From this same thread:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17034959
> God I would love it Manhattan banned Uber and all non-commercial traffic (exile all civilian traffic to the highways and parking garages alongside them) and upped the number of buses. Clean new yellow cabs too and tougher requirements to drive them (raise the fares, I don't care).
Re:Buses Need Our Love More Than Ever
by icebraining on Friday May 11, 2018 @11:24AM
(#17047959)
Manhattan is not a city, it's the smallest borough of a city.
> No one is saying we should ban private cars from cities.
Many people on HN do (search for it). That's the point i was trying to counter with the original comment.>"No one is saying we should ban private cars from cities"
I am actually saying that, at least for the city centers.
Ban private cars, or charge a non-trivial congestion fee. Let commercial vehicles with a business purpose drive there, for deliveries and work, and let taxi services operate. But get rid of the space-hogging private cars.
I think it's reasonable to expect a commuter to walk 4-5 blocks on either end of a ride unless they happen to be handicapped. And winter jackets, boots, and umbrellas are available for the conditions you've mentioned.
No one is saying we should ban private cars from cities. Those will be needed, but they should definitely not be the default mode of transportation for most urban dwellers.