The only bad thing about OSFP is that its highly similar name will confuse the hell out of network engineers who never see the OSI layer 1 of a network, and deal with things at OSI layer 3.
OSFP != OSPF (the routing protocol).
When I talk about SERDES I’m talking about the electrical signal interface to the optic. Also it’s worth noting that the majority of coherent DWDM interfaces are some kind of embedded optic already.
So if the above is true OSFP is not needed now.
Honestly, 800G is only incremental at best and frankly it’s not clear that An 800G pluggable is the way to go. The 800G presumes 32 radix and that breaks down power-wise in the datacenter when we get to spine switches where we need 128 radix. The reason being that we need so many power hungry chips to make a high radix switch fully non-blocking (eg Clos topology). 112G SERDES will have limited reach and hence require many retimers which eat power too. So the OSFP is in my view is A solution looking for a problem.
The problem this presents for OSFP going forward is that it encourages early adoption to steer toward QSFP-DD, which will tend to drive follow-on purchase decisions as well.
QSFP-DD is backwards compatible so that you can run your 400G port as a 100G or 40G with 4 lanes at 25G/10G. OSFP will be able to do the same thing but with an adapter from OSFP to QSFP
But what this article fails to mention is that OSFP is the connector of the future that will support 8 lanes of 100G to support 800G ethernet with good signal integrity and capability to support high power optics for longer distances. ( This looks to be in 2020 )
So QSFP-DD is a 1 generation connector...
OSFP will see us through 400G and 800G.
Disclaimer I work at Arista Networks who is bullish on OSFP.
For more info see Andy Bechtolsheim's talk on 400G optics at OCP
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kotu6B7AQpk