News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by eli on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @09:10AM (#1694096)
What if it doesn't really make sense to add online or multiplayer support to the app/game? Then isn't it just the typical DRM anti-feature?

I'd be pretty annoyed if I couldn't play my fun new game on a plane because it needs to constantly connect to the internet to prove I didn't steal it.

Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by patio11 on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @09:44AM (#1694163)
As somebody who makes a living selling software, I do not consider the author getting paid a minor feature. Apologies for the inconvenience, take it up with 80% of your generation.
Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by tc23emp on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @01:43PM (#1695129)
Notch's success and that of other indie developers don't support the claim made by most game studios and their publishers that the weak market and rampant piracy is forcing them to take drastic measures.

If you look at Minecraft, it has the worst graphics possible and, in the Alpha that Notch is selling, half of the features don't work in multiplayer. The main thing the game has going for it is its limitless replay value with the ability to create and show off things (however tedious I think the average person would find the process).

Despite its flaws, Notch seems to be doing something right. He doesn't have much overhead and he can sell the game for cheap (although not very much so by indie standards). He doesn't even have an effective copy protection scheme. The login system is easily bypassed, and multiplayer servers hosted in "offline" mode are no different from a regular server.

Granted, there are previous incarnations of the game that did not take off and Notch has a lot of open promises about what he will deliver with the game. Yet, the game is in a state that is highly addictive and people have nothing but good things to say about it. Word of mouth and social media (namely youtube tutorials and showcasing) have rocketed sales.

Obviously, this game is a different caliber than most big budget games, but they are at a disadvantage to Notch's straightforward development style. Game studios are often rushed to finish their game and they need to see immediate success upon release. Yet, they are almost always still working out bugs. Beyond patching and token DLC, the game is considered final. Some games have even lost modding support despite how much value that adds to a game.

Blaming the current generation of consumers doesn't fit. There is an exponentially larger consumer base buying games. Most gamers are always ready for the next game and often games are sold on hype alone. Maybe this is an overstatement, but we have attained what is close to rabid consumerism. There is a lot of competition, but when a game hits, it sells big.

Could it be that there is something else rotten going on in the games industry? Look at the surefire success that is the Call of Duty series (even despite the supposed boycott). Activision apparently couldn't afford to properly take care of Infinity Ward and there was a huge falling out. Can this be explained by greed, incompetence, or what?

Even if piracy is to blame, games are already harder to pirate. You can probably fight it head on to a certain extent, but I doubt you can stop it. At some point, it will hurt business more than it will help. The type of article Notch has written here has become fashionable among indie developers. It makes them look good, while making big game studios appear to be at a loss. Maybe they are also trying to serve as an example of how you can rise above piracy concerns rather than getting hung up on them.

Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by eli on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @09:55AM (#1694194)
Well as somebody who buys software for a small company, I do not consider unobtrusive and transparent DRM a minor feature. If your licensing scheme is too much of a hassle, I will look elsewhere.
Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by v21 on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @10:30AM (#1694292)
I'm pro authors getting paid, but you can't expect users to like antifeatures. Such as an online mode that merely detracts from the game. If it adds more than it takes away, then users will be happy about it, even if the main reason you put it in was your own wallet.
Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by chc on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @03:01PM (#1695439)
If you deliberately make your software a pain in the ass for legitimate customers, your product had better be absolutely amazing or someone who treats their customers well can easily come along and do you one better just on that basis.
Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by eru on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @09:31AM (#1694134)
That's why the Minecraft creator's solution is sane. He does not block any features without network access. But some features only make sense with network access.
Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by mquander on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @09:39AM (#1694150)
I understand the perceptual difference (it's annoying when features that are already there are "taken away," and less annoying when new features just don't appear.) But is there an actual difference? The time he's spent on network-dependent features may have been spent on other, more interesting features for everyone if the networked features didn't also serve as piracy prophylaxis.
Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by nlawalker on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @10:28AM (#1694287)
Bingo. I worry about the state of gaming when the primary question on a developer's mind during design is "how can I make online servics a part of this game so I can actually make some money off of it?"
Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by eli on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @09:49AM (#1694179)
Yeah, I get it.

But it stinks that developers now have a bias towards online features (because they combat piracy) instead of potential offline features that are more useful or better serve customers.

Re:'How piracy works' according to Minecraft creator by crystalis on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @04:46PM (#1695781)
If online support doesn't fit your app/game, add better offline support. This ends up meaning difficult to copy stuff, like included cloth maps or quality manuals. You could get crafty and convince the user to pay you extra money for, e.g., t-shirts, with a discount if they bought your game.