News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla reviewing contractors, firing everyone not vouched ... by woodpanel on Monday May 07, 2018 @12:31AM (#17010411)
Having driven Fords, GMs and a Tesla, I'd say GM isn't international standard either, but Ford is definitely.
Re:Tesla reviewing contractors, firing everyone not vouched ... by nitrogen on Monday May 07, 2018 @02:06AM (#17010684)
In terms of driving experience, most Ford cars I've driven (Contour, Focus, and Taurus, probably all from early 2000s; they are probably better now) handle like boats; turning radius comparable to an oil tanker, unresponsive brakes and gas, etc. So there are tradeoffs among all makes and models within those makes.
Re:Tesla reviewing contractors, firing everyone not vouched ... by doikor on Monday May 07, 2018 @02:29AM (#17010747)
All the things you mentioned are design decisions not build quality related.
Re:Tesla reviewing contractors, firing everyone not vouched ... by fsloth on Monday May 07, 2018 @05:20AM (#17011338)
Weeelll... given that a modern car is a complex dynamic system I would presume it's not to trivial to state where exactly design constraints concerning build quality end and dynamics and handling start.

For the end user they both affect the 'feel' of the product - how it behaves on the detail level when in use. "I have a door I have a hard time closing" and "the dynamics feel a bit clumsy" deal with totally different things on the engineering level, but end users (generally) are not buying engineering but holistic products.

Namely, concerning this comment: Are there compromises made on the design of the handling to facilitate the build quality? And if there are, then those are not two different things, but systems which interact - hence, it's relevant to offer commentary on one while discussing the other.

Re:Tesla reviewing contractors, firing everyone not vouched ... by taneq on Monday May 07, 2018 @08:20AM (#17012141)
> it's not to trivial to state where exactly design constraints concerning build quality end and dynamics and handling start

Maybe I'm being overly simplistic here but I'd say if the finished product doesn't match the design then it's a build quality issue, whereas if it does match the design and it's still crap then that's a design issue.

Arguably if they end product doesn't match the design because the design isn't feasible to manufacture then that would also be a design issue.

Re:Tesla reviewing contractors, firing everyone not vouched ... by Retric on Monday May 07, 2018 @08:32AM (#17012198)
Unless the design is limited by build quality issues. The AK-47 is perhaps the most famous example, but most designs are a back and forth around the manufacturing process.
Re:Tesla reviewing contractors, firing everyone not vouched ... by woodpanel on Tuesday May 08, 2018 @01:21AM (#17018985)
This is exactly what I've meant.

Ford doesn't compete with Land Rover, Mercedes and BMWs but deliver a good value-for-money nonetheless. Compare that to a Cadillac Escalade from GM: Worse quality than a Ford, priced at Mercedes level.

Re:Tesla reviewing contractors, firing everyone not vouched ... by cptskippy on Monday May 07, 2018 @10:35AM (#17013040)
I've never driven a modern for F Series but I have driven most of their Sedans and I can understand why they're withdrawing them from the US market. They're quite bad.

We took a road trip from Poughkeepsie to Niagra in a rented Ford Focus. It had a USB charge port in the center console that came out when we went to unplug the cable. This got me prodding about at the rest of the interior and most of it was too easily removable with my bare hands. It was scary to think who the whole passenger compartment might just explode in your lap with an accident.

I know many parts of the car are held together with retention clips and other tool-less mechanical fasteners but this Ford was exceptional. I don't know if it was down too the poor materials quality or the shoddy engineering of the fasteners but everything could be pulled apart with astonishingly little effort.

Re:Tesla reviewing contractors, firing everyone not vouched ... by justinclift on Monday May 07, 2018 @11:30AM (#17013489)
Wonder if that means it should be easily repairable? :)
Re:Tesla reviewing contractors, firing everyone not vouched ... by theandrewbailey on Monday May 07, 2018 @12:47PM (#17014220)
Maybe, but that would violate the DMCA. :P
Re:Tesla reviewing contractors, firing everyone not vouched ... by WalterSear on Monday May 07, 2018 @02:14PM (#17014999)
And good luck finding the proprietary parts. My friends motorcycle displays used encrypted handshakes to connect to the rest of the engine - ostensibly to prevent theft, but incidentally delivering lock-in.