NASA has the entire history of US Spaceflight in its collective memory. It has many memories of accidents occurring during fueling that resulted in the loss of the spacecraft. It has no memories of a crew being saved by the crew abort systems because it has only happened once[1] and that was with a Russian rocket.
Thus, going by what they "know", NASA knows that rockets can blow up when they are being fueled and they know that SpaceX blew up one of their rockets while fueling it, but they do not know if a launch escape system would save astronauts in that situation. Therefore SpaceX's plan is "risky" because they are exposing the crew to a "known" danger and relying on an "unknown" system to protect them from that danger. It is this kind of thinking that keeps NASA moving slowly and carefully.
SpaceX has essentially said, "Trust us, if anything went wrong the crew escape system would save them." Unfortunately they don't have a launch pad they can blow up on purpose to demonstrate that for NASA (it would help if they could). The last time they blew up a rocket while fueling it, it took months to recondition the pad for launches again.
[1] In 1983, an escape rocket pulled the three cosmonauts of Soyuz T-10-1 to safety when its booster exploded on the launch pad. As of 2015, this is the only case where an abort system saved a crew from a launchpad accident. -- https://www.space.com/29260-how-spacecraft-launch-aborts-wor...
1. In the video of the Amos 6 explosion[2], you see the payload fairing falling to the ground, with the satellite inside. You see it happened slowly, the payload did not explore, it burned down after falling. The abort system would have saved the crew in that situation. We were also told[3] the Dragon 1 would have been just fine if it was programmed to open its chutes after the second stage disintegrated under it during ascent on CRS-7. NASA participated in analyzing both failures, they know this.
2. SpaceX have done a pad abort test in 2015[1] that demonstrated the capsule reacting to "something bad happened to the rocket" on the launch pad and saving a test dummy's life.
1 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dragon_2#Pad_abort_test
2 - https://youtu.be/_BgJEXQkjNQ?t=79
3 - https://www.nasaspaceflight.com/2015/07/saving-spaceship-dra...
Pad abort test: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1_FXVjf46T8 Pad abort test (POV): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wcHD9AmkxA0 Stream of the same test: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OpH684lNUB8
Does it? I did a brief search and only found SpaceX’s explosion and an old Soviet ICBM accident where the engines ignited during fueling. I certainly may have missed something.
Propellant loading is a state change, and so it's theoretically more dangerous. But examples of real problems are rare.
“Convair engineers noted with some pride that there had never been a repeat of the same failure more than three times....”
The past sure was a different place.
Any idea how much that would cost to make? It doesn't have to be properly functional, it just has to hold the rocket and feed it fuel.
sounds like a properly functional launchpad to me.
Instead of a hundred million dollars making a really nice launch pad, you can make a $1M gantry on a small foundation and some barebones tanks.
Why can't NASA provide one for such purposes? Safety systems should be tested.
Well, not the NTSB, but the IIHS is crashing cars all the time - I've worked on their crash facility. Check out the dates on the videos here: https://www.youtube.com/user/iihs/videos.
But IIHS's rate is dwarfed by individual car manufactures. One car company I've worked with was smashing four to five cars a day, every day of the week, at their crash center.
But I still like your reasoning a lot.
But I’m just a software guy so this is just uninformed opinion!
Still, I’d be really interested in seeing the estimated numbers here.
https://science.ksc.nasa.gov/shuttle/missions/51-l/docs/roge...
We agree! :) I was just pointing out that your first comment expressing a preference for one style over another presupposes the relative magnitude of those numbers.
I would also be interested in actual data.
This is more of the current culture of being so risk adverse that you end up with more risky behavior with the ‘mitigation’ than the original risk.
What's the failure rate during fuel loading?
That is, if we assume 0% failure rate of the abort system then your scenario works.
If we assume (for argument's sake) a 50% failure rate in the abort system, and a 10% chance during fueling, then there's a 5% failure leading to human deaths.
Without those numbers, it's hard to draw a conclusion.
The expected failure rate for the LAS is pretty high, high enough that the loss of crew/mission statistic computation doesn't include the LAS.
If we assume the launch escape system is unreliable, then the numbers strongly point towards loading the crew after the rocket has been fuelled. The crew avoid the riskiest part of the process, and they are on the rocket for a shorter amount of time.
There are two ways to do it. You can load the fuel first, then have the astronauts board a rocket full of stuff ready to go boom. Or you can load the astronauts first, and load the fuel once they’re strapped in and ready to go.
In the first scenario, there’s a large window where an exploding rocket results in dead crew. The launch escape system doesn’t do them any good if they’re still on the walkway or the elevator. In the second scenario, there is no such window. At all times, either the rocket is unloaded or the launch escape system can save the crew.
If I were flying on Dragon, I’d really want to be in the scenario where I can always be saved.