News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I Left the U.S. 20 Years Ago and Why I Won't Be Comin... by fwdpropaganda on Saturday April 28, 2018 @03:54AM (#16946604)
> If you want all those government benefits in exchange for making 1/3rd of what one makes in the US, go right ahead.

Over here we don't consider that healthcare and education are a "government benefit". We consider them rights.

But you sound slightly offended. Like now you're trying to prove that some people like the USA. You don't have to prove anything dude.

Re:Why I Left the U.S. 20 Years Ago and Why I Won't Be Comin... by dang on Saturday April 28, 2018 @01:26PM (#16948638)
You have been one of the worst offenders in this thread full of horrible violations of the HN guidelines. You've also been uncivil on HN many times before. This is really bad.

I'm not going to ban you, because your recent history hasn't been as bad as this, but if you do this sort of flamewar on HN again, we will ban you. Please do not pour any trace of nationalistic poison, regardless of how badly other users are behaving. If you do, you're as bad as they are. This of course goes for every user, not just you.

Please (re-)read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and do a much better job of using this site as intended from now on.

Re:Why I Left the U.S. 20 Years Ago and Why I Won't Be Comin... by fwdpropaganda on Saturday April 28, 2018 @03:49PM (#16949147)
> You have been one of the worst offenders in this thread

I obviously disagree with the characterisation of what I said as "nationalistic poison", but I will no longer talk politics on HN to be on the safe side.

Re:Why I Left the U.S. 20 Years Ago and Why I Won't Be Comin... by Hnrobert42 on Saturday April 28, 2018 @07:30AM (#16947166)
I read something about the term “right” that I have yet to fully reconcile. For some rights, nothing is required of other people. E.g., freedom of speech, voting rights, even right to bear arms. Other rights require taking from others. Universal health, basic income, etc. requires taking money from some/all to give to others.

I dont know that the second is necessarily bad, but it is an interesting distinction. However, it may be a false distinction. Child care leave may not require taking from the employer so much as establish that if the employer wants an employee’s work, a fair trade includes leave.

Like I said, I haven’t fully thought this one through.

Re:Why I Left the U.S. 20 Years Ago and Why I Won't Be Comin... by fwdpropaganda on Saturday April 28, 2018 @08:59AM (#16947439)
> Child care leave may not require taking from the employer so much as establish that if the employer wants an employee’s work, a fair trade includes leave.

I hear you, but I think the distinction isn't great because it's A) semantic more than anything, and B) too easy to take it into the realm of mental gymnastics, to the point the distinction loses all meaning. I could just as well argue that X right may not require taking from other people (in the form of taxes) so much as establish that if you want to be a part of our society (after all, no one is stopping you from leaving and go live in the jungle), a fair trade (i.e. the taxes you pay for the benefits you get) involves your taxes paying for X, and that this is true for all X.

[dead]
Re:Why I Left the U.S. 20 Years Ago and Why I Won't Be Comin... by dang on Saturday April 28, 2018 @01:32PM (#16948662)
If you post like this again, we will ban you. Please read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stop wrecking this place with poisonous flamebait.
Re:Why I Left the U.S. 20 Years Ago and Why I Won't Be Comin... by fdw on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:27AM (#16946677)
I don't think you'll care to read or think about this reply, but others might, and HN is for me also about open-minded discussion.

I don't pay through my nose for healthcare. According to a quick Google search, it seems to be about what the average US resident pays (while I'm above average in income for my country). For that price, I don't ever have to worry about going to a doctor or hospital. I'm feeling sick - I go to the doctor. I have a toothache - I go to the doctor. I think I broke my finger - I go to the hospital, wait a few hours, and learn that everything is alright. I can't imagine having to wonder if the visit is really necessary, because I need the money. I don't want to have to choose between health and money. For me, this is comfort.

Additionally, I have friends with chronic diseases. They cannot emigrate to the USA, because they couldn't pay the medicine. That doesn't sound like a first-world country to me, where you cannot afford to treat your sickness, even though you've got skills and a paying job. That sounds like a bad dystopian movie.

Re:Why I Left the U.S. 20 Years Ago and Why I Won't Be Comin... by throwaway84742 on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:41AM (#16946707)
I go to the doctor when I’m sick too, imagine that! And I too have a chronic disease for which I pay a princely sum of $10/mo as a co-pay for medication. It is true that Americans pay quite a bit more for healthcare. But our doctors make quite a bit more than European ones, too. I do like it when the person treating me is well off, and their income is largely decoupled from the whims of a random unelected government bureaucrat.

