News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by ZeroGravitas on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @12:00PM (#1691016)
Android is only free of carrier abuse if you're geeky enough. However, Apple is only free of carrier abuse if you're affluent enough. The average joe is getting shafted either way. (Though, to continue the class theme, note how offended people are that it's NASCAR apps that they can't uninstall, as opposed to the stock market apps they can't uninstall from Apple). Remember when Sony charged more to remove the junk they themselves put on their machines? The subsidies earned by these bits of software lowered the price for those who would struggle to afford them otherwise and for the geeks who repave as an automatic response, similar to how people spending at the overpriced hotel minibar reduce the room prices for everyone else.

If this is actually considered important for folk in the US, then they're going to have to stop the Apple fanboys in the media using it as a stick to beat Google with and face up to the reality that Apple has failed to change the carrier business model too, just as Google's Nexus One failed. I seem to recall that just like the Nexus One, the iPhone was supposed to be sold direct to consumers at the full unsubsidized price.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by orangecat on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @12:20PM (#1691092)
I seem to recall that just like the Nexus One, the iPhone was supposed to be sold direct to consumers at the full unsubsidized price.

Excellent point. It was sold unsubsidized initially, but people were apoplectic about spending $600 for a phone. Apple quickly realized that joining the subsidy model was better than fighting it, so they announced the price "cut" on the 3G model and got glowing press, while hardly anyone noticed that with the monthly rate increase customers would be paying more over two years.

Apple has far better taste than the carriers, to be sure. But both agree that you should not have control over "your" hardware.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by kylec on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @01:33PM (#1691417)
It may have been unsubsidized, but it was still locked to AT&T and only available with a 2-year contract with an ETF. It was basically the cost of an unsubsidized without any of the benefit.
Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by SoftwareMaven on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @04:16PM (#1692102)
There's a big difference between the NASCAR app and Apple stock market app. It is exceedingly clear that the NASCAR app was bought by somebody outside of the phone chain (me, manufacturer, service provider) and forced on me. The Apple stock app is a goofy app the manufacturer put on to make sure the home screen wasn't empty.

Yes, it annoys me I have to have a folder of "stuff I don't care about" on my iPhone, but I know Apple and/or AT&T didn't put it there to pad their pockets at my expense and that makes all the difference.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by ZeroGravitas on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @04:46AM (#1693706)
Are you sure that they didn't just think "most of our customers would like this" and simply not bother expending any energy to allow people offended by its existance to remove it? Hanlon's razor and all that? And probably the same thought process Apple used for not making its built in apps removable, more work for them and who really cares so just don't bother?

I'm not in the US so I've no first hand experience so maybe this app is some kind of spyware but I'm not sure how spamming people with sports coverage works as a business model and I've seen various people quite pleased at one or other of the "crapware" things they've got. (It seems like a killer app for the iPad is some baseball app, so I can see how people might think that sports coverage is something people actually want.)

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by grhino on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @02:22PM (#1691642)
"people spending at the overpriced hotel minibar reduce the room prices for everyone else" only works in a very competitive marketplace where prices are necessarily driven down by competition. Otherwise, the hotel just figured out how to wring out more profit by simply offering an overpriced minibar.
Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by Terretta on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @12:24PM (#1691109)
> Android is only free of carrier abuse if you're geeky enough. However, Apple is only free of carrier abuse if you're affluent enough.

Not sure about that dichotomy: unsubsidized, both cost roughly the same, and for both, root/jailbreaks are free.

Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by ZeroGravitas on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @12:32PM (#1691159)
I think you're perhaps only comparing the Android handsets that get featured on sites like engadget. They'll occasionally laugh at some low-end phone and wonder aloud who on earth would buy something like that but generally they just ignore them. Apple has as much intention of fighting for that market as they do of entering the netbook space.
Re:IPhone vs Android? No. We're fighting the wrong fight by biafra on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @07:26AM (#1693925)
"Android is only free of carrier abuse if you're geeky enough."

Or if your carriers behave. In most parts of the world they do nowadays.