Re:On Britain's Intellectual Decline
by mistermann on Monday May 07, 2018 @05:45PM
(#17016726)
downvote-to-disagree is (or was) explicitly ok according to HN guidelines, so that's why I asked WHY the downvoters disagree. Are the things I wrote not factual (interestingly, this is the inverse of my above complaint...former matters of opinion are now considered matter of fact, but also things that were previously objectively factual are now "considered" matters of opinion)? I've been scolded for not being agreeable, should people who downvote facts not also get a talking to?
As for whether it might start a flame war....well, that is my ongoing concern, that free speech, or more specifically certain opinions are no longer tolerated, or even more specifically, you can say something (unacceptable) once, but if someone disagrees with you, any reply is considered "argumentative" or "not appropriate behavior".
Perhaps I'm completely wrong on some of my beliefs. Personally, I enthusiastically encourage people to disagree with me or challenge my ideas, it wasn't so long ago that this was considered admirable for a variety of very good reasons. When people start believing their ideas are beyond challenge, to me that seems like the sort of thing that's dangerous.
As for whether it might start a flame war....well, that is my ongoing concern, that free speech, or more specifically certain opinions are no longer tolerated, or even more specifically, you can say something (unacceptable) once, but if someone disagrees with you, any reply is considered "argumentative" or "not appropriate behavior".
Perhaps I'm completely wrong on some of my beliefs. Personally, I enthusiastically encourage people to disagree with me or challenge my ideas, it wasn't so long ago that this was considered admirable for a variety of very good reasons. When people start believing their ideas are beyond challenge, to me that seems like the sort of thing that's dangerous.