News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by thisisit on Thursday May 03, 2018 @02:54AM (#16983870)
A friend of mine was trying to upskill himself and learn AI/ML. He had 10+years in IT and well paid . But on approaching his manager, the upskilling request was denied.

The manager said that he could "gather a bunch graduates" to build an AI/ML platform. There was no need to experiment and bet on someone with that much salary and experience.

So, I somehow feel ageism in tech is the result of everyone thinking tech is easy to build. A 15+years JAVA guy has similar output to say 5-6 years or for some extreme managers even 2-3 years.

Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by afpx on Thursday May 03, 2018 @07:08AM (#16984866)
I’m slightly over 40. Recently, I’ve been interviewing, and almost all of the focus has been on how I solve their ‘coding challenge’. Few questions about software engineering practices, algorithms or data structures, about how to approach challenging problems, make trade offs, or ship software.

It all comes down to if I can solve a problem like “Given an NxM matrix of integer strings, print true if any row, column, or diagnonal contains only palindromic numbers that can be written as the sum of consecutive squares.“ Oh, and on some random guy’s laptop, with a panel of 4 people watching me type as they sit in silence, and with 20 minutes remaining.

When I look back at all of my career successes (leading engineering teams through 10 successful commercial products, 4 startups, 3 acquisitions, millions of users, etc.), coding was hardly important.

I guess it’s time to retire.

Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by Lendal on Thursday May 03, 2018 @07:50AM (#16985066)
Fist, I don't want to work with a group of people who have only been selected by their ability to solve stupid, meaningless puzzles. That's something you do in college, which I hated.

Second, once you get past a minimum level of intelligence a lot of success in software development is based on motivation. It's hard to be motivated by a made-up problem where all your hard work is going to be thrown away and not used by anyone for anything, and my first step in solving it is to involuntarily roll my eyes and groan. That starts the project off on a bad foot to begin with.

Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by monsieurbanana on Thursday May 03, 2018 @11:14AM (#16986745)
I take offense on the "stupid, meaningless puzzles". I don't agree with their use in interviews, but that's needless bashing.

You not liking them doesn't make them stupid.

Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by perl4ever on Thursday May 03, 2018 @03:08PM (#16988873)
Different people like different kinds of puzzles. I like Fermi-type problems, which at least at one time, it seemed like everyone on the internet liked to bash. It may be they are no longer bashed because interviewers abandoned them.

I once posted a puzzle on a different website that boiled down to "why did I choose this particular non-round number" with some context, and eventually someone got it, but some people got very angry at me.

The trouble is that a lot of puzzles reduce to "can you follow a particular convoluted path to a solution" and if you don't, you are being judged unworthy for being dissimilar in your thinking and not necessarily for your sheer brainpower.

That's why I prefer puzzles that nobody has solved, but those have two obvious problems - either (a) they are too hard to solve, or (b) once solved, they appear to be too easy. Either way, you can't use them as tests.

It's natural to like tests that you are good at and other people are not, and to hate tests that other people are good at and you are not. So, people are always going to take offense at tests.

Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by tcbawo on Thursday May 03, 2018 @08:18AM (#16985258)
Seeing whether someone can code has to be part of the recipe. It's surprising how many candidates can't demonstrate basic coding ability. The coding component is better if it requires the candidate to ask questions about what is required, where they can demonstrate their thought process and approach to the problem at hand. Anything that requires more than 15 minutes on a whiteboard is probably overkill. Brainteasers and the like are mostly a waste of time.
Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by perfunctory on Thursday May 03, 2018 @08:29AM (#16985335)
> “Given an NxM matrix of integer strings, print true if any row, column, or diagnonal contains only palindromic numbers that can be written as the sum of consecutive squares.“

Ok, but this is not really a puzzle. It looks like a rather trivial exercise just to see if you can write nested loops. I guess an average software engineer shouldn't have problems with this. Or I am missing something.

Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by afpx on Thursday May 03, 2018 @10:28AM (#16986331)
Well, I failed this one and similar problems going on 5-6 times now.

I don’t know why I can’t do it. I freeze up with analysis paralysis, or stage fright, or something. Maybe it’s because I have no clue what they’re looking for, and I’m so used to simplifying problems based on business cases and stakeholder feedback. Maybe it’s because I’m always thinking about production-grade code (I do try to avoid nested loops!). Maybe because I assume that the problem requires a specialized data structure, and so try to invent it on the spot. Or, it could be that I am old-school and like to solve problems on paper first before coding.

