Sigma Octantis (mag 5.47, ra 21h09m dec −88°57′) is the best South Pole star within (optimistic) naked-eye range. As you can see, it is just over 1° off axis (c.f. Polaris, which is marginally better at c. 3/4° out).
Instead we navigate by using the southern cross to find the south celestial pole
My polar alignment scope has etchings for Sigma Octantis (screenshot from companion iOS app: [1]). Wikipedia also describes Sigma Octantis as a southern pole star [2]. Maybe it's just not as common to refer to Sigma Octantis as a pole star as it is for Polaris, but it does seem to be recognized.
[1] https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/astro-physics-polaralign/id5...
We're talking about pole stars. Being a naked eye star isn't a necessary condition. Choice of a pole star is a balance between brightness and proximity to the pole.
> again no one in the Southern Hemisphere I've every heard of looks up and points at a "pole star"
It's never too late to learn something new. :)
More to the point, "the north and south polestars" would be well understood by much of Sky & Telescope's target audience, and that's who they're writing for. I get that it's going to be less common knowledge outside of their target audience, but that doesn't make the article incorrect, which seems to be what you want to argue.
Ofcourse, at the poles you have long polar day (midnight sun) in summer - and will generally see only one star during the night: the sun.
Conversely, during polar night, you'll be able to see some stars for most of the day, if not maybe a few bright stars even at noon.