructure to our 50 houses than to 50 houses in a less dense area.

For better or worse, our tax system is not built on paying proportionate to use. If it were, your point might be valid, but as I said, then new residents would get to avoid paying for a lot of other things they never used. If you charged new residents for the new infrastructure they require, then it’s not fair to make them pay for teachers and other public employees that retired before the new residents moved there. I’d take that deal in a heartbeat.

Re:The YIMBYs lost in California but they’re just getting st... by stinkytaco on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @11:30PM (#17036173)
You'll have to explain to me how new residents pay for retired public employees. Our public employees are either on a state or local pension plan they payed into, had that money invested, and are now drawing from, or they have a 457 plan. Currently working employees pay a portion of their salary into the plan to keep it going. The city's pension obligations to retired employees are almost nil.

I also take issue with your use of the term "shared infrastructure". If you view all infrastructure as shared, then the existing infrastructure is being used "for free" by new residents, its costs having been payed for by previous residents. In your proposal the costs are loaded onto existing residents who payed for both old and new infrastructure, as opposed to new residents who only pay for the new. This would seem to balance out whatever new residents are paying in for "things they never used".

EDIT: I should address your point about urban sprawl. I would think that as long as it is cheap to build new, the incentive to infill cities is low. Developers and buyers will prefer new, and that creates a number of negative externalities beyond housing shortages. New construction is obviously necessary, but we need to find ways to align the incentives of developers and communities. I actually think we're off the mark here talking about new residents, since only residents that buy new are saddled with the extra burden. New residents that opt to infill existing neighborhoods do not. Perhaps the better option is to place the burden on the developers, but offer residents other incentives (such as property tax relief on new construction).

Re:The YIMBYs lost in California but they’re just getting st... by zdragnar on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @08:41PM (#17035597)
Isn't this the crux of the issue? Why would current tax payers volunteer to pay more so that more people can come into their neighborhood, devaluing their property by increasing noise, light and chemical pollution?

It's curious to me that so many people complain about gentrification in terms of destroying the nature of an existing community, but then we also have so many complaints about zoning laws that are designed to protect the visible characteristics of communities.

Re:The YIMBYs lost in California but they’re just getting st... by pcwalton on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @08:44PM (#17035610)
> Why would current tax payers volunteer to pay more so that more people can come into their neighborhood, devaluing their property by increasing noise, light and chemical pollution?

Rayiner's point is that current tax payers won't pay more, because new residents result in a higher tax base in the first place.

In California with Prop 13 and widespread rent control, this is especially true.

Re:The YIMBYs lost in California but they’re just getting st... by crzwdjk on Thursday May 10, 2018 @03:20PM (#17042124)
In California with Prop 13, the current tax payers' property tax rates are well below those of newcomers regardless. So they have no incentive to change things, since their taxes stay at the same low rate either way, whereas in a normal state, I have an incentive to get as much new development in my town as possible to add to the tax base, especially if that new development is stuff that doesn't require lots of expensive infrastructure or tax subsidies.
Re:The YIMBYs lost in California but they’re just getting st... by mertd on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @09:33PM (#17035818)
I don't get the density causes devaluation argument. A plot of land in a high density area is a lot more valuable than in a low density area. So from a purely economic standpoint one should welcome density.

I feel like in California this devaluation argument is not really about economics but rather a proxy for making a case that might not be too politically correct when laid out as it is.

Re:The YIMBYs lost in California but they’re just getting st... by nitrogen on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @10:05PM (#17035919)
But a high or medium density plot in a low density area lowers the value of low density plots around it. A house on a quiet street with a decent view might be worth X, but the same house becomes worth X/2 if a high-traffic, view-blocking apartment complex is built next door.
Re:The YIMBYs lost in California but they’re just getting st... by mertd on Thursday May 10, 2018 @12:30AM (#17036386)
> A house on a quiet street with a decent view might be worth X, but the same house becomes worth X/2 if a high-traffic, view-blocking apartment complex is built next door.

I disagree. The house might be worth less but the plot of land it is sitting on is worth a lot to a developer who wants to build a similar complex there.

Re:The YIMBYs lost in California but they’re just getting st... by mmt on Thursday May 10, 2018 @01:15AM (#17036564)
> The house might be worth less but the plot of land it is sitting on is worth a lot to a developer who wants to build a similar complex there.

The problem is that this doesn't work in practice for individual homeowners. It would only work if all the homeowners who own those "plots" required by that developer are willing/able to sell at once, and that happens approximately never.

Moreover, the value of the house isn't just important at the time of sale but also at times such as mortgage refinances. A drop (or lesser gain) in value can have real negative financial consequences well before any sale.

Re:The YIMBYs lost in California but they’re just getting st... by nitrogen on Thursday May 10, 2018 @12:55AM (#17036493)
People with houses don't want land, they want houses.
Re:The YIMBYs lost in California but they’re just getting st... by ScottBurson on Thursday May 10, 2018 @12:12AM (#17036326)
But without the level of demand that created the need for that apartment complex, it would have been worth X/4.
Re:The YIMBYs lost in California but they’re just getting st... by nitrogen on Thursday May 10, 2018 @12:57AM (#17036499)
Not really. Imagine a wealthy neighborhood in a suburb. The value is the space and quiet.
Re:The YIMBYs lost in California but they’re just getting st... by jfoutz on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @10:01PM (#17035905)
I lived in the sticks. To connect to a utility, you pay the initial cost. Stuff like utility poles or pipes. The maintenance is covered by the community.

Perhaps it’s not like that everywhere. But from that background, it seems reasonable for the developer to pay for upgrades.

Re:The YIMBYs lost in California but they’re just getting st... by rayiner on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @10:09PM (#17035930)
I’m not talking about utility hookups, which developers pay. I’m talking about the practice of forcing developers to pay for upgrades to shared infrastructure in order to secure approval for their projects.
Re:The YIMBYs lost in California but they’re just getting st... by jfoutz on Thursday May 10, 2018 @01:13AM (#17036560)
I understand your point. But if a pipe only carries 10 gal/min and the new building requires 20, it’s on the developers for the upgrade.

And to clarify, by new installations I mean paying for half a mile or more of infrastructure. Not a hookup, but running new stuff for a good distance.

Re:The YIMBYs lost in California but they’re just getting st... by stinkytaco on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @09:24PM (#17035774)
Not sneaky at all, but rather by design. Why should existing residents pay for new residents to move in? What benefit are new residents to them? In fact, many towns don't put the burden of maintenance on existing residents either, but rather make it up in special assessments and utilities.
Re:The YIMBYs lost in California but they’re just getting st... by landryraccoon on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @10:27PM (#17035984)
Won’t the new residents pay way more than the old ones because of prop 13? I don’t see how there’s any way the new residents don’t end up paying more than the old ones.
Re:The YIMBYs lost in California but they’re just getting st... by mmt on Thursday May 10, 2018 @01:23AM (#17036594)
Maybe more, but is it enough more? Remember that prop 13 doesn't completely freeze property taxes, nor does it eliminate various special assessments and parcel taxes and other non-percentage-of-value taxes.