News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On Britain's Intellectual Decline by mistermann on Monday May 07, 2018 @02:31PM (#17015158)
My perception is that unlike in the past, a huge percentage of the population in modern Western democracies believe things that most everyone used to consider matters of opinion, are now considered matters of fact and should not even be subject to a public debate.

Canada is currently going through this on the topic of immigration - we are starting to experience significant issues with housing costs and economic inequality (both are directly affected my immigration to a degree), but many people considering any opinion not consistent with the status quo to be literally racist. And unsurprisingly, you rarely can find one that will defend their beliefs, at best you will just get general dishonesty and never ending changing of the subject.

I think this new culture is going to have some very serious negative long term effects.

EDIT: Out of curiosity, which part are people disagreeing with here? That political views are more polarized? The inflationary housing prices claim? Inflationary housing prices not being reflected at all in CPI? Whether immigration has an effect at all on wages or real estate prices? That the word racist is commonly used to quash dissent (heck, even our mayor is on record doing it)? That people won't defend these racist charges? That any of this has changed? That these changes, assuming it is true, will have an effect?

Re:On Britain's Intellectual Decline by icebraining on Monday May 07, 2018 @04:14PM (#17016109)
I didn't downvote you, but maybe those who did think it's not relevant to the conversation, and/or that it may provoke a flamewar.
Re:On Britain's Intellectual Decline by AnimalMuppet on Monday May 07, 2018 @04:36PM (#17016279)
I thought it was off-topic to my statement, but not completely irrelevant to the topic of "intellectual decline". And, while it might provoke a flamewar, it was not stated in a flame-bait fashion.

I wonder if this isn't just downvote-to-disagree by people who won't "defend their beliefs". (And thereby proving mistermann's point - ironic, that.)

Re:On Britain's Intellectual Decline by mistermann on Monday May 07, 2018 @05:45PM (#17016726)
downvote-to-disagree is (or was) explicitly ok according to HN guidelines, so that's why I asked WHY the downvoters disagree. Are the things I wrote not factual (interestingly, this is the inverse of my above complaint...former matters of opinion are now considered matter of fact, but also things that were previously objectively factual are now "considered" matters of opinion)? I've been scolded for not being agreeable, should people who downvote facts not also get a talking to?

As for whether it might start a flame war....well, that is my ongoing concern, that free speech, or more specifically certain opinions are no longer tolerated, or even more specifically, you can say something (unacceptable) once, but if someone disagrees with you, any reply is considered "argumentative" or "not appropriate behavior".

Perhaps I'm completely wrong on some of my beliefs. Personally, I enthusiastically encourage people to disagree with me or challenge my ideas, it wasn't so long ago that this was considered admirable for a variety of very good reasons. When people start believing their ideas are beyond challenge, to me that seems like the sort of thing that's dangerous.