It's pure FUD.
But since we're throwing out wild speculations it's more than possible this guy was doing something really shady. (He admits to affiliate links which are perfectly fine under GDPR). There would definitely be a market for user data even about who's borrowing what, where. Certainly the vast majority of these "the GDPR killed our free business" are precisely these shady businesses who knew they were dead anyways if they had to actually ask their users for consent in plain language.
Now they do.
He wants to leave the game? Feel free! He wants people to be completely powerless? Well.. the kitchen has a door. Feel free to open and leave if it gets too hot.
McDonald's has it easier to comply with food safety regulations than the cozy mom and pop cafe down the street. Would you be willing to shit your guts out because the ambiance is better there?
People cooking for themselves at home aren't required to comply with (the same) food safety regulations. Obviously, you never eat at home or at the home of a friend or relative either, right?
People collecting phone numbers in their personal phonebooks aren't required to comply with data security and privacy regulations.
What you say it's an unintended side effect, I think is very much intended. That's why the GDPR (if it doesn't fail for other reasons) is a very welcome regulation.
Show us some proof the GDPR is harder for small and new businesses to comply.
Once upon a time Facebook was the fresh new competition. Once upon a time Google took pains to maintain their "Don't be evil" motto. Everyone starts out starry-eyed, keen to destroy the oppressive incumbent. Very few stay that way.
What does it change? Not much just by knowing, but it can allow for change, including exercising a right to delete that data under GDPR. That is a positive change in my opinion.
Regulation allowing me to delete that is good.
You understand, you just disagree and you seem intent on moving the goalposts as needed to make your “GDPR = bad” point.