News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:TSB Bank: Botched upgrade has left customers unable to ac... by FLUX-YOU on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @08:29AM (#16911946)
Besides simply quitting, what can a civil engineer do to blow the whistle on a company that is cutting corners for a bridge?
Re:TSB Bank: Botched upgrade has left customers unable to ac... by wlesieutre on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @11:01AM (#16913135)
First you pass the FE exam, then you work for several years under a certified PE, then you take the PE exam. It's an 8-hour open book test, though IIRC for structural engineers it might actually be a 16-hour affair over 2 days.

If you pass, you get a stamp, which lets you approve drawings as a certified PE.

If you believe something is not designed to adequate standards, as a PE it is on you to not put your seal on the drawings. They can't build the bridge without an engineer doing this.

If you're taking about options when some other engineer has already approved the design, I'm not sure what the best course is. Maybe bring your concerns to the engineer in question and work from there.

Or if the design is fine but a contractor is cutting corners in construction and not building to the specifications, you could potentially engineer a new design to reinforce the problems, or you could make them take it out and build it right.

Re:TSB Bank: Botched upgrade has left customers unable to ac... by scottfr on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @10:26AM (#16912811)
In the US civil engineers must go through a multi-year certification process that involves a significant amount of on the job work in addition to standardized examination before they are labelled a Professional Engineer (PE).

As a PE, they can face significant legal repercussions for errors in work they approve.

The benefit to the PE is that many Civil Engineering projects are legally required to have a PE design/approve them. The PE literally has a physical stamp they use to stamp blueprints and designs when they approve it. Work won't proceed without that stamp.

So, if a PE refused to approve a bridge design, presumably it would be very difficult to find another PE who would approve it (especially given the record of the first PE rejecting the plans) and the work would not proceed.

Re:TSB Bank: Botched upgrade has left customers unable to ac... by ryandrake on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @11:11AM (#16913208)
If software engineers could potentially face legal repercussions or jail time for serious errors, unsound technical judgment, or bad ethical decisions, it would enable a lot more push-back on these poorly-planned projects and corner cutting. I've always thought it was pretty sad that lawyers are held to higher professional and ethical standards than software engineers.
Re:TSB Bank: Botched upgrade has left customers unable to ac... by EpicEng on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @12:01PM (#16913750)
> I've always thought it was pretty sad that lawyers are held to higher professional and ethical standards than software engineers.

I think that's a bit silly. The vast majority of software is trivial stuff and no real harm is caused when something goes sideways. Few of us work on safety critical systems. When a lawyer screws up it often does a lot of harm and they are also inherently bound by our legal systems. Corruption and negligence/incompetence in this area lessens the public's faith in those systems.

Lawyers and civil engineer inherently take on far greater responsibility than your average Joe Schmoe programmer writing yet another CRUD app.

Re:TSB Bank: Botched upgrade has left customers unable to ac... by skolemtotem on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @03:07PM (#16915616)
That's true, but what about the software engineers who do build world-changing stuff? I think that we should definitely hold them to a higher standard than we currently do.
Re:TSB Bank: Botched upgrade has left customers unable to ac... by EpicEng on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @07:37PM (#16917613)
>That's true, but what about the software engineers who do build world-changing stuff?

Yeah I can get behind that. I work in biotech/cancer diagnostics/prognostics and we could definitely afford a higher standard, especially around the core stuff (e.g. the CV/algorithms people, but also the typical IT end of things.)

Re:TSB Bank: Botched upgrade has left customers unable to ac... by walshemj on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @12:20PM (#16913954)
Also a freshly minted CE (PE) is not the one signing off on a proper big bridge that's going to be a Partner
Re:TSB Bank: Botched upgrade has left customers unable to ac... by danpalmer on Tuesday April 24, 2018 @08:42AM (#16912017)
They can "blow the whistle".

This could involve going to the press, to a standards body in the country, to the government, to their union or industry representative body.

In the UK there are laws protecting whistleblowers who take actions like this.