News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by wccrawford on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @07:27AM (#1693928)
Sadly, pirates don't actually convince their friends to buy it. They help them pirate it.

He's right about doing what he can to provide features that pirates can't take advantage of, though. That's the only way to actually combat piracy.

Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by storm on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @08:28AM (#1694020)
> Sadly, pirates don't actually convince their friends to buy it. They help them pirate it.

Pirating software is often a pain - find a proper release, install, replace a binary, generate a key, avoid online services, seek out cracked updates (or go without them). If your time has value, it's hardly free. Do you really think everyone pirating anything is going through this process for every Tom, Dick and Harry they know, as opposed to just saying, "Yeah, it's $50 at Gamestop..."?

What the author is talking about sounds like the far more common scenario -- friends will see a pirated game being played (or just hear it being praised), and make a purchase later if they so desire (perhaps on services like Steam, where hordes of people who used to exclusive pirate games now periodically pay for the simple conveniences of being legit). And the pirates themselves are occasionally 'turned' by the kind of value-adds that the author is taking about. How many people who really liked the single-player modes in their pirate copy of MW2 didn't go legit so that they could play multiplayer?

Piracy can unquestionably lead to expanded mindshare and buzz, it's silly to assert that it merely spawns more piracy. Piracy of Photoshop isn't destroying Adobe's profit, it's securing it. How many legions of designers and photographers cut their teeth on a pirated version, in the process trained themselves to all its concepts, quirks and idioms, and later became a paid seat in a professional context (where using a pirated version is astonishingly stupid behaviour)?

Edit: This is clearly an emotional issue. Parent is getting a steady stream of upvotes for blithely making a generalization about how all pirates behave, whereas I saw a downvote faster than what I've wrote could even have been read.

Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by lhnz on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @08:42AM (#1694039)
I agree with others that the OP really over-promised by saying that pirates will convince friends to buy. However, you don't deserve to be down-voted. A large number of people pirating something often causes it to become popular enough to get many sales. Word-of-mouth is not always a pirate explaining to others how to get something for free, it's often them just saying something is 'good' (which for many people implies worth buying).
Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by _delirium on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @02:10PM (#1695235)
It's especially true in the indie-game sphere, where people get their recommendations from random reviews on blogs, mailing lists, wikis, forums, whatever. Lots of those reviews are not by people who paid for the game, but some people who read them might pay. Maybe not most of them, but often non-zero. It's useful enough that some indie-game devs are pretty liberal with their "review copies"; if you're going to write up even a blog blurb on a medium-traffic blog, they'll just send you a free copy and save you the hassle of pirating it.

Really the biggest likely pitfall facing indie-game developers is that they release their game and nobody notices or cares, not even enough to pirate it. There are a ton of indie games that come out every year that never rise out of obscurity, which is the main thing publicity attempts have to overcome, at least early on. Enough people pirating it to generate some forum/blog buzz is one possible way, like underground musicians who get their initial publicity via people trading mix tapes.

Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by sliverstorm on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @09:04PM (#1696465)
> Sadly, pirates don't actually convince their friends to buy it. They help them pirate it.

> Pirating software is often a pain

I agree with the first part. The second line is also true, but the cash value must be low. I am a student, and I will very often see students (pirates) helping their friends pirate Cadence Orcad. Sure, it's a pain, but it's not THAT much of a pain and a single license is several thousand dollars. (Heck, it might even be more- they don't list prices, because they don't sell to individuals!)

Orcad is a fantastic piece of software by the way. I'd happily give them lots of money if they'd sell it to me, and I had lots of money. (call me cheap, but I am guessing my annual income is probably on par with only a small handful of licences)

Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by gaius on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @11:23AM (#1694513)
Do you really think everyone pirating anything is going through this process for every Tom, Dick and Harry they know

Probably, yes. They're trading their time for social capital.

Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by Vivtek on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @10:08AM (#1694228)
That's the only way to actually combat piracy.

No. That's the only way to make money in an economic reality that copying is free. It's redefining what you sell so that it cannot be pirated because it's a different product/service to start with.

You're not combating piracy when you offer a non-copyable service - you're just redefining your terms to work with reality.

Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by zephyrfalcon on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @08:51AM (#1694050)
"Sadly, pirates don't actually convince their friends to buy it. They help them pirate it."

The article says:

> But what if that person likes that game, talks about it to his or her friends, and then I manage to convince three of them to buy the game?

