Re:The Zeroth Commandment
by amluto on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @02:06PM
(#17023127)
> I hold the bodily autonomy of women ... to be my Zeroth Commandment, the foundation-stone of my moral worldview, the starting point of every action I take and every thought I think
If I were to choose a personal Zeroth Commandment along these lines, I would, at the very least, hold the bodily autonomy of everyone to be important.
(Of course, the bodily autonomy of women is more often violated than that of men, but that doesn't mean that one should fail to respect the bodily autonomy of men or of non-binary folks.)
Re:The Zeroth Commandment
by ardent_uno on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @02:31AM
(#17019226)
The author impressively found a tremendous amount to say about a topic that I think is a bit trivial.
Of course we should feel bad for people, both men and women, who cannot fulfill their sexual desires, for whatever reason.
This is not a radical thought. That the author does such an elaborate dance around this simple statement seems unnecessary to me.
The comparison to people who are financially impoverished is a legitimate one.
Just because there is no "good" solution to severe sexual frustration - no solution that preserves the autonomy of desired yet unwilling sexual partners - does not mean we are prohibited from feeling compassion and sympathy.
Re:The Zeroth Commandment
by ardent_uno on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @01:50PM
(#17022954)
Definitely. I'm not one to chant "legalize and regulate" at every vice in society, but this is one case where we should most definitely legalize and regulate.
When I said there was no good solution I was thinking more for people who want sex without paying for it.
Re:The Zeroth Commandment
by lifeformed on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @02:02PM
(#17023088)
Well, the article isn't just about that, but also about modern discourse style and mediums that prevents hard topics from being constructively discussed.
> two Bayesian agents with a common prior can ensure that they agree to within ±ε about the value of a [0,1]-valued random variable, with probability at least 1-δ over their shared prior, by exchanging only O(1/(δε2)) bits of information—completely independent of how much knowledge the agents have. My conclusion was that, if Aumann’s Nobel-prizewinning theorem fails to demonstrate the irrationality of real-life disagreements, then it’s not for reasons of computational or communication efficiency
Under the gracious assumption that your agents are implementing a reasonable protocol for information exchange :)
Re:The Zeroth Commandment
by AstralStorm on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @07:17AM
(#17020145)
You have to extend the Bayesian thought experiment to include agents not behaving rationally and cases of bounded information. And then go to multivariate models.
Combined, these give robust decision making methods. However, none of the above concerns actual hypothesis making which is biased from the get go.
Bayesian statistics cannot answer the question of how to build hypotheses, only maybe how to value them. Sometimes.
If we solve the question of how to make hypotheses reliably, then we might have some angle of attack on the strong AI problem.
Related problem is deciding ways to falsify statements - inverse Bayesian reasoning. That is, given posterior probability, figure out potential priors.
Re:The Zeroth Commandment
by jl2718 on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @01:22PM
(#17022687)
Is there not a positive aspect of the ‘Commandment’, that a person is free to do with their body as they wish, so long as it does not violate the sanctity and dignity and peaceful experience of another, nor violate or deny rights to property. Would this not include the use and free exchange thereof for labor and profit? Is it exploitive of men to pay them to perform feats of strength, or of the intellectually gifted to pay them for their ability to solve problems? Or is it a right for every person on earth to leverage their unique talents toward profitable exchange, and use that profit for satisfaction of needs which they are less endowed to serve for themselves?
This is not a new question. The solution is ‘the oldest in the world’.
Re:The Zeroth Commandment
by kup0 on Wednesday May 09, 2018 @05:01PM
(#17034045)
I read through the comments on that post, and goodness, the fact that someone (especially supposedly a Berkeley professor) can seriously hold the views espoused at length in comment #49 just boggles my brain
If I were to choose a personal Zeroth Commandment along these lines, I would, at the very least, hold the bodily autonomy of everyone to be important.
(Of course, the bodily autonomy of women is more often violated than that of men, but that doesn't mean that one should fail to respect the bodily autonomy of men or of non-binary folks.)
1) He writes a long blog post about problems that men have, specifically, and how there is unfair treatment between sexes.
2) He also writes explicitly that bodily autonomy of women is so important to him, it might as well be called holy.
3) He has had his son circumcised.
Any two out of these three positions i could understand. All three together are... hard to rationalize.
Of course we should feel bad for people, both men and women, who cannot fulfill their sexual desires, for whatever reason.
This is not a radical thought. That the author does such an elaborate dance around this simple statement seems unnecessary to me.
The comparison to people who are financially impoverished is a legitimate one.
Just because there is no "good" solution to severe sexual frustration - no solution that preserves the autonomy of desired yet unwilling sexual partners - does not mean we are prohibited from feeling compassion and sympathy.
When I said there was no good solution I was thinking more for people who want sex without paying for it.
Under the gracious assumption that your agents are implementing a reasonable protocol for information exchange :)
Combined, these give robust decision making methods. However, none of the above concerns actual hypothesis making which is biased from the get go.
Bayesian statistics cannot answer the question of how to build hypotheses, only maybe how to value them. Sometimes.
If we solve the question of how to make hypotheses reliably, then we might have some angle of attack on the strong AI problem.
Related problem is deciding ways to falsify statements - inverse Bayesian reasoning. That is, given posterior probability, figure out potential priors.
This is not a new question. The solution is ‘the oldest in the world’.