Also, people who are trained already can always go into academia or return to Europe. These movements aren't permanent by nature.
That's great for those other areas, but the open letter in question is about machine learning.
> It doesn't actually 'deplete' academia except in the short run, unless the supply of students who want to do research becomes fully tapped out.
... or the very limited supply of established researchers who can train them is tapped out. Also, "fully tapped out" is a squishy notion; you can always lower your recruitment standards, with obvious consequences.
But there is no need to get into hypotheticals here:
https://www.theguardian.com/science/2017/nov/02/big-tech-fir...
> people who are trained already can always go into academia or return to Europe
But why would they want to? They chose to move away for a reason, so something would have to change for them to change their mind. What would that be?
The authors of the open letter seem to think that a European AI hub could be that thing.
Tenure is about the only carrot academia has to dangle
Make that American companies and the problem, from an academic perspective, is that they recruit away students and researchers from academia. That works for a few years, but longer term, the argument goes, it depletes academia to the point that new talent can no longer be trained... by academia.
At that point, the companies wishing to keep recruiting will create their own training facilities and/or step up collaboration with academic institutions. That's where the American part comes in: if the existing talent has all gone to the US and those making the decisions have been there all along, they are likely to focus their training efforts on the US.
On top of that, you have the well-publicized problems with data collection by foreign entities and local tax avoidance, which are indeed political.