The author is hoping that he can convince these friends to buy the game; he isn't suggesting that pirates do the convincing. In the next paragraph he describes how to do it:

> Instead of just relying on guilt tripping pirates into buying, or wasting time and money trying to stop them, I can offer online-only services that actually add to the game experience. Online level saving, centralized skins, friends lists and secure name verification for multiplayer. None of these features can be accessed by people with pirated versions of the game, and hopefully they can be features that turn pirates from thieves into potential customers.

Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by yason on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @09:48AM (#1694178)
I'm maybe 15 years behind the current trends but all games I've ever bought (when I was still buying games...) were carefully screened and test played using pirated sources. Piracy has always been the de facto news channel for new games: not magazines or demo disks. You had the game coming from your friends first and you saw it weeks or months later in a magazine.

Investing actually money into something as brittle and vague as a video game simply requires that I certainly know what I'm buying. Thus, the title must either be a few-in-a-decade known hit or tested with a pirated version.

If the situation is even remotely like that these days, game publishers are making their money because of piracy, not despite of it.

Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by jpdbaugh on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @10:51AM (#1694362)
I often find demos to be misleading of what the final product will be like. Games are expensive, at least for me, and demoing the final product is the only way I will know for sure that I am not going to waste $60 if I decide to buy something.
Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by _delirium on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @02:14PM (#1695248)
The 90s shareware approach was almost ideal for me from that perspective. I could play 1/3 of Doom and then decide if I wanted to buy the remaining 2/3 or not.
Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by jpdbaugh on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @02:32PM (#1695325)
I am not really sure why this died? Ten minute demos are just not enough time to judge a game.
Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by chc on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @03:17PM (#1695497)
It's the same thinking that leads to antipiracy misfeatures. They don't want to give away any more for free than they have to, even if it winds up hurting the game itself.
Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by patio11 on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @07:49AM (#1693963)
Put it online and downloading the client lets you pirate the game like downloading Firefox lets you pirate Basecamp.
Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by eli on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @09:10AM (#1694096)
What if it doesn't really make sense to add online or multiplayer support to the app/game? Then isn't it just the typical DRM anti-feature?

I'd be pretty annoyed if I couldn't play my fun new game on a plane because it needs to constantly connect to the internet to prove I didn't steal it.

Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by patio11 on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @09:44AM (#1694163)
As somebody who makes a living selling software, I do not consider the author getting paid a minor feature. Apologies for the inconvenience, take it up with 80% of your generation.
Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by tc23emp on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @01:43PM (#1695129)
Notch's success and that of other indie developers don't support the claim made by most game studios and their publishers that the weak market and rampant piracy is forcing them to take drastic measures.

If you look at Minecraft, it has the worst graphics possible and, in the Alpha that Notch is selling, half of the features don't work in multiplayer. The main thing the game has going for it is its limitless replay value with the ability to create and show off things (however tedious I think the average person would find the process).

Despite its flaws, Notch seems to be doing something right. He doesn't have much overhead and he can sell the game for cheap (although not very much so by indie standards). He doesn't even have an effective copy protection scheme. The login system is easily bypassed, and multiplayer servers hosted in "offline" mode are no different from a regular server.

Granted, there are previous incarnations of the game that did not take off and Notch has a lot of open promises about what he will deliver with the game. Yet, the game is in a state that is highly addictive and people have nothing but good things to say about it. Word of mouth and social media (namely youtube tutorials and showcasing) have rocketed sales.

Obviously, this game is a different caliber than most big budget games, but they are at a disadvantage to Notch's straightforward development style. Game studios are often rushed to finish their game and they need to see immediate success upon release. Yet, they are almost always still working out bugs. Beyond patching and token DLC, the game is considered final. Some games have even lost modding support despite how much value that adds to a game.

Blaming the current generation of consumers doesn't fit. There is an exponentially larger consumer base buying games. Most gamers are always ready for the next game and often games are sold on hype alone. Maybe this is an overstatement, but we have attained what is close to rabid consumerism. There is a lot of competition, but when a game hits, it sells big.

Could it be that there is something else rotten going on in the games industry? Look at the surefire success that is the Call of Duty series (even despite the supposed boycott). Activision apparently couldn't afford to properly take care of Infinity Ward and there was a huge falling out. Can this be explained by greed, incompetence, or what?

Even if piracy is to blame, games are already harder to pirate. You can probably fight it head on to a certain extent, but I doubt you can stop it. At some point, it will hurt business more than it will help. The type of article Notch has written here has become fashionable among indie developers. It makes them look good, while making big game studios appear to be at a loss. Maybe they are also trying to serve as an example of how you can rise above piracy concerns rather than getting hung up on them.

Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by eli on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @09:55AM (#1694194)
Well as somebody who buys software for a small company, I do not consider unobtrusive and transparent DRM a minor feature. If your licensing scheme is too much of a hassle, I will look elsewhere.
Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by v21 on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @10:30AM (#1694292)
I'm pro authors getting paid, but you can't expect users to like antifeatures. Such as an online mode that merely detracts from the game. If it adds more than it takes away, then users will be happy about it, even if the main reason you put it in was your own wallet.
Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by chc on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @03:01PM (#1695439)
If you deliberately make your software a pain in the ass for legitimate customers, your product had better be absolutely amazing or someone who treats their customers well can easily come along and do you one better just on that basis.
Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by eru on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @09:31AM (#1694134)
That's why the Minecraft creator's solution is sane. He does not block any features without network access. But some features only make sense with network access.
Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by mquander on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @09:39AM (#1694150)
I understand the perceptual difference (it's annoying when features that are already there are "taken away," and less annoying when new features just don't appear.) But is there an actual difference? The time he's spent on network-dependent features may have been spent on other, more interesting features for everyone if the networked features didn't also serve as piracy prophylaxis.
Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by nlawalker on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @10:28AM (#1694287)
Bingo. I worry about the state of gaming when the primary question on a developer's mind during design is "how can I make online servics a part of this game so I can actually make some money off of it?"
Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by eli on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @09:49AM (#1694179)
Yeah, I get it.

But it stinks that developers now have a bias towards online features (because they combat piracy) instead of potential offline features that are more useful or better serve customers.

Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by crystalis on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @04:46PM (#1695781)
If online support doesn't fit your app/game, add better offline support. This ends up meaning difficult to copy stuff, like included cloth maps or quality manuals. You could get crafty and convince the user to pay you extra money for, e.g., t-shirts, with a discount if they bought your game.
Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by NickPollard on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @08:55AM (#1694059)
I believe this is (most of the time) the best solution these days, but it's still starting from a position of assuming the customer is a criminal.

If you're not actually adding any useful internet-based features, then this is just another DRM system that will piss off paying customers when they want to play but don't have a net connection because they're using a laptop on a plane flight.

Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by mquander on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @09:05AM (#1694083)
What's wrong with assuming the customer is a criminal if the big majority of your customers are, in fact, criminals? (Presuming that by "customer" you just mean "person playing your game.")

The question should be: how do you account for the fact that your customers are criminals and still make money without crippling your game? Putting useful features online is a good answer to that question.

Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by dingy on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @09:22AM (#1694123)
Well, if I'm the (non-criminal) customer and you're the game producer, what's wrong with it is that you're making your problem my problem. It isn't, it shouldn't be and I'm not going to let it be (and no, I don't pirate, I just don't buy stuff I dislike).
Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by mquander on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @09:26AM (#1694130)
That's why I said "without crippling the game." You're right, though; most developers will make their problem your problem, either to a small degree (by making sure that some useful things are only accessible for authenticated online clients) or a large degree (requiring always-on connectivity, nutty DRM schemes.)

I don't think there's really anything "wrong" with that, though. It's not very fair, but that's how the world works. Given that people are going to continue to try making money from games, it seems like an optimal outcome.

Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by dingy on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @09:32AM (#1694136)
So, it's not fair but there's nothing wrong with it? I don't think we have the same definition of the word "wrong".
Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by mquander on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @09:33AM (#1694141)
I guess we don't.
Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by chc on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @03:11PM (#1695478)
I'm not sure it's an optimal outcome. It might help it some cases, but it definitely feeds the problem it's trying to solve. The less people like you, the less guilty they'll feel screwing you over. I don't pirate games, but pirating Activision titles would feel downright good.

It also often creates the paradox that pirates get a better experience. Once the pirates work around all your antifeatures, the pirated version is actually a better product than the one you're selling (which makes piracy even more tempting).

Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by frobozz on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @09:52AM (#1694187)
There are two reasons:

1) It drives your customers to your competitors

If you had a choice between a shop that detained you in an "interview room", and checked your bags, pockets and body cavities against the receipt, every single time you went there, and one that just had a few CCTV cameras, which would you choose?

