News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:HDCP master key allegedly posted by thehodge on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @04:12AM (#1689890)
I bought my first Blue-Ray the other day and the experience was terrible, I put the disk in and nothing happened.. I tried to play it in windows media center, no ball.. not in VLC.. there was no player included on the disk.

I had to download a 300meg trial of PowerDVD just to play a film I'd already paid for (I also had to update my graphics card for some reason, the computer had been playing HD content for months without needing that).

That will be the last Blue-Ray disk I buy..

Re:HDCP master key allegedly posted by illumin8 on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @09:45AM (#1690500)
The experience on Blu-Ray is terrible. I have to sit through as much as 20 minutes of unskippable commercials before I get to the menu screen. They even show you commercials about how great movies are on Blu-Ray - even though they should know you already are a customer because you're watching a Blu-Ray. Not only that, some of the commercials are streamed over the Internet, which means they use your bandwidth without asking permission to download an unskippable commercial.

The experience is getting a bit ridiculous, and I personally hope someone writes a DeCSS for Blu-Ray so that we can uncripple this format.

Btw, I don't actually buy any Blu-Ray disks, I just have my Netflix account enabled for Blu-Ray and watch most movies in that format since it looks better on my HDTV.

Re:HDCP master key allegedly posted by reduxredacted on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @01:39PM (#1691450)
I personally hope someone writes a DeCSS for Blu-Ray so that we can uncripple this format.

I've been using AnyDVD HD for a few years, but I have not had a Blu-Ray reader or writer until a couple of days ago and I have no Blu-Ray discs yet (Netflix, hurry up!). AnyDVD works great on DVDs and claims to work with Blu-Ray and HD-DVD formatted content. It's not free, unfortunately, but it's supposed to uncripple the format.

And before I get to far: I'm not a pirate, my use of AnyDVD HD is simple: I have a single SageTV Media Server (HTPC/DVR software) and I use extenders to play all of my video content on three televisions (meaning my TVs have one tiny low-power box yet all of my TVs can play a DVD or watch recorded content and live TV from my noisy HTPC tucked away in a rack in my basement). Without AnyDVD, I can't put a DVD in the basement server and play it on an extender upstairs. I was hoping to do the same with my new Blu-Ray player.

Re:HDCP master key allegedly posted by illumin8 on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @03:02PM (#1691814)
I think the problem with Blu-Ray, and AnyDVD has this issue as well, is that every disc has a slightly modified copy protection scheme that requires additional hacking to make a copy of it. I believe this requires a company like Slysoft, that makes AnyDVD, to constantly release updates for every new movie that is released.

For this reason, I doubt we'll ever see a public domain solution like DeCSS arrive. It's too bad.

Re:HDCP master key allegedly posted by reduxredacted on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @03:44PM (#1691991)
... and Slysoft releases new versions about as often as the folks who write No Script do. Thankfully, for a while, they had a lifetime upgrade policy.

The funny thing is that I would have been a Blu-Ray early adopter if I didn't see this mess coming. I can't believe my parents purchased a player before I did.

Re:HDCP master key allegedly posted by timdorr on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @11:28AM (#1690886)
To be slightly fair (and only slightly because I still think Blu-Ray sucks), Netflix does often get separate rental copies of movies that differ from the store-bought versions. They usually have more extraneous crap in front of the movie, since they are making less money off them in the long run.

But the load times alone make me want to throw my Blu-Ray player out of the window. It's a mind-numbingly slow experience in every way.

Re:HDCP master key allegedly posted by msisk6 on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @11:57AM (#1690998)
The load time with my old Sony Blu-Ray player was the same -- horribly slow. Unusable, IMHO.

Then I got a PlayStation 3. It made the kids happy and is radically faster playing Blu-Ray discs. If you're not a gamer be sure to get the optional "normal" bluetooth remote and you'll be all set.

Re:HDCP master key allegedly posted by wwortiz on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @12:58PM (#1691261)
I have a ps3 as well and most of my experiences with bluray have been pretty much the same as dvd with the exception of terminator 2 (skynet edition I think) which took forever to load.

The real problem is that I can't see much of a difference between the dvd version of a movie and the bluray version, if I have a choice for the same price I probably will buy bluray but otherwise the dvd upscaling works just as well for me.

This experience of quality differs greatly than that of a regular xvid rip and a hidef h264 rip which are actually quite noticeable.

Re:HDCP master key allegedly posted by illumin8 on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @02:47PM (#1691746)
The load times on my Sony PS3 are not that bad... But, I once had a Blu-Ray ask me if I wanted to download an update to it, and I was forced to download the update before I was able to watch the movie.

I think the bottom line is that Sony and the Blu-Ray disk manufacturers are treating our player devices like they own them. This is the same kind of thinking that caused the Sony Rootkit fiasco. What would people do if they found out that a Blu-Ray update caused their player to start reporting every movie they watched to a server (it probably already does)?