You may not believe me, but I code everyday. At every job I’ve held, I’ve been complimented as one of the best programmers. So, maybe I’ve only ever worked with C-grade developers? But, I’ve worked with 100s of people. How can that be?

But, let’s say that I really do suck at coding. Are all my other attributes, skills, and experiences valueless? Seems like such a waste.

Years ago, relatively early in my career, I went into management. But, I only did it for 2 years before going technical again. It just didn’t make sense at that time. Senior developers then made more than managers, and I enjoyed building things. Now, I really regret that decision.

Anyway ... I clearly can’t get a job. Anyone have any career ideas for a washed up software engineer?

Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by SmirkingRevenge on Thursday May 03, 2018 @12:12PM (#16987224)
There are definitely companies out there that don't follow the Cracking the Code Interview/Hacker Rank formula.

This is an interesting list that has been posted here before:

- https://github.com/poteto/hiring-without-whiteboards

But if you want to work somewhere firmly in the whiteboard club - do regular practice on hackerrank and leetcode. Many interviewers will draw their questions directly from those sites (and some others, I'm sure).

(Personally, I honestly feel those exercises have improved my coding, so there's that too.)

Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by stevenwoo on Thursday May 03, 2018 @11:20AM (#16986786)
What resources are you using to find jobs and where geographically are you looking for jobs? I started looking a couple of weeks ago and found AngelList to be a lot better than Hacker news job postings, YMMV.

I thought it was kind of silly but have you tried practicing on hackerrank or leetcode for the coding tests? Hackerrank feels pretty brittle but a lot of companies use it for timed screening so good to get a feel for the platform's ability to lose all your work in a non pressure situation, leetcode has very useful discussions about user supplied solutions.

Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by fuzzygroup on Thursday May 03, 2018 @02:49PM (#16988686)
Hey Afpx,

You're not alone. I recently went thru this myself and wrote up my experiences here: http://fuzzyblog.io/blog/jobhound/2018/04/24/ten-things-i-le...

I hope that helps.

Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by throwawayjava on Thursday May 03, 2018 @11:14AM (#16986748)
Sitting here, in your chair, you can definitely do this no problem, right? So find a group of people who will simulate the interview environment for you.

Also, there are strategies for managing the time problem. 20 minutes is a bit fast for understand => ask questions => implement => test on this problem. But you can organize the code so that if you run out of time it's still clear you knew how to solve the problem and can code your way out of a wet paper bag. E.g., I would pass an answer that got everything correct but didn't get around to implementing isPalindrome() or isSoCS() before the 20 minutes was up, especially if the candidate could give a ~1 minute description of how to implement those functions. (I would also give more than 20 minutes.)

Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by perl4ever on Thursday May 03, 2018 @03:29PM (#16989058)
I interviewed at a place that started by having me do a HackerRank test online, and complimented me on my code and comments. Then the in person interview ended with a coding test involving a much simpler problem which I assume I failed, from my perspective due to the pressure of limited time and people talking at me. It's hard for me to figure out what was going on, unless they basically thought they were testing to see if I cheated on the first test.

However, I haven't experienced repeated failure of a consistent type, so I'm not particularly motivated to worry about this sort of thing. I do know that different companies have radically different processes, so if someone tells you "you're not a good fit" it may be completely true and not a negative judgement at all (even if that's how they mean it).

It so happens that I got my undergraduate degree about ten years later than is typical, and thus I can pass for someone that much younger than me, at present. So in an interview, it is tempting for me to give away my age by reminiscing about computing in the 80s, and that could have caused me to be rejected a couple times but I will never know for sure...

Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by eythian on Thursday May 03, 2018 @09:04AM (#16985579)
We use questions like this (actually, significantly simpler - basically, can you drive a loop and an array) as a screener test to see if you actually write a trivial program. If you succeed, it's a chance to add constraints and talk about how data structures and algorithms would change given these changes, or how it could be more optimal, etc.

But a surprising number of applicants fail to pass a simple coding test, not even getting a naive solution.

Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by perl4ever on Thursday May 03, 2018 @03:37PM (#16989144)
There exist people who can't code in an interview, period. Now, you might react to this with doubt that they are employable. But the reason such people exist is because interviews that do not require even trivial coding exist, and thus they are hired and proceed to code just fine in their actual job.

