News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Subscription Hell by lajhsdfkl on Sunday May 06, 2018 @01:49PM (#17007369)
People need to understand that the alternative to ads is paying hundreds of dollars a month in subscription fees and then still not having access to all the services you would have had access to in an ad economy world.

People in Europe will soon get this wakeup call. Services that were only marginally profitable are already shutting down because of GDPR.

I'm confident that the EU government and its citizens have little idea of the consequences that will result from their privacy legislation.

Re:Subscription Hell by banishwashtub on Sunday May 06, 2018 @09:03PM (#17009671)
Thing is, ads don't have to track users as individuals or at all. TV ads and print media ads are based on the content, why can't web based ads also be based on content? No more GDPR issues, we still get free content. Perhaps we can still do a pay-to-remove-ads option.
Re:Subscription Hell by tonyedgecombe on Sunday May 06, 2018 @03:48PM (#17008104)
Honestly, I don't think it would be a great loss to forgo most of the advertising funded content.
Re:Subscription Hell by lajhsdfkl on Sunday May 06, 2018 @04:15PM (#17008260)
>Honestly, I don't think it would be a great loss to forgo most of the advertising funded content.

Since you clearly haven't put much thought into this comment let's just start listing things that are funded by ads

- News

- content creators on youtube

- music

- twitch

- search

- blogs

- websites with tutorials

- a thousand different things which I have missed

and then facebook, snapchat, instagram, and twitter which of course you are too good for

Re:Subscription Hell by wott on Sunday May 06, 2018 @09:20PM (#17009732)
- News

Best TV and radio channels across the globe are government channels, funded by tax.

- content creators on youtube & twitch

99,99% dispensable trash.

- music

Music funded by ads???

- search

The only point that holds in your list. Could perfectly be funded by ISPs as part of our Internet subscription.

- blogs & websites with tutorials

No need for funding. Cost to setup is zero (provided by ISP) or close to zero (basic hosting or domain name registering).

Re:Subscription Hell by lajhsdfkl on Sunday May 06, 2018 @09:33PM (#17009780)
>- content creators on youtube & twitch

>99,99% dispensable trash.

Yes, the thousands of tutorials/guides and content that people enjoy watching is trash. Everything that I don't find agreeable is trash.

>No need for funding. Cost to setup is zero (provided by ISP) or close to zero (basic hosting or domain name registering).

Yes, no need to give people money for work they do.

Do you have any respect for the work that goes into the content you read and or watch every day? Or do you think people should just be content volunteering their effort for no reward?

>The only point that holds in your list. Could perfectly be funded by ISPs as part of our Internet subscription.

Yes. Perfectly. Let's just tack on another $50 a month. Or are you actually suggesting that ISPs should just do it out of their good will?

Re:Subscription Hell by AlexandrB on Monday May 07, 2018 @07:58AM (#17012031)
> - content creators on youtube

I only watch ad-free videos from content creators I fund on Patreon. I'm sick of Youtube's shitty advertising - it's as bad as TV when I was young, right down to running terrible political attack ads when I'm trying to take my mind off politics.

> - music

I don't think this is funded by ads. It's funded by VC dollars, since just about every streaming site is losing money right now. More to the point, my musical tastes are pretty eclectic so I usually have to buy Vinyl/CDs to get the music I want.

Re:Subscription Hell by dnomad on Monday May 07, 2018 @01:08AM (#17010523)
BTW, I agree, but I think the opposite is the case. I strongly suspect that in fact we'll see more content as the ad economy collapses. People don't understand just how much content is driven without ads for other reasons (like HN itself) and once more and more content gets locked behind subscription walls that indeed opens the door for free content to thrive. Combine this with strong, pervasive ad blocking and what you have is a recipe for the return of the free web.
Re:Subscription Hell by philwelch on Sunday May 06, 2018 @09:52PM (#17009850)
Most of those are covered by either subscription models or Patreon. Some of them (news, blogs, tutorials) can, like Wikipedia, be funded with non-profit models.
Re:Subscription Hell by paulific on Sunday May 06, 2018 @06:35PM (#17009012)
Well there are genuinely people out there who don't use the content. Our attitudes to media and who should be watching what haven't changed much from the broadcast era. "I'm not one Facebook" is the new "I don't watch TV.
Re:Subscription Hell by lajhsdfkl on Sunday May 06, 2018 @07:47PM (#17009333)
I'm sure there are but that has nothing to do with my point.

Anyway, I personally never use facebook because it is not something I find interesting. Do I feel pride in that fact? No I don't because I have an equally harmful relationship with reddit and hackernews. I always have to laugh when I see people state as a point of pride how they have deleted their facebook accounts on different social networks. If anything I think reddit and hackernews could be worse because I'm ingesting unfiltered opinions from random strangers.

Re:Subscription Hell by scarface74 on Sunday May 06, 2018 @10:18PM (#17009947)
For tutorials, I pay $30 a month for a PluralSight subscription, $12-$20 for the occasional Udemy video and watch vendor supplied tutorials from Amazon and Microsoft.

