News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by yosito on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @04:11PM (#17033553)
Pretend you're a woman and then read the comments on this post. That makes it pretty obvious that one of the reasons women have a hard time feeling welcome in tech is because men don't listen to or empathize with them when they speak about their opinions or perspectives.
Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by as1mov on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @04:21PM (#17033651)
I've been browsing this thread for about 45 minutes. Not a single comment is rude, most of the comments are trying to debate about the issue.

If you post a submission on a forum and expect everyone to blindly agree with you or you else you consider it as "hate", then the problem is perhaps with you.

Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by yosito on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @04:38PM (#17033831)
You must have missed all the comments of men complaining that they can't be friendly to women because they're an unattractive man. Not sure where you got the word "hate" from. I'm not saying anything about hate.
Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by arkis22 on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @04:51PM (#17033964)
Are you saying that the men here aren't being empathetic because they feel like when they talk to women they get called creepy and therefore don't want to? Please, be specific.

Otherwise it just sounds like the pot calling the kettle black.

Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by yosito on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @05:26PM (#17034259)
Specifically, dismissive comments full of excuses like "I'm unattractive and women aren't nice to me" are lacking empathy.
Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by arkis22 on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @05:31PM (#17034321)
It is not dismissive if it's true.
Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by yosito on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @07:12PM (#17035111)
That's not how that works.

^ This comment is me being dismissive of you, and it's also true.

Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by arkis22 on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @07:46PM (#17035301)
You have the right to be dismissive, but you don't have the right of proving me wrong without arguing against my point with a coherent argument.

You are basically saying that women have never treated men differently based on their attractiveness, which is absurd.

Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by yosito on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @08:03PM (#17035397)
> you don't have the right of proving me wrong without arguing against my point

Did you have a point? I missed it. The closest thing I've seen to you making a point in this thread was when you said "the problem is perhaps with you".

> You are basically saying that women have never treated men differently based on their attractiveness

That's not what I'm saying. But I'm tired of repeating myself, so please re-read my previous comments.

Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by stcredzero on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @04:48PM (#17033937)
You must have missed all the comments of men complaining that they can't be friendly to women because they're an unattractive man.

I've missed them. Can you aggregate links? I honestly find this interesting. (You can "cheat" this using the reply links.)

Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by yosito on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @05:24PM (#17034233)
CMD+F unatt

I'm not gonna do your work for you.

Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by meowface on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @08:10PM (#17035441)
Most of these commenters don't appear to be whining about their situation, but rather replying to the question of why men in tech positions don't try to befriend more women. Their answer is that they're concerned about the optics of trying to initiate the friendship.

And by unattractive, they don't necessarily mean "ugly" but rather geeky, asocial, with niche interests, no fashion sense, little in common with most women, etc. It can be the way they carry themselves, their posture, the way they walk, the sound of their voice, stuttering, lack of vocal control... For someone like that with poor social skills and a lot of anxiety, it's not at all uncommon for a woman to misconstrue their efforts at friendship as a romantic overture or worse. It can also just be shyness due to inexperience interacting with women.

This is not necessarily the fault of the women; they likely do receive a lot of uncomfortable romantic overtures from socially awkward people like this. The commenters aren't placing blame on anyone, but describing the reality of their situation.

Some of the commenters have a rather rude and selfish attitude about it, but this is a genuine issue for a lot of men and explains part of the reason why some women in CS may feel isolated. If anything, I think people should try to have more empathy for this particular predicament, so that men and women can hopefully become more comfortable fostering professional and platonic relationships in the workplace.

Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by stcredzero on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @10:59PM (#17036085)
And by unattractive, they don't necessarily mean "ugly" but rather geeky, asocial, with niche interests, no fashion sense, little in common with most women, etc

Young men and women in their 20's usually don't have a very good self awareness of their own inherent attractiveness. There's that which Iain M. Banks termed, "the elegance of the newly matured." By that, I mean something which is natural, and of the natural world and natural beauty. That cat over there might have a slightly squished face and a weird toe, but hell, it's still a cat. You don't have to have much in common with women/men. Dress neatly and be well groomed. Genuinely have fun with something and genuinely be yourself. Do socialize, but don't limit yourself by thinking that bros or sociopaths need to rule your life. Do try dancing and see if you genuinely have fun with that. If you do, then know that it's very potent, but you have to be in the moment to let the real magic happen. Actually, that last part applies to everything else as well.