One thing that really helps with perspective, whichever side of an interview you are usually on, is to have seen how radically differently different companies do things.

That doesn't necessarily mean that you should change your practices, but diversity in behavior exists because there are niches that can be exploited and trade-offs to doing so.

Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by myth_drannon on Thursday May 03, 2018 @08:55AM (#16985509)
Solve it with a For loop and it's immediate interview fail. The solutions should be optimal. /S
Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by theandrewbailey on Thursday May 03, 2018 @09:14AM (#16985666)
...because our architect forbids use of for loops. One killed his pappy.
Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by dlandis on Thursday May 03, 2018 @11:34AM (#16986907)
> Oh, and on some random guy’s laptop, with a panel of 4 people watching me type as they sit in silence, and with 20 minutes remaining.

That part, to me, is worse then the question. Are you exaggerating, or did the panel really just sit there and watch you? If so, can you say which company so people know to avoid?

Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by softawre on Thursday May 03, 2018 @12:42PM (#16987532)
isn't this what most companies do?
Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by erikb on Thursday May 03, 2018 @04:28AM (#16984243)
The difference is between companies who want to use technology to really gain influence in the world (Amazon, Alibaba etc) and companies that just try to get by creating some fluff so the next paid version of their product keeps customers paying.

The first kind of company will not underestimate certain workloads and pays experts very high salaries. The second company really doesn't need to succeed technology wise, so they use the cheapest way possible to create their fluff.

And one tip that always applies: Never tell your manager about your ambitions. Never! A middle manager is certainly someone who is more about the fluff+constant pay type of person, a rent seeker. He doesn't like people showing true effort and actually gaining leverage for raises and maybe even take over his position. Especially the last point is very important to him. For him his position is the most valuable thing in the world so it is natural from his point of view that everybody below him wants to steal it from him. And it's also not totally wrong since he probably got his position just in this way. So even if you work for Amazon who really want to compete for AI leadership don't tell your manager. Maybe talk with HR or do it in private, and then apply for another team when you got the skills.

Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by Gustomaximus on Thursday May 03, 2018 @08:15AM (#16985244)
I believe your 'one tip that always applies' is horrible advice. And if this is the mentality someone approaches management it doesn't surprise me they have bad relationships.

For me I'm open and direct with managers. I've had some good ones and bad ones. Id say 70/30 ratio in favour of good. And when a manger is bad the adage plays true, 'People do not leave bad companies, they leave bad bosses'.

Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by Lendal on Thursday May 03, 2018 @07:56AM (#16985105)
If you showed the ability to steal his position, that means he made a good hire which means he's going to move up himself. So why would he care if you had ambitions on his position or not? All the better if you did. Your working harder makes him look good.
Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by erikb on Thursday May 03, 2018 @01:30PM (#16987912)
Really good question! I also find this part quite illogical myself. My current believe (but no evidence whatsoever) is that:

a) He doesn't want to move up. The higher you get the more visible lack of skill and ambition becomes as well.

b) “It is not enough [for him] merely to win; others must lose.” ― Gore Vidal

Sorry, that's all I got about this question.

Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by probablybroken on Thursday May 03, 2018 @06:07AM (#16984609)
Wouldn't he also have to learn a lot of advanced mathematics? I'd imagine the bunch of graduates in this case would be math majors. Obviously I don't know the specific requirements of your organisation, but this re-skilling might take up to five years ( if the requirements were R&D focused... Maybe the situation is different if it's more about applying pre-existing sofware. )
Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by mattmanser on Thursday May 03, 2018 @06:51AM (#16984769)
Does ML really need advanced maths? I think you're under-estimating how the fundamentals are pretty simple really. What we were previously lacking was raw processing power to get good results.
Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by Scea91 on Thursday May 03, 2018 @10:27AM (#16986319)
You would be surprised how the devil always emerges in the details when you move to real applications from academic exercises and datasets.

I definitely use a lot of statistics daily. I do not need to compute integrals by hand or construct formal proofs, but a lot of intuition is necessary.

Statistics is very tricky by the way. It is so easy to have incorrect assumptions and totally misapply the methods. Also another problem with ML in general is that if you make an error you very often do not notice it. The methods will usually work a bit worse but they will still kinda work.

Just yesterday I discovered a tricky feedback loop that corrupted my data for several weeks.

Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by darkhorn on Thursday May 03, 2018 @01:09PM (#16987750)
> Statistics is very tricky by the way.

