I'm almost finished with Picketty's Capital in the 21st Century, and Prop 13 seems to be a godsend for rentiers seeking the inequality of 1900-1910.
Overturning Prop 13 isn't realistic since voters are selfish. Prop 13 has GOT to be the biggest reason behind NIMBY-ism. If the little old lady in the 3 bedroom $2M house had to pay $20K a year in taxes, she'd have sold a long time ago. But because of Prop 13, her taxes are likely less than $1K a year.
But the sick thing about Prop 13 is that it applies to landlords. You know why LA is filled with all these single-story rental properties from the 70s in prime locations? Because the taxes hardly budge, so they're paying about $1 per year per square foot in taxes. Even if they sold for the huge premium, it'd be impossible to re-invest that money into something with a higher rate of return.
It also applies to businesses. It's why you see a lot of car washes making < $1M/year sitting on land worth $20M.
We could potentially modify Prop 13 to eliminate the benefits for rental properties and have the benefits only apply to the first $1M of real estate. That'd only affect the top 5%, and only marginally.
But it could eliminate a lot of NIMBYism, I think.
Homesteading tax breaks are one thing, but applying them to all property is absolutely insane. This is easily the worst thing about it, and it has to go.
As to homesteading, even for homesteading the property taxes need to be able to go up with housing inflation somewhat at least.
It would be quite different if it was only the actual percentage tax rate that was limited in growth. I'd want that for income taxes too.
A brake on one kind of tax will spill into another kind. Thus, e.g., in TX property taxes function as an income tax via the Robin Hood school funding plan. It would be better to have a proper income tax, but no one will vote for such a thing without a hard constitutional brake on rates.
Why do older people need cheaper homes? Older people have paid off their mortgages and have 100% equity.
And at some point many elderly people start needing to tap their equity. Sure, you can use a reverse mortgage to do that, but downsizing works too, so some do that.
In any case, "we're retiring and moving to the middle of nowhere, where land and homes are cheap" is a common thing I see. Property taxes are a big reason for this, because even with senior homesteading property tax breaks, it can be a big savings to live farther out, and that's a big deal when your retirement savings aren't as big as you might have hoped.
Then again, few people "need" SUVs.
That's true, but it's a bit misleading IMO. Older folks might have accrued more wealth than younger demographics, but they're not really adding to it each year.
For example, the 65-69 age range has a median net worth of ~$194k[0]. However, somebody in that age range is likely retired and will be living off of that $194k for the remainder of their life. Conversely, somebody under 35 might only have a net worth of $6.6k but will likely be bringing in ~$4,000 each month. Were an individual in the 65-69 age range to withdraw $4,000 per month, they'd be out of money in 4 years. Realistically, most might withdraw around $2,000 per month (before or after Social Security). That's where my parents are at. They really have much less to spend even though they have a lot saved up.
If you take into consideration home equity, it's more apparent why property taxes and such are a big deal to older folks: upwards of 80% of their assets are in their house[1].
[0]: http://www.businessinsider.com/heres-the-average-net-worth-o... [1]: https://amp.businessinsider.com/images/593580d679474c17018b6...
Retirement starts to get scary when your parents are thinking about it. You start asking them just how much they have saved, and you start thinking about how much more income you'll need if you end up having to supplement theirs.
Also property taxes are not there to decide who leaves and who stays. The only reason why we have property taxes is to pay for Police, Public schools and other bare minimum public services.
Well, the limitation on increases in tax basis value probably needs to go, but I think the case is less clear for the tax rate limits and other parts of it.
Overturning Prop 13 isn't realistic since voters are selfish.
Overturning Prop 13 for everything but one's legitimate primary residence would be a lead-pipe cinch. Yet neither the legislature nor any deep-pocket funder for a relevant initiative constitutional amendment (cough Tom Steyer cough) has come forward.One of Prop 13s benefits from a planning perspectives is that your property taxes are isolated from the decisions of your neighbors. So if adjacent properties turn into condos or commercial, you won't see your taxes rocket, so you have less of an incentive to oppose development.
CEQA and the California Coastal Commission are weapons that NIMBYs use, but what drives NIMBYs in CA is the same as everywhere else. The hippy/champagne communists of SF just make it stronger (damn those evil developers making a profit! boo hiss!!!!) and elect malevolent local politicians, but it's the same drivers as anywhere else.
There's a huge class of people who aren't particularly impressive, hard-working, or otherwise "deserving" in my admittedly-morally-loaded-sense of the term, who happened to buy a ton of real estate over the last 30 years, and are now earning eye-popping rates of return (20%+/year on millions of invested capital) owing to the combination of increased desire to live in city centers, and prop 13.
It's really shocking. If you look at most small towns in America, the wealthy people tend to be small business owners, successful professionals, and perhaps a few landowners. Here in the SFBA, the serious peninsula wealth is all tech (early employees and execs) and everywhere else it's landowners by a mile. Here in Oakland, restaurants are closing practically every day because this rentier class is bleeding them dry of any profit. Both directly through rents, and indirectly by the wages employees are demanding to live in an area where prevailing rents are 2-3k/month.
I wouldn't even be mad about this except that they're using bad government policy to line their pockets, and they're just shameless about it. It boils my blood. These people are just leeching off of the huge south bay productivity engines (Google, facebook, Apple, etc) and taking a pound of flesh by restricting supply of a necessary good. Their entire livelihood rests with the stubbornness of execs at the big tech companies to stay here and put up with it. These companies end up paying exorbitant salaries just so that this rentier class can line their pockets with what would otherwise be shareholder profit or personal income of employees.
Not the same issues. Seattle doesn't have anything like Prop 13, or nearly as bad height restrictions. City residents and council are much more supportive of upzoning than SFBA — as in, it actually happens.[0]
Plenty of actual issues, and development still lags demand. But the situation is not nearly as dire as SFBA, and it's not getting worse quite as fast.
[0]: https://seattle.curbed.com/2017/11/9/16629248/seattle-hala-m...
There's a tipping point where the NIMBYs have enough power to block all or most upzoning and development, and I think — fortunately for us — Seattle has not passed that threshold. SFBA has.
In effect, it would've converted a lot of the Bay Area's SFH into much denser condominiums.
So yeah we're going to end up with middle class social housing lotteries, 1.5 hour commutes and crazy inflation of basic service costs ($3k/month child care, anyone?).
Every neighborhood can't be a wealthy enclave of SFH. There is literally no where to live in the central Bay Area on teachers salary much less a Social Security Disability paycheck. The homelessness epidemic will grow.
It's a rentier economy of land owners and the rent-controlled incumbents. How "Progressive".