Re:HDCP master key allegedly posted by viraptor on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @05:00AM (#1689960)
> That will be the last Blue-Ray disk I buy..

I wouldn't be so sure. This is exactly the experience I got in the first year of DVDs being available. (although the player was a bit lighter ;) ) After some time we got proper software for Windows and after that, there was DeCSS.

Just give it time. If there is useful content on Blue-Ray, people will use it and the experience will improve.

Re:HDCP master key allegedly posted by reduxredacted on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @02:04PM (#1691568)
Just give it time. If there is useful content on Blue-Ray, people will use it and the experience will improve.

I thought we would have been there by now. DeCSS came out at about the time my parents upgraded from VHS to DVD. My parents just purchased a Blu-Ray player, so I'm thinking ... any day now. People have commented on how long it's taken to get the HDMI master key, but I'd argue it hasn't been that long. Despite some theoretical attack methods being published as early as 2001, there wasn't any reason because HDCP/HDMI was exotic for quite some time. Going back to the "My Parents" analogy: their first device to ever have an HDMI port on it was purchased earlier this summer. Both Panasonic devices, yet my dad has to power cycle the blu-ray player occasionally because the TV won't pick the picture up.

Here's my theory on how consumer electronic DRM cracking: 1) DRM or other scheme is created. It ticks off geeks/enthusiasts, but they largely deal with it. ...2) Despite itself, eventually it gains critical mass and a bunch of those geek's non-geeky parents buy devices and experience the same trouble. ...3) Geek children get constant phone calls from parents about why their new stuff doesn't work as well as their old stuff and ask said Geek Children to come over and fix it because they don't know what an HDCP Error is. ...4) One or more geeks get irritated enough with the phone calls to finally test that theoretical attack. ...5) Geeks everywhere find custom firmware for their parent's televisions and players and permanently solve the problem, while also recommending to their other non-technical friends precisely which model of TV and Blu-Ray to buy based entirely on its ability to have the play-back destroying copy-protection removed. The last part hasn't happened yet, but one can dream.

Re:HDCP master key allegedly posted by sofuture on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @08:51AM (#1690318)
Right, the experience of being treated like a criminal will improve. Their shackled product won't.
Re:HDCP master key allegedly posted by viraptor on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @09:14AM (#1690379)
On one hand-side - yes, you're right. On the other - right now you have a choice of not seeing the movie at all, or maybe seeing it correctly in the next month thanks to this key.

One step at a time.

Also, there's a whole industry around copy-protection which won't go away in one day. Pretty much the best we can do right now, is make is obsolete by proving DRM is useless, while they will try to prove otherwise. DVD-s right now are a nice compromise where they did their job™, and we get the content as if it was not locked. (of course you still cannot skip the intros on "official players", but that's just an education issue - for example mplayer can play the movie itself without the added marketing crap)

Re:HDCP master key allegedly posted by reduxredacted on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @02:14PM (#1691615)
Pretty much the best we can do right now, is make is obsolete by proving DRM is useless

The proof is in their own studies, really ... if they believe them. According to Big Media, piracy rates are incredible. It takes a few words in Google to find that everything that has ever been put behind DRM is available without it, for free (illegally, of course). The negative effects of DRM schemes are huge (see rest of comments).

There would be so many very cool things that have nothing to do with piracy if DRM wasn't part of the equation. And they can be done right now by breaking US law and circumventing whatever scheme is in place.

Re:HDCP master key allegedly posted by flannell on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @05:03AM (#1689963)
I guess Microsoft is still reeling about losing the HD format war to Sony! tbh, I think everyone knows that video streaming is the future and not physical disks. I give the format two years.
Re:HDCP master key allegedly posted by mikemol on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @08:56AM (#1690335)
You know, some of us like to be able to watch a large block of multimedia data multiple times without chewing through bandwidth allocation, or spending exorbitant amounts of money on a high-end DOCSIS or crap-hardware VDSL connection.

I have several Blu-Ray discs, but I've loaned them (and my PS3) to my parents until I get around to getting a BD drive for my Linux box. I do miss watching video in 720p, though; interlaced DVD is unpleasant, to say the least.

Hulu and boxee would be nice for some things, if the streaming servers for baseball games wouldn't get bogged down, or something causes a stutter or pause as bandwidth runs thin.

Also, I get poor cell signal in my new ground-floor apartment, so my $80/mo cell bill providing service to my smartphone isn't doing me any good. I switched to using Google Voice for the time being, but that doesn't well if something's hogging bandwidth. (Just because I can rate control going out, doesn't mean I can rate control what's trying to come in from the other side of that pipe.)

