News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by scrollaway on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @01:55PM (#17023015)
So why exactly are people suddenly up in arms about this?

How's it different from opening up your android phone and using google's spellcheck, with algorithms that predict your next word when you're typing?

Never seen such atrociously negative comments to what's essentially a cool feature you can disable.

PS: How many of the outraged people here are actually voting with their wallet and paying for something like Fastmail? (https://www.fastmail.com)

Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by dmazin on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @02:05PM (#17023114)
Two big problems.

One, AI mediation of language sees issues like bias amplification (AI learns our biases then suggests them back to us). Google itself wrote about this recently [1].

Two, spell check has a homogenizing effect on spelling [2]. If you extend this to the level of phrases, that will homogenize not just spelling but the very way we talk.

[1] https://developers.googleblog.com/2018/04/text-embedding-mod...

[2] https://www.nature.com/articles/srep00313#references

Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by peatmoss on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @02:18PM (#17023268)
To add a third, I have a problem with my personal emails being used as a corpus of text to train these models.

Maybe they're using only my emails to train a model for me, and turning that feature off disables them doing so. Maybe they're using everyone's email to train a generic model.

Of course, they've been (machine) reading your emails to provide ads since forever, so in that sense maybe this isn't really that new. That said, many people habituated to email reading for ads back when Google's brand image was riding higher.

Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by prlambert on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @03:17PM (#17023880)
We're training Smart Compose from highly anonymized global corpus of consumer email.

We've stopped using emails for Ad targeting entirely, and the enforcement is quite strict, as reported in June: https://www.nytimes.com/2017/06/23/technology/gmail-ads.html

Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by peatmoss on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @04:19PM (#17024596)
> highly anonymized global corpus of consumer email.

I read this as confirmation that, if I were a Gmail customer, that you would indeed be using my personal emails to train your models.

For me, I then have to wonder what "highly anonymized" means in this context. Does this means that users' emails are put through yet another processing pipeline to separate emails into anonymous / not-anonymous buckets or to redact personally identifying information?

Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by gone35 on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @07:28PM (#17026264)
[H]ighly anonymized global corpus of consumer email.

What do you mean by "highly anonymized"? What specific privacy notion are you using, and what is the (demonstrably unavoidable) tradeoff you are de facto threading between utility and privacy?

Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by jedberg on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @03:43PM (#17024166)
You don't have an email in your profile, so I'm just gonna hijack this comment. :)

I can't enable smart compose. My general tab doesn't have "Enable experiments" at the bottom. Is this getting rolled out in phases?

I logged out and logged back in just in case, but no dice.

My email is in my profile if you need it. Thanks!

Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by prlambert on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @04:06PM (#17024430)
Rolling out over the course of the day. We'll be at 100% in a couple hours. Thanks for your patience. :)
Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by jedberg on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @04:23PM (#17024645)
Sweet, thanks! I'll just keep hitting reload till I see it. ;)
Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by dmazin on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @02:21PM (#17023296)
Yup, I forgot where I read this, but I believe all Gmails are eligible for the model. Again, forgot where I saw this, but Google takes great precaution to protect your data from human inspection, but being used in the corpus is fair game.
Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by peatmoss on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @02:25PM (#17023342)
I think if you are a (paid?) enterprise user, they do not do this.

On the other hand, sussing out what is and is not fair game is quite a lot easier with a service such as Fastmail.

Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by scrollaway on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @02:30PM (#17023407)
Doesn't have to be "enterprise". Anyone can pay $5/mo for GSuite (https://gsuite.google.com), which includes gmail and a ton of other tools. Furthermore, it's on your own domain rather than @gmail.com, which is not only better (you truly own the email address), it's also a hell of a lot more professional and makes it easier to migrate to other services if you wish to.

To put it bluntly, if anyone here is complaining and has an @gmail.com address, email me and I'll be happy to help you buy your own domain and create MX records to either gsuite or fastmail. But I just can't hear the empty negativity anymore from consumers who say "no! bad google!", yet, by using the free product, keep making their emails available for the AI models and keep signaling to Google that an advertising business model works better than a paid-per-user one.

Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by Bucephalus355 on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @10:14PM (#17026982)
Why can’t I buy gmail and just use regular @gmail? Would love all the features of GSuite, but a custom domain name I would pay even more to avoid. Unless you’re running a business, it looks bizarre. For some in the development industry / those who write technical blogs I can imagine that being useful at times, but still......
Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by scrollaway on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @09:35AM (#17029649)
Go to https://gandi.net and buy a domain name you like with your name in it. I recommend something with your last name. <lastname>.me is a good one, or something more clever if you like.

It doesn't look bizarre, trust me. It looks extremely professional. Even on CVs, this alone will get you past some filters. And the domain name is $5-10 USD / year, it's nothing.

Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by dannyw on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @03:51AM (#17028089)
Get a personal domain name, e.g. "[email protected]" if your name is Taylor Bushinka.

With @gmail.com, you have lock in. With @yourdomain.com, you don't.

Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by CamelCaseName on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @12:38AM (#17027441)
I've been meaning to do this for ages. Thanks to you, I just did.

https://i.imgur.com/wXkPYXs.png

Let me know if you have any tips for getting the most out of my new subscription!

Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by scrollaway on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @11:16AM (#17030457)
Congrats!

Go to https://admin.google.com - there's a lot of cool stuff you can do there that isn't usually possible in a regular Gmail account, including for example recovering emails and drive files up to 3-4 weeks after they've been deleted.

Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by peatmoss on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @04:22PM (#17024633)
That's a generous offer, and one that I'd echo. If anyone is unsure where to start, or wants some advice, I'll be glad to help you with domain registration and email hosting MX record setup.
Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by njarboe on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @02:33PM (#17023439)
I don't think this is true. When our large university switched to gmail, all I could find was that they said they would not use our emails for targeting advertising. Seems like that leaves a lot of other possibilities like profile creation (they just won't use it to target ad at you), machine learning of all types, cross correlation with my personal email for who knows what, etc.
Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by prlambert on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @03:18PM (#17023897)
Paid domains can choose if they want us to use their data for training. Many do since it improves the quality of features they receive.
Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by prlambert on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @03:17PM (#17023883)
This is correct.
Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by ForHackernews on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @06:39PM (#17025955)
Don't use Gmail if you don't want Google reading your mail?
Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by peatmoss on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @02:03PM (#17023095)
I'm a paying Fastmail user. I switched over after they (EDIT: Gmail) started announcing compatibility-breaking features. Processing my emails to suggest content is one of a litany of reasons that I'm glad to have switched my email to Fastmail.

In this particular case, I think people are (probably rightly) concerned about how the machine learning models here are used to suggest content. I would guess that most of the people who are unconcerned with the Android keyboard's privacy model either haven't thought too much about it, or have come to accept it in small increments.

Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by _bxg1 on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @02:06PM (#17023125)
At this point the only reason I haven't ditched Gmail is because that's the email address I've used everywhere. Changing email addresses is even more problematic than changing physical addresses these days.

The reason people are so upset is that it has a negative effect on the world even if people have the option to turn it off (and don't), and it has virtually no real benefit. It's the latest in the trend of tech companies trying to solve problems that don't exist, and creating new ones in the process.

At best, you'll never know if the person on the other end of the line outsourced their response to Google. At worst, people's mental capacity for expression and nuance will start to atrophy because they couldn't be bothered to manually relate to another human being.

Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by peatmoss on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @02:10PM (#17023169)
I've recommended it elsewhere in similar threads, but a nice middle ground between self-hosted email (lots of work), and a straight-up Gmail/Yahoo/Fastmail/Hotmail/Etc account is to buy your own domain and set up your MX records in accordance with Fastmail's (or whoever's) instructions.

I've ported my email address / domain across several hosting providers now. I don't have to retrain anyone.

Obviously this doesn't help you now, but maybe you can start training people on to your new [email protected] email address to avoid this problem in the hypothetical future when Fastmail becomes dystopian and gross.

Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by toomuchtodo on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @02:17PM (#17023256)
The best time to start using your own domain for email was 10 years ago. The second best time is today.
Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by ocdtrekkie on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @02:17PM (#17023257)
Get your own domain, set up an email forwarder on it that points to your Gmail, and start shifting your contacts and accounts over to it. Then if down the road, you decide you want to switch, most of the work will already be done. I spent about 18 months on Gmail using my own domain before I switched to FastMail, and it made the transition much less painful.
Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by brlewis on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @02:09PM (#17023159)
I think HNers are overestimating the amount of thought people put into composing emails absent this feature.
Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by Invictus0 on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @02:10PM (#17023171)
How many times does it take for people to understand that incremental "cool" features are exactly what leads to a dystopian future? Facebook added one cool feature after another until suddenly people realized that Facebook knew everything about you; only then were people alarmed. This is so obviously, blatantly terrible it's beyond belief that anyone could be in support of this. It's literally bending the way you think to fit more closely into a form field, rounding out the edges on human interaction. Do you really think that most people will take the additional time to write out their real thoughts, or just go with the autogenerated approximation? Just wait until you start typing "can you go to the supermarket and pick up" and the thing suggests Doritos, because that's exactly where this is going.
Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by scrollaway on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @02:19PM (#17023274)
Are you seriously not seeing the difference between [human] giving information to [company], versus [company] making a suggestion to [human]?

I never liked Facebook; I never thought any of Facebook's cool features made up for their creepy business model. I do like Google and Google Mail because I pay for the service and the relationship is extremely different. But that's outside the point anyway. You're giving information to the company by simply using gmail (receiving and sending emails through gmail). Autocomplete is a feature that doesn't gather information (at best a yes/no)...

Seriously, wtf is dystopian about autocomplete? Do you write your code in nano or something?

And how much thought do you put into an email anyway? Outside of development ones, all my emails are extremely standard (the few times I even bother sending any). I won't use this for development emails. What is the problem?

Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by fabatka on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @10:32AM (#17030108)
I never understood the need for autocorrect or even spellchecking if I'm not writing a report or anything official. Am I a luddite for thinking that there are a lot of technologies that provide very superficial improvements to our lives while opening the possibility for serious problems (see other comment on parent about incremental changes that may be not harmful by themselves)?
Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by scrollaway on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @10:49AM (#17030244)
A report, anything official, anything professional, or really anywhere you don't want to appear to make typos left and right.

Furthermore, if you're dyslexic, autocorrect is essentially assistive technology.

Now, do I need autocorrect when I'm texting my mom? No, I don't, but that doesn't mean I want to be turning it on/off every time I switch context. What harm does it do by staying on? Hide my true nature as a poor speller?

I'll let you in on a secret: My handwriting looks like shit. Digital text has allowed me, for the past two decades, to hide my true nature as a shitty handwriter.

Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by ocdtrekkie on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @02:05PM (#17023116)
I pay for FastMail. Voted with my wallet two years ago.

If I get any impression someone is writing me messages with this feature, I'll filter them into my trash. I want to speak to people, not Google.

Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by scrollaway on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @02:08PM (#17023148)
I got news for you, a large chunk of the HN userbase is on mobile and has been using predictive keyboard input for years.

A large chunk of people on the internet, in fact.

You're speaking to robots right now.

Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by astura on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @02:13PM (#17023206)
>If I get any impression someone is writing me messages with this feature, I'll filter them into my trash. I want to speak to people, not Google.

This seems like an extreme overreaction and quite antisocial.

Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by typomatic on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @06:12PM (#17025739)
Sending me robot-generated messages is quite antisocial!
Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by joshuamorton on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @07:45PM (#17026341)
See scrollaway's response above. A lot of the text you already read is robot-generated. More than half the words in this comment were generated via autocorrect or auto complete in some fashion. It's still useful and thoughtful though.
Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by typomatic on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @04:15PM (#17033590)
> A lot of the text you already read is robot-generated. More than half the words in this comment were generated via autocorrect or auto complete in some fashion. It's still useful and thoughtful though.

Just to be clear, I don't find these things reassuring, it just makes me think you don't care about communicating very much. Please accept that some people find machine-generated communication to be gross and don't want to be subjected to it, whether or not you understand.

Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by joshuamorton on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @04:30PM (#17033740)
On the other hand, I care about communicating so much that I want to focus solely on the thoughts, not the form. So I defer the form (such as spelling and completing phrases) to a tool, so that I can focus on the content. This is essentially the same thing that writing tools like Hemingway do. They force you to focus on content, whereas autocomplete lets you focus on content.

Saying you don't want to be subjected to machine generated communication to me says that you don't want to read anything written in the past 10 or so years. Practically everything written in that time frame is in some way machine generated or edited.

Like I said, just because something is in part machine generated doesn't make it not thoughtful.

Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by ocdtrekkie on Thursday May 10, 2018 @12:40AM (#17036425)
I think trying to suggest spellcheck and your email client writing sentences for you as the same thing is incredibly disingenuous. One fixes the content, one generates it.
Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by joshuamorton on Thursday May 10, 2018 @12:13PM (#17040213)
I'm suggesting that autocomplete of words and autocomplete of short phrases aren't substantively different, yes. Especially given that a lot of mobile keyboards already essentially do this.

I can type "I" and then my phone's keyboard will suggest "be there at" as the phrase completion it does this a single word at a time, but in practice it does let me complete a phrase. If I don't want to say that, I'm capable of not using the autocomplete suggestions. There's no substantive difference with Smart Compose except that I don't have to confirm between every word, so its slightly more efficient.

I'm not sure what you think smart compose is doing, but "writing sentences for you" isn't it.[1] So no, I think you're either misunderstanding what this is, or perhaps you're being disingenuous by describing it as something that writes sentences for you.

[1]: Granted given the Duplex demo and other work in the NLP space, I expect that in certain contexts a tool that given an instruction like "set up a meeting with John this week" that schedules it over emails (like x.ai[2], which has been around for quite some time) is totally possible, but Smart Compose isn't it.

[2]: https://x.ai/

Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by typomatic on Friday May 11, 2018 @01:27PM (#17049194)
> I want to focus solely on the thoughts, not the form.

I think this is a dangerously stupid way to think about linguistics.

Re:Write Emails Faster with Smart Compose in Gmail by joshuamorton on Friday May 11, 2018 @01:34PM (#17049267)
I mean in certain contexts absolutely. I certainly wouldn't use smart compose to write a novel, but then I don't think it would be very helpful for creative writing where or writing where my focus is on tone.

But for otherwise mechanical things ("hey can we set up a meeting tomorrow", "do you want to grab lunch at ____ today"), the form is mostly irrelevant. It's the kind of thing where if we weren't in a formal context, I'd write as "hey u wanna grab fud at ____ later". I'm not losing anything by having a tool formalize that to "Hey do you want to eat lunch at ____ today." Again, we already do that a lot. As far as I can tell, this is just doing that a bit faster.