I hate ads for video content. I pay for Netflix and ad free Hulu. I use Plex for ad free content from CBS and the CW via by subscribing to the channels. It’s more ad blocking then piracy. Plex scrapes the content from the networks’ website real time and transcodes it and streams it.

I pay for Apple Music and before that iTunes.

I would pay for a high quality news source, I use to pay for WSJ.

Re:Subscription Hell by lajhsdfkl on Sunday May 06, 2018 @11:49PM (#17010285)
> For tutorials, I pay $30 a month for a PluralSight subscription, $12-$20 for the occasional Udemy video and watch vendor supplied tutorials from Amazon and Microsoft

Good for you that you can afford that. We all know the dream of the internet was information gated behind pay walls only accessible by the well off.

Re:Subscription Hell by tonyedgecombe on Monday May 07, 2018 @02:49AM (#17010800)
Since you clearly haven't put much thought into this comment

Sorry, did I say something to offend you?

Re:Subscription Hell by rahoulb on Sunday May 06, 2018 @01:58PM (#17007419)
Maybe if the service is only marginally profitable without acting unethically it should shut down.
Re:Subscription Hell by lajhsdfkl on Sunday May 06, 2018 @02:03PM (#17007454)
Showing ads is unethical now?

>Maybe if the service is only marginally profitable without acting unethically it should shut down.

Also I love this neo puritan thinking. I'm sure all the users of these services agree with your ideology and you forcing it down their throats is for their own good correct?

Re:Subscription Hell by Sylos on Sunday May 06, 2018 @03:02PM (#17007797)
No, tracking is unethical, which most ads rely on.

And yes, it is for their own good to not have thousands of databases with their data littered across the internet.

I know, this is not a very American way of thinking, but no one can be an expert at everything. Most people are not experts at computers and even less can grasp the outreach and effects of their data being everywhere.

These people need help just as much as the average guy needs assistance with doctors. If they knew enough to tell when a doctor is bullshitting them, they could probably become a doctor, too.

Re:Subscription Hell by lajhsdfkl on Sunday May 06, 2018 @03:41PM (#17008052)
>And yes, it is for their own good to not have thousands of databases with their data littered across the internet.

"With their data". Aka whether or not they liked a group pertaining to motorcycles or whether they searched for fishing rods on google. Yeah, we definitely need to shut off what is the most consumer friendly way of monetizing services in history so that a database of inane shit that is only relevant to marketers isn't tracked.

Re:Subscription Hell by Sylos on Sunday May 06, 2018 @11:49PM (#17010287)
Well, it's not only relevant to marketers. Your two most innocent examples are not the only type of information that's going to slip in there.

And even with those two examples, you just have to be creative to find ways for them to damage you:

You'll probably have to pay more for your health insurance, if they find out that you enjoy motorcycles.

And if your next potential employer is vegetarian, they might pass on you for fishing, a.k.a. killing things as a hobby.

Someone wanting to rob/extort/kidnap/murder you, might look for you at lonely lakes in the region.

And these are the most generic examples of this supposedly useless information being used against a person.

Someone who happens to have an actual use, is going to be even more creative, since they'll find themselves in some particular situation where it's useful.

And again, there's going to be more information. They can sift through an entire list to find the ones that are useful and they can combine multiple pieces of information, too.

Re:Subscription Hell by ozim on Sunday May 06, 2018 @03:14PM (#17007872)
How showing ads is against GDPR? You still can show ads, you just need consent for tracking users. If they are going out of business because of GDPR they were not just showing ads.
Re:Subscription Hell by lajhsdfkl on Sunday May 06, 2018 @05:50PM (#17008787)
There are no ads without tracking.
Re:Subscription Hell by saratogacx on Sunday May 06, 2018 @11:27PM (#17010209)
Ads existed before tracking. DDG uses ads based on the page content, not what is known about the user. This is actually how ads were before everyone went tracking-happy.

It is a model I prefer simply because it is more inline with the content I'm viewing. I'm more willing to let those ads get whitelisted because they're more likely to be related to the content I'm looking at and less about "what do we think saratogacx really wants today based on all of the data across the web."

Re:Subscription Hell by AlexandrB on Monday May 07, 2018 @08:01AM (#17012047)
> There are no ads without tracking.

I can definitively say you're wrong because I saw a billboard on my way to work today.

Also, in the early internet days tracking was referred to as spyware and security software would uninstall it from your machine.

Re:Subscription Hell by ozim on Monday May 07, 2018 @03:04AM (#17010869)
You don't have CTR in newspapers and people still buy adverts in those.
Re:Subscription Hell by rahoulb on Sunday May 06, 2018 @05:18PM (#17008605)
GDPR basically says “get consent for what you do with peoples data”. If you can’t do that I would say your business model is it very ethical.

Edit: or have “legitimate interest” - in either case it’s a very low bar for ethical standards so GDPR shouldn’t be an issue