It’s also true that the health insurance system badly needs an overhaul. But I’d very much like to keep it private, because our government is a money black hole.

Re:Why I Left the U.S. 20 Years Ago and Why I Won't Be Comin... by leadingthenet on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:12AM (#16946646)
I can’t believe a comment which literally calls Europeans commies is this highly upvoted on HN.

That’s why I’m smh.

Re:Why I Left the U.S. 20 Years Ago and Why I Won't Be Comin... by dang on Saturday April 28, 2018 @01:40PM (#16948693)
The comment was not only downvoted but flagkilled. It takes time for the community's reaction to settle.

There's something more important though: you helped make this horrible flamewar worse. If you post something like https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16946815, you have no basis to complain about others.

If you saw a house on fire, or a forest, or a city park, I'm sure your first reaction wouldn't be to pour fuel on it. Please bring that instinct for good behavior here too. It's not as obvious that it's needed, but it is.

[dead]
Re:Why I Left the U.S. 20 Years Ago and Why I Won't Be Comin... by dijit on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:30AM (#16946834)
To save us talking about ill defined social policies, I'm going to quickly define them (I'm not being condescending, it is easy for people to infer meaning from things like this)

* Capitalism is an economic and political system in which a country's trade and industry are controlled by private owners for profit, rather than by the state.

* Communism a theory or system of social organization in which all property is owned by the community and each person contributes and receives according to their ability and needs.

* Socialism is a political and economic theory of social organization which advocates that the means of production, distribution, and exchange should be owned or regulated by the community as a whole.

Doing any single one of these is a possible disaster, I won't get into the theories here, but lets assume extremes are unhealthy.

Now, you're inferring that Europeans are "lax commies" which would mean that the goal is to get everything into the public hands. That's not quite the case, in fact it's not the case at all honestly, so it's not communism.

Secondly, you refer to Europe as one political and economic model, it's not, there are many for instance the Nordic regions have their own model which is often referred to as "Nordic Capitalism" or "Nordic Social Democracy"[0]

Finally, and I know this one is quite hard: Europeans typically are not nationalistic. Given that the rise of nationalism is seen as being very closely followed by facism; nationalism is a dirty word, and if you were to be described as "nationalist" it would be considered an insult in many European countries by the majority of the population. The principle problem here is that "patriotism" is synonymous with "nationalism". And Americans are very "patriotic", meaning any criticism of the country as a complete functioning system is met with hostility because so many people are so sensitive of the subject.

I know it's hard to be objective when you've been drilled that your way of life is objectively "better" or "freer", but its often good to take a step back and look at the system so that - at the very least - you can hold your government to account for "why can't we do healthcare too, since we pay more per person for it in taxes anyway".

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nordic_model

Re:Why I Left the U.S. 20 Years Ago and Why I Won't Be Comin... by throwaway84742 on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:46AM (#16946872)
I would like to point out, however, that aside from Norway (which sits on a huge barrel of hydrocarbons) all of the countries mentioned are significantly worse off in terms of per capita GDP (PPP). So it might just be that capitalism is not such a total disaster as you suggest.
Re:Why I Left the U.S. 20 Years Ago and Why I Won't Be Comin... by mpweiher on Saturday April 28, 2018 @07:29AM (#16947158)
Hmm...if we're doing "capitalism somewhere else" and "reaping the benefits", do tell me how come German companies are beating US companies left and right in the marketplace?

It's the US that can't compete, as shown by the amazing trade deficits that have been in place since the 80s, and in fact, the rest of the world is subsidizing this deficit.

US wealth is, to a large extent, borrowed wealth.

Re:Why I Left the U.S. 20 Years Ago and Why I Won't Be Comin... by holydude on Saturday April 28, 2018 @08:41AM (#16947379)
Where and how are the german companies beating the US ?

US wealth is borrowed wealth ? From whom did they borrow it then ?

Re:Why I Left the U.S. 20 Years Ago and Why I Won't Be Comin... by mpweiher on Saturday April 28, 2018 @09:43AM (#16947592)
Just in 2017, the US had a $64 billion trade deficit with Germany. 2016 was pretty much the same, and as I said, it's been like that for a long, long time.