Most 20-somethings, males and females, are too mired in their preconceptions and their contention in the social hierarchy competition to have a full appreciation of their own natural beauty. (And often, each other's.)

Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by meowface on Thursday May 10, 2018 @12:03AM (#17036285)
That is easier said than done for people who have been struggling with social isolation, ostracization, loneliness, mockery, anxiety, awkwardness, zero self-esteem, an inability to relate, and little or no contact with the opposite sex for their entire lives. They don't know how to dress in a fashionable or appealing way. They probably don't know proper grooming beyond the basics. And even if they were to improve their physical appearance, many will likely still have a lot of difficulty carrying out normal social interactions (in the minds of others), especially with the opposite sex.

You say "genuinely be yourself", but many people are unable to be themselves without unintentionally and unknowingly creating aversion and discomfort in others.

Of course many of these people can and do improve themselves and gain a lot more confidence, but the reality is that in tech careers, they exist in large numbers and will continue to exist. Many will have experienced situations where a woman feels uncomfortable or threatened despite purely good and platonic/professional intentions. Many will choose to limit all interactions with women to a minimum as a result of this, if for no other reason than instinctive and learned fear.

And on the flip side, many women will probably have experienced romantic/sexual advances, stalking, and harassing behavior from awkward people like this (perhaps sometimes from people who don't realize they're coming across that way and sometimes from people who know exactly what they're doing), so they've been conditioned to have this reaction as well.

This is not to put blame on either party, but just to describe the reality of the situation and one of the potential reasons why women may feel less connected to their coworkers at such jobs. Many women also struggle with anxiety, awkwardness, isolation, and the other issues listed, but on average it tends to be less common and less severe than for men, especially in CS-type fields (as the article describes).

Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by stcredzero on Thursday May 10, 2018 @02:16AM (#17036774)
That is easier said than done for people who have been struggling with social isolation, ostracization, loneliness, mockery, anxiety, awkwardness, zero self-esteem, an inability to relate, and little or no contact with the opposite sex for their entire lives.

That would also have been me, to some extent. Many things that are worth doing have an element of challenge. Easier said than done.

They don't know how to dress in a fashionable or appealing way. They probably don't know proper grooming beyond the basics.

Those are big ones, and they are fairly easily fixed if you have the resources of a white collar worker. Isn't that what happens in those 80's movies? The awkward one gets cleaned up and turns out to be a hottie?

You say "genuinely be yourself", but many people are unable to be themselves without unintentionally and unknowingly creating aversion and discomfort in others.

This, too goes for just about everyone, to some extent. Dancing or some other kind of physical activity can help. The point isn't to let all of your guts spill out. The point is to get you out of yourself, without being artificially impaired. Being artificially impaired actually never actually helped me one iota. Not even Ecstasy, at least not in the long run. In terms of good relations between men and women, I think it largely hurts on US campuses.

Many women also struggle with anxiety, awkwardness, isolation, and the other issues listed

I dated one for most of a decade and asked her to marry me. She said no. Didn't end well. I would say, that finding a partner who is well adjusted pretty much trumps every other concern. The first well adjusted partner who you'd trust to save your life: I'd say one should marry her/him.

One last thing I'd say: Don't be a nihilist. I'm an atheist, but I would also say that I have a purpose driven life. Go and see enough of the world, so you know how both ugly and beautiful it can be -- until it brings you to tears. Then you will be able to find and live for some meaningful goal. Getting past nihilism can be a huge leg up on finding good relationships. (College aged women can sometimes mistake nihilism for depth, but for me, I was too psychically beat up to "benefit" from that.)

Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by stcredzero on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @06:35PM (#17034857)
I see. You, "won't do labor." Most of the time I see the phrase, it's not from good people. It's not like you can CMD-F a sentiment.

So, I just tried it, and I found exactly one match for "unatt" that fit the sentiment discussed from the 1st person. I only found one person who said he, personally, couldn't be friendly to women because he is unattractive. The rest are talking about people in general, and aren't necessarily attached to the ability to be friendly. From what I saw, the issue of being friendly with women is more attached to the problems of risk, and this risk is correlated with relative attractiveness.

Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by turingcompeteme on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @04:46PM (#17033912)
They didn't say rude, they mentioned empathy.

Julia Enthoven shared her experience as a Woman in tech, and this thread is filled with nitpicking, asking for sources, disagreement, alternate theories, debates, etc.

There is no empathy here. So I'll start:

Good for her for sharing her thoughts and experiences. It's a tough topic to talk about, and as we see here and elsewhere, people will immediately pick apart everything you say. Individual experiences like these are useful to read about for people like me who recognize that there is a problem but don't really know what to do about it. So thank you, Julia. I'm sorry it is such a difficult topic, but I hope you keep talking about this and that others are encouraged to do so as well.

Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by peoplewindow on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @04:54PM (#17033989)
That attitude doesn't help the cause of women in tech. It makes things worse.

Machines don't have empathy. They do not care about feelings. Code is harsh. So are professional code reviewers. Therefore if you're a programmer, you will in fact spend a lot of time dealing with nitpicking issues, finding sources for claims you make, debating alternative theories and so on.

If women can't even do that in debates they start then they should give up in being programmers. They won't make it and they won't get along with their colleagues.

I don't think they are incapable of such things, as I always get the impression posts like this one ("why can't you just respect her opinion") are actually written by men. But her compiler won't give her opinions automatic respect. Why should anyone else?

Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by yosito on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @05:23PM (#17034225)
Wow, please get that toxic attitude out of tech.
Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by arkis22 on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @04:53PM (#17033978)
What you're calling empathy can be rephrased as "you go girl!"

Not sure I'd call that empathy.

Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by mywittyname on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @05:07PM (#17034090)
There are lots of posts of this nature, but there's also many, many posts that give the other side of the story -- explaining why young men in this field don't engage with women.

So, I think there is a good deal of empathy here. We understand that women feel excluded and have offered insight into why they may be excluded, which in turn can help society figure out how to help the next generation overcome this.

Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by finnthehuman on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @11:58PM (#17036273)
>this thread is filled with nitpicking, asking for sources, disagreement, alternate theories, debates, etc.

Sounds fairly typical for a Hacker News thread on any topic.

Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by daenz on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @04:53PM (#17033976)
Another way to look at the comments is to look at the audience. HackerNews readers are typically hard problem solvers. They discuss theories and solutions, and can't be afraid of avoiding potential causes because they make people uncomfortable.

So while your post has empathy, it doesn't really push the solution-finding process forward in the way that other, more active (vs passive), posts do.

Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by yosito on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @05:21PM (#17034210)
You can't be sure you're offering a solution to the right problem if you haven't taken the time to empathize with what the problem is first.
Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by daenz on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @05:47PM (#17034465)
And passive empathy without action is pointless. How much data needs to be gathered before an action becomes clear? Should we all not take any action until then?
Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by yosito on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @07:11PM (#17035104)
I haven't seen any actions recommended. Just people nitpicking everything they think is wrong with a woman's opinion.
Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by peoplewindow on Thursday May 10, 2018 @09:13AM (#17038524)
Because the actions that would be obvious outcomes of the identified problems are pointless to suggest, they will never happen.

For example, a key issue identified in this discussion is the perceived career risk of being friends with women at work. Stories have been shared about harmless comments that came back to bite innocent men years later, or being described as creepy, and of course, we've all seen the string of high profile men losing their jobs based on mere tweets.

An obvious action that could address this is for women to stop collectively insisting that they never lie and that they should be able to shoot down the career of any man based on nothing more than a complaint to HR. But there is no sign this will happen, why would people give up such power.

Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by troupe on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @04:24PM (#17033689)
> men don't listen to or empathize with them when they speak about their opinions or perspectives.

The comments I've seen are on par with comments on other posts where the author was male. The fact that someone disagrees with the cause of some statistical result is not the same as not listening.

Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by yosito on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @04:46PM (#17033914)
I'm not talking about the comments that disagree with the hypothesis in the article. I disagree with it too. There's no statistical result being discussed in the article, but people are dismissing the author's opinion (saying things like she must be an outlier) and getting defensive about men's behavior (saying they have their reasons for how they act, like being unattractive).
Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by indoorfish on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @06:34PM (#17034847)
I would appreciate a bulleted list as to why my 5,5 mixed race frame is somehow unequal in engaging my coworker as another's 6,3 white mans. If it could completely explain how my careful quests for affection were dismissed, regarded as unwanted then maybe I would have more sympathy with direct, out of hand dismissals.
Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by forapurpose on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @05:08PM (#17034099)
> Pretend you're a woman and then read the comments on this post.

To carry your point a couple steps further, HN demonstrates the huge gender disparity in tech. Are there any women in this discussion? Even the parent assumes the reader is male, with good reason.

Most of the discussion is complaints about how hard it is for the commenter because of #metoo and other actions against sexual harassment and discrimination, and then other people agreeing. Imagine how different it would be if half the commenters were women.

Those voices are not only missing from HN, but probably from your workplace and classroom as well.

Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by hkmurakami on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @06:22PM (#17034741)
So far one person has self identified as female, and 2 or 3 commenters have provided anecdotes from their female SO.
Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by wieghant on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @05:24PM (#17034232)
HackerNews isn't really a place to wave a empathy stick at. This is a place where years of work on startups and concepts come to die. If you came to find yes men, this is sadly the wrong place. Having said that, there are an unusual lot of people empathizing and acknowledging the issue that women are more alienated and that we should fix that. There is a severe lack of empathy on the other side though that cannot seem to fathom why men heed cautionary tales and choose not to risk their career over fighting for equity.
Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by cwperkins on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @04:25PM (#17033704)
Seems to me like a lot of people in this comment section read the article before responding? One of the things I like about HN is that the commenters more respond to the content of the article rather than the headline.
Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by yosito on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @04:40PM (#17033858)
They read the article and then promptly dismissed it as a woman who doesn't know what she's talking about. I don't agree with the article, but I think we're too quick to dismiss the author's perspective and get defensive.
Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by gnulinux on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @06:27PM (#17034784)
But also maybe think from the perspective of men when all throughout your life all your attempts to socialize with women were quickly labelled as "creepy" and it's very easy and comforting to ignore socializing with them. I would never discriminate against a women coworker, I do perfectly fine communicating with my female coworkers professionally, and I cannot see anything ethically wrong with what I'm doing. But it's simply too hard to properly socialize with women. I don't get mad at people when they don't learn something I find fascinating like automated theorem proving, and it drives me crazy when my friends get mad at me for not learning how to socialize with women. It really is not the end of the world.
Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by Zarath on Thursday May 10, 2018 @01:26PM (#17041008)
Why doesn't she try empathizing with men before basically telling us that it's our problem and that we need to change? If women are so much more "pro-social" than men, maybe they need to use their skills to fix the problem, instead of "anti-social" men going and trying to fix the problem.
Re:A female engineer's opinion on why there are fewer women ... by dang on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @11:11PM (#17036122)
It's a problem for HN if the threads fill up with disgruntled comments, but it doesn't say much about the world at large, because of sample bias. People are more motivated to comment if they feel strongly about something, especially strongly negatively. Here that means they've self-selected for the quality you're talking about.

Fortunately we're also getting comments from men who enjoy talking to women at work (shock!) and don't have an ideology about it. Those comments take longer to appear because they only emerge as a reaction to the first kind of comment. Why would you bother to post such a thing unless some other comment denied it?