Be bookstore owner. Set the value to be twice as much as comparable neighbor property. Get bought by B&N. Buy property next to you, move your books, pocket the difference.
> I get that making $15m for my house would make me rich, but this is our first home as a family and all our memories are here.
Price it accordingly. :)
Yes, the whole idea is that the tax is much lower (1% maybe) than the value of the land.
Also, some regulations might be added, that eg. a person who got forcefully bought-out, has a year or two to move out, just to make it less convenient to use it "aggressively", while allowing wise long-term investments.
I don't see this as very helpful. The above poster views their home as something to protect from the market. It is a safehaven for family and friends and community connections, it is something that holds all the most important things in life and so it is above market mechanisms to the extent possible. Seeing this and purposefully advocating a system which forces them to put an actual price on their family memories supposes that there should be zero aspects of our life which are safe from market mechanisms. That seems like an impoverished way of looking at life.
Owning a piece of land is not really owning it. Not in the USA, and most of the world. You are having a "privilege" of using the land vs. paying some taxes.
That being said I don't approve of home taxes in the US. The taxes should be applied equally on all citizens to provide the required amenities (roads, cables, sanitary, etc...) The money should go to maintain the relevant infrastructure.
I'm not sure if the taxes you pay on your home value in the US goes to relevant infrastructure; or else (nor do I really care!)
Eg. I buy a property that I want to use as a factory. Some people who work for me move their own accomodation to be close to my factory. I spend absolutely tons of time and money filling my factory with machines, some of which are bolted to walls or have to be constructed inside the warehouse.
The price I'm willing to accept for this property isn't the price of the property, it's the cost to me of moving all my people and goods and rebuilding things. Plus the cost of the interruption to my production flow etc.
Caveat I know nothing about manufacturing but the point is more general, property isn't even close to fungible.
Tesla wouldn't sell their hyperfactory thing for the price they bought it for!
Everyone would be overpaying tax to the extent that their reliance on property isn't fungible, I'm not sure what the implications of that are but property is so fundamental and so much money that they'd be huge.
If I understand, your argument is that self-assessed taxes would eliminate investment efficiency.
The property owner should factor transaction costs into their own value of the building. This would increase their assessment of the land-value, and increase their taxes. This works because, keeping land valuations constant, the one with the highest transaction costs is the one who can derive the most efficiency from the land.
Then maybe the rule is that you will be forced to sell to anyone who pays you N × the value you self-assessed at, where N > 1. E.g. if transaction costs average 20%, you have to sell to anyone who will pay 1.2 times your self-assessed value.
I think the real issue is whether is promotes certain uses of land over others, and whether that's problematic.
Everyone overpays, but they overpay in proportion to how sticky their business is to a specific property. It would take someone who knows more about commercial property to dissect what businesses would get destroyed by that.
Imagine you live in a neighborhood with deep community or family ties. Someone down the street wins the lottery/makes an 8-figure exit and wants to buy out the block for a mega mansion. Can tax rates be low enough for you to raise your own valuation to "defend" your middle class home against vast wealth? What does that do to local government revenues?
The very rich regularly spend $15m or more on a home. If Jeff Bezos came by my house and decided he liked the view, I would have to start paying $300k in taxes or move (if 2% tax). I get that making $15m for my house would make me rich, but this is our first home as a family and all our memories are here. I shouldn't be forced to choose like that - protection from arbitrarily being forced out of my home is one of the main reasons to own a home in the first place.