And no, that's not by dumping cheap products due to low labor costs. Labor costs in the industrial sector tend to be quite a bit higher in Germany, strong unions and labor protection and all that awful "socialist" stuff.

The surplus is because German products are high quality and are in demand. In fact, most of the top categories of exports are the same for the US and Germany, so it's a pretty direct competition.

Overall, the US trade deficit was $478 billion in 2016. Recently, Germany had a trade surplus with China, despite the much lower Chinese wages.

The US current accounts deficit is very similar in scale, at $462 billion in 2017. That's the difference between the amount that the US (private+public) borrowed from foreign countries and the amount that foreign countries borrowed from the US.

Re:Why I Left the U.S. 20 Years Ago and Why I Won't Be Comin... by holydude on Saturday April 28, 2018 @11:20AM (#16948065)
That is very much a false dichotomy. Your german products are of good quality but largely overvalued and this shows when Trump threatens with tariffs ;). There is actually very little that makes as much money for the germans and is not directly connected to a field where german companies have a specific monopoly. I hope you are joking right now and know how borrowing public and private money works.
Re:Why I Left the U.S. 20 Years Ago and Why I Won't Be Comin... by mpweiher on Saturday April 28, 2018 @11:28AM (#16948098)
LOL. You have to threaten tariffs when you can't compete.

And yes, unlike you, I do know how borrowing money works: the US is currently borrowing half a trillion dollars per year from foreign sources, net.

Re:Why I Left the U.S. 20 Years Ago and Why I Won't Be Comin... by dang on Saturday April 28, 2018 @01:41PM (#16948698)
Would you please stop using HN for flamewars? It's totally not ok, and you've done it a lot and we've had to warn you about it repeatedly. You've posted many awesome things to Hacker News so we'd hate to ban you, but protecting the site from flames is more important. This is a problem we need you to fix.

Please read and follow https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and help take care of this place instead of helping to wreck it. I'm sure you wouldn't fuel flames in a forest or a garden, so please don't fuel them here.

Re:Why I Left the U.S. 20 Years Ago and Why I Won't Be Comin... by mpweiher on Saturday April 28, 2018 @06:30PM (#16949768)
Sorry, I don't "use" HN for flamewars. And just to be sure I checked several pages worth of my comments just now, after all I could be misremembering.

I also don't recall being "warned" about this "repeatedly".

I do try to correct gross misinformation. With facts and figures.

Re:Why I Left the U.S. 20 Years Ago and Why I Won't Be Comin... by dang on Sunday April 29, 2018 @12:54PM (#16952779)
The most recent moderation reply is here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16288896. If it doesn't read like a warning, that's out of politeness and respect for your positive contributions to HN.

It's true that your most recent history doesn't contain ideological flamewar (not counting this nationalistic spat), which is great. Nonetheless it has noticeably been a problem in the past, and your comments still sometimes contain uncivil swipes that need to be edited out.

Re:Why I Left the U.S. 20 Years Ago and Why I Won't Be Comin... by fwdpropaganda on Saturday April 28, 2018 @08:48AM (#16947408)
> Where and how are the german companies beating the US ?

Have you seen many American cars on the road lately? Not a rhetorical question, I'm actually expecting an answer.

Re:Why I Left the U.S. 20 Years Ago and Why I Won't Be Comin... by holydude on Saturday April 28, 2018 @09:05AM (#16947461)
I did in Norway :-).

Seriously picking a car industry which is and always had been different in the US than in Eu is a shitty example to prove a point. If it would not be for your liberal americans throwing billions at your german cars they would be nothing compared to what they are now. Ever been to SK ? How many non korean cars have you seen ?

The entire IT industry dwarfs everything Europe has or will have in the next decades and still it is just a fraction of the US of A produces or trades with the world.

Besides Germany is your China of europe dumping shit to weaker markets en masse. Just looking at the list of largest german companies gives you a hint of how Germany really operates.

Re:Why I Left the U.S. 20 Years Ago and Why I Won't Be Comin... by fwdpropaganda on Saturday April 28, 2018 @09:22AM (#16947519)
> Seriously picking a car industry which is and always had been different in the US than in Eu is a shitty example to prove a point. (etc)

I'm not trying to "prove a point". You asked for an example ("Where and how are the german companies beating the US ?") and I gave you one: German car companies are beating american car companies in the us.