2) It makes people think "If I'm going to be punished anyway, I might as well commit the crime"

In some countries (IIRC, both Finland & Netherlands do this), purchasers of recordable media are "treated as criminals" and pre-emptively fined for copying music (specifically music, not software). If I were subject to that kind of treatment, you bet I'd copy as much music as I could lay my hands on.

Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by dlytle on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @10:00AM (#1694209)
I helped my friends pirate the first 10 audiobooks of a series I love, by handing them a flash drive with the MP3s on it, and the condition that if they liked the series they should buy the new ones as they come out.

Now 6 of my friends (who never would have been hooked on the series otherwise) own legal versions of the two most recent novels starring our favorite wizard-detective.

Those sales would not have been made if they hadn't gotten a taste of the series beforehand. Sure, this situation isn't the rule, and they pirated 5x the books they've purchased... but 2 sales each is better than 0, and with 8-10 more books coming in the series, the author/publisher have come out far ahead.

Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by pilif on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @11:04AM (#1694423)
as a huge fan of audibooks myself: Can you tell me what series you are talking about?

(see? Another chance to hook somebody)

Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by dlytle on Thursday September 16, 2010 @12:05AM (#1696778)
The series in question is the Dresden Files by Jim Butcher, read by James Marsters, If you're an audiobook fan, I also recommend looking into GraphicAudio. Unabridged audiobooks with a full voice cast, music, and sound effects.

The Night Angel trilogy by Brent Weeks is good in GraphicAudio, as is Warbreaker by Brandon Sanderson. Warbreaker is stand-alone, so it may be a good starting point.

There are a few rough bits, but there always are; some sections with awkward musical choices, some re-used recognizable sound effects, but they're no more common than errors in standard audiobooks.

(Disclaimer: GraphicAudio books are abridged, but functionally unabridged. If it's raining, they play the sound of rain instead of having the narrator say "it was raining". By definition, that makes them abridged, despite no loss of content.)

Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by blaqsmith on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @03:15PM (#1695494)
Based on dlytle's description, he's likely talking about the Dresden Files series.
Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by jokermatt999 on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @09:07AM (#1694087)
That's actually not always true. Check out the reddit thread on this topic, and you'll see plenty of people who pirated first and then actually bought it. I know plenty of pirates use the "I try before I buy" line, but some of them actually do. You're right on your second sentence, but do you have anything whatsoever to back up your first?
Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by gyardley on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @09:11AM (#1694098)
Back when my company was using our analytics to track piracy for iPhone applications, we found that 1 out of 243 people who stole an application later installed a legitimate copy.

We stopped tracking piracy when we realized that we were getting into a cat-and-mouse game with application pirates and the feature wasn't worth the resources, but I can't imagine these stats have changed much since.

Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by jokermatt999 on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @09:17AM (#1694110)
And how many of those people would have bought the application if it wasn't available to pirate? I'm guessing it would still be a much smaller number. There's a massive gap between being able to get something for completely free and having to pay for it.
Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by scott_s on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @09:48AM (#1694177)
Thank you for bringing data into the discussion.
Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by steveklabnik on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @10:37AM (#1694321)
While I agree with you that data is nice, this data in particular doesn't say a whole lot. It's like saying "1mm pay Google for the enterprise version of Google apps, and 100mm don't. They're leaving so much revenue on the table!" When discussing freemium, nobody talks about those who choose the free plan as 'pirates', even though they are doing the exact same thing that 'pirates' do.
Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by scott_s on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @10:51AM (#1694363)
It brings more to the table than the hand-waving that I see all over piracy discussions. And I don't see how you connect the parent's post with your freemium discussion - he made no such conclusions from his data.
Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by steveklabnik on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @10:57AM (#1694383)
It's true, he didn't. But I've seen others draw the same conclusion from similar data before, so just pointing out that fallacy ahead of time.
Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by flannell on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @10:40AM (#1694329)
I agree with you. However, truly outstanding apps will always do well. I downloaded Angry Birds Lite to my itouch, played the first few levels and promptly bought it. I also did the same with Tower Madness. There was an article on a flash games company that could detect when the app was running on illegal web servers. It would display an advert inside the game saying where it came from which resulted in a spike of traffic and revenue for the original owners. I believe a few developers are now treating the pirates as salesmen to reach a larger buying audience. It's not ideal, just goes with the territory
Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by mquander on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @09:02AM (#1694072)
I don't understand the logic at all here. Do you have some reason for believing that?
Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by njharman on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @11:27AM (#1694529)
> Sadly, pirates don't actually convince their friends to buy it.

Untrue, I have direct personal proof to the contrary ;)