I think this why HR hire computer engineers instead of statisticians when it comes to ML.

Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by Scea91 on Thursday May 03, 2018 @01:39PM (#16988010)
At least half of my colleagues have degrees in mathematics.
Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by itg on Thursday May 03, 2018 @07:10AM (#16984882)
Yes, it does, especially if your going to put a model in production for anything critical ex: self driving cars, healthcare. Understanding the math is what allows you to properly understand what is going on, how to improve, debug, etc. A person who only knows how to use a library/framework will be limited.
Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by mattmanser on Thursday May 03, 2018 @07:24AM (#16984958)
Who said anything about him using it for health care or self driving cars?

The vast majority of applications for AI/ML can be done with libraries, just like the vast majority of programmers doesn't need to understand how to make a compiler or even how memory works. It just helps.

Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by mywittyname on Thursday May 03, 2018 @10:37AM (#16986403)
The vast majority of programmers do need to understand boolean algebra though. Likewise, you do need to understand matrix algebra and statistics to do any AI/ML beyond a color-by-numbers problem.

At some point you need to explain why something works.

Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by mattmanser on Thursday May 03, 2018 @12:09PM (#16987194)
Matrix algebra and statistics are taught in high school, or at least were when I was young.

A random 40 y/o programmer might be rusty on it, but it's not going to take very long to pick it all up again.

And if you've done any game programming even just for fun, you probably know quite a bit of that already.

Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by vidarh on Thursday May 03, 2018 @08:27AM (#16985314)
There are plenty of ML problems that requires nothing more than being able to pick up something of the complexity of Bayes theorem. Yes, there are also ML problems that require far more. But you can't say much about the math requirements without knowing what kind of problems they'd be working on.
Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by raducu on Thursday May 03, 2018 @08:56AM (#16985512)
I'm pretty sure I can have the same output as a chess grand master, even though I haven't played it in decades.
Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by kodablah on Thursday May 03, 2018 @10:18AM (#16986245)
> But on approaching his manager, the upskilling request was denied.

Bad way to go about it anyways. The best way is to change companies if possible (granted, one will have to put in their own time to learn or do it quietly at their current job). If the company is good about intra-company movement, it might be possible to do this within the company, but often the companies that can do this come off as too large to have the flexibility one needs to really dive in as opposed to getting lost in the fray (you'll feel like you're a junior all over again). Unfortunately, mobility is the antithesis of stability.

Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by mikkom on Thursday May 03, 2018 @06:34AM (#16984708)
> he could "gather a bunch graduates" to build an AI/ML platform

I would claim that the more general and reusable the tool ("AI platform") is, the more experience is needed to build it.

Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by Double_a_92 on Thursday May 03, 2018 @03:08AM (#16983926)
> A 15+years JAVA guy has similar output to say 5-6 years or for some extreme managers even 2-3 years.

I'd expect the output to be logarithmic.

Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by snarfy on Thursday May 03, 2018 @05:48AM (#16984552)
Somewhere along the line you learn it's better to write a couple lines of shell script than 20,000 lines of Java.
Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by jdipierro on Thursday May 03, 2018 @06:59AM (#16984809)
Something tells me you just read the latest XKCD.
Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by majewsky on Thursday May 03, 2018 @07:14AM (#16984904)
It's not like overengineering is a new trend that emerged a few years ago.
Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by erikb on Thursday May 03, 2018 @04:34AM (#16984269)
I totally understand where that's coming from. A guy doing the same tasks/processes for 15+ years will get less and less from additional experience.

However, he will not do exactly the same thing. For instance a 10+ years guy might realize that instead of investigating a topic for 3 workdays, he can ask the colleague from another team he worked with 2 years ago, and get the answer in 20 mins. His processes will change a lot, so his output can increase exponentially even. Of course it's limited by his intelligence, i.e. his ability to learn from his experience. And it's likely to happen in steps. So a quite smooth line for a few months, then an aha-moment where he bumps his output drastically, then another smooth line.

Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by chaosite on Thursday May 03, 2018 @03:14AM (#16983966)
Define output. Once you get to a certain level of competence, you can easily produce lines of codes, so if that's your metric then the output plateaus after some years.

A developer can only type so much each day, after all.

Re:Over 30? Too Old for Tech Jobs in China by Double_a_92 on Thursday May 03, 2018 @04:51AM (#16984346)
I took the word from the parent comment. But I assumed it to mean whatever the employer gets (or wants to get) from the worker.