So before you change the subject into china, south korea, the IT industry, weaker markets, mass production, and so on and on, can you first acknowledge that you asked for an example of German companies beating american ones, and I gave you exactly one such example?

Re:Why I Left the U.S. 20 Years Ago and Why I Won't Be Comin... by mpweiher on Saturday April 28, 2018 @09:48AM (#16947620)
Well, you asked for an example, so you were given an example.

However, I agree that examples are not all that useful. Numbers are, and these show that, in aggregate, German companies are beating US companies, individual sectors notwithstanding.

And the US is borrowing tons of money from the outside world and has been doing that for decades.

Now you can try to dispute that, but you'd need to come up with some solid arguments backed with data. Certainly your point that these awful commies are mooching off the great capitalists is ... a little off base. As in not compatible with the facts.

Re:Why I Left the U.S. 20 Years Ago and Why I Won't Be Comin... by holydude on Saturday April 28, 2018 @11:16AM (#16948045)
Your inability to understand the subject is astounding.

Funny how you demand from me to show you numbers when you are not doing so yourself .. but what can i expect from a german right ? ;)

My point was never about commies mooching off the great capitalists so again you missed this one as well. The point was that the european economies gained its wealth and glory by employing capitalist practiced in the countries of 2nd and 3rd world while pretending moral superiority and bad mouthing countries like the US or China.

Re:Why I Left the U.S. 20 Years Ago and Why I Won't Be Comin... by dang on Saturday April 28, 2018 @01:37PM (#16948679)
You violated the site guidelines badly more than once in this wretched flamewar. That's bad, and we ban accounts that do this. We've also had to warn you before about this.

Would you please (re-)read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and use the site only as intended from now on? The rules are the way they are because we don't want this community to destroy itself. If it's valuable enough for you to participate in, it's valuable enough for you to help preserve it. Helping to wreck it is incongruent, and I'm sure you're not doing that intentionally, but unfortunately the effects are the same.

Re:Why I Left the U.S. 20 Years Ago and Why I Won't Be Comin... by fwdpropaganda on Saturday April 28, 2018 @03:46PM (#16949141)
> I'm sure you're not doing that intentionally

And I'm sure that you know that is not true. You can't possibly believe that someone who says "but what can i expect from a german" does not know exactly the effect he will provoke on the other person.

Re:Why I Left the U.S. 20 Years Ago and Why I Won't Be Comin... by dang on Saturday April 28, 2018 @04:20PM (#16949253)
The capacity to not see something like that goes orders of magnitude further than you'd expect. That's one thing I've learned from moderating HN: nearly all abuse, including what you'd swear is outright trolling, is unconscious and unintentional. Any vague awareness that one is doing it is accompanied by the righteous feeling that the other person has done much worse; which is another variant of self-deception.

I'd even say that in their trivial way, these internet forum dynamics are connected to the causes of violence and war. If that's true, it has an interesting consequence: internet forums are an opportunity—trivial, yes, but therefore also safe—to work on the sources of violence and war in oneself.

Re:Why I Left the U.S. 20 Years Ago and Why I Won't Be Comin... by leadingthenet on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:23AM (#16946815)
I didn’t think people like you actually existed.
Re:Why I Left the U.S. 20 Years Ago and Why I Won't Be Comin... by dijit on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:37AM (#16946850)
This is not a helpful argument.

Please try to rebuff his points if you don't agree with them.

Re:Why I Left the U.S. 20 Years Ago and Why I Won't Be Comin... by leadingthenet on Saturday April 28, 2018 @05:46AM (#16946874)
Mate, no offense, but there’s nothing to rebuff. When you are that far gone, people should have the right to mock you. Spouting meaningless platitudes does not an argument make, and we’d only be feeding his stupidity by answering any of those, frankly, ridiculous points.

I mean, just look at the fantastic discussion your rebuff started.

Re:Why I Left the U.S. 20 Years Ago and Why I Won't Be Comin... by throwaway84742 on Saturday April 28, 2018 @06:06AM (#16946937)
“Far gone” is a matter of perspective. To me, you seem like you are “far gone”. And who’s to say that your perspective is more valid than mine.
Re:Why I Left the U.S. 20 Years Ago and Why I Won't Be Comin... by fwdpropaganda on Saturday April 28, 2018 @07:52AM (#16947238)
I know, these people are cartoonish. I thought they only existed in American movies.