Re:Amazon threatens to suspend Signal's AWS account over cen...
by toast0 on Wednesday May 02, 2018 @06:45PM
(#16981814)
I don't have a better idea, I don't think it's possible.
When a server has multiple identities to choose from, and the client has not previously communicated with (and has no no out of band information), as far as I can tell, either the SNI has to be in plain text, or it could be encrypted with an untrusted DHE key (which only eliminates passive detection).
Way upthread, bscphil wondered if [big companies] will oppose encrypted SNI to avoid having their IP ranges banned, but their business reasons don't really flow into a decision not to do impossible things.
In TLS 1.3 that 1RTT completes the handshake so as the client we know who we're taking to.
That SNI draft is the result of interested parties coming up with a list of desirable properties for SNI encryption. If you have a better idea that satisfies those properties you absolutely should propose it.