I wired my apartment to avoid wifi noise, but 6Mb/s DSL just isn't good enough for some common network multitasking activities. DOCSIS in apartment contexts is a horrible choice; you quickly get too many people on the same loop. VDSL may or may not be available; tech says one thing after a test, phone company's system says another. With VDSL, though, I'll get tied to a crap router with a built-in 802.1x identifying key, so I can't use my own setup.

Re:HDCP master key allegedly posted by fragmede on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @06:26PM (#1692569)
>(Just because I can rate control going out, doesn't mean I can rate control what's trying to come in from the other side of that pipe.)

Rate control of what's trying to come in from the other side of the pipe is half the point of putting voip traffic in its own QOS class. (The other half being rate control of data going out.) You may not be able to for some reason, but any good QOS system should let you do that.

Re:HDCP master key allegedly posted by beaumartinez on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @05:56AM (#1690044)
Two years? Yeah, because the whole world has cheap access to 10 Mbaud internet connection.
Re:HDCP master key allegedly posted by Maakuth on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @06:21AM (#1690080)
Good point. Bluray will probably be the last optical media we'll have for movies, but I don't think it'll get replaced completely very soon, as there's a lot of places with consumers willing to pay for HD content, but without great enough bandwidth to stream them from the web.
Re:HDCP master key allegedly posted by joey_bananas on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @07:01AM (#1690143)
I bet 99% of all people who might be interested in Blu-Ray does.
Re:HDCP master key allegedly posted by omnigoat on Wednesday September 15, 2010 @01:17AM (#1693389)
Hi! I live in Australia, where the majority of people on ADSL2+ have speeds less than or equal to 4mb/s. Due to the geography (technically, topography) of our country, high-speed internet is particularly tricky to roll-out. Not for perhaps four years more will we have any speeds greater than there are now.

So your comment sounds particularly naive, in this part of the world.

Re:HDCP master key allegedly posted by petercooper on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @10:00AM (#1690555)
I ostensibly have a 12Mbps connection, yet only get between 2-6Mbps depending on the time of day due to contention. And I live in an area with reasonably good broadband.

Things have a long way to go before a majority of westerners have access to solid, reliable 10Mbps connections.

Re:HDCP master key allegedly posted by rue on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @10:36AM (#1690689)
> And I live in an area with reasonably good broadband.

Clearly you do not.

Re:HDCP master key allegedly posted by petercooper on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @12:53PM (#1691242)
You can't know that without knowing where I live. It's reasonably good by British standards, though perhaps not in an absolute sense.

My connection is somewhat above the surveyed "average" speeds and stability for the UK, as frequently reported in the media here. One such story puts the average true throughput of a 10-12Mbps DSL connection at around 3.3Mbps: http://www.digitalspy.co.uk/digitaltv/news/a251311/uks-avera... .. As mine is usually around 5-6Mbps (though dropping to 2-3 at peak, sometimes) my connection is, I believe, "reasonably good" by national standards.

Re:HDCP master key allegedly posted by rue on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @06:15PM (#1692536)
> You can't know that without knowing where I live.

Yes, I can. It is an absolute measure. Yours may well be well above the average for the region or even the nation, but it is still not good. Mind, slightly tongue-in-cheek since estimating actual required level of service is a bit tricky. I meant it mostly in the sense of "do not let the telcos tell you that is 'good enough'".

Personally, I would put the "reasonably good" barrier for this day and age at about 20/10Mbps. (I pay about 40€ for a nominal 100Mbps - which, in a quick test right now, gives me 24/13Mbps to/from the UK, over Wi-Fi LAN).

Re:HDCP master key allegedly posted by nuclear_eclipse on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @01:17PM (#1691342)
I think the missing phrase is relative compared to the average. "Good" broadband in many parts (the majority?) of the US is still crap shoved upon citizens with no other choice but dialup.
Re:HDCP master key allegedly posted by petercooper on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @04:00PM (#1692053)
It's not missing - the word "reasonably" covers it with "reasonable" meaning fair, average, not excessive.
Re:HDCP master key allegedly posted by pinksoda on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @09:56AM (#1690543)
FIOS offers up to 50Mbps now in the US. Several Asian countries have had 50-100Mbps for years.
Re:HDCP master key allegedly posted by ZachPruckowski on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @11:43AM (#1690937)
Yeah, if you happen to live in a newly-wired building in a major city or suburb. But if you're talking about replacing TV or DVD/Blu-Ray, it's not about what the fastest guys have, it's about the slowest 5-10% have.

Even if you assume "everyone [and that's 1/3 the country] still on dial-up is such a late-adopter they're not even interested in HD yet", a lot of that broadband is less than 1 Mbps. And many broadband consumers have monthly bandwidth caps.

People with >1Mbps uncapped broadband is probably too small of a market to make purely digital distribution viable.

Re:HDCP master key allegedly posted by reduxredacted on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @02:20PM (#1691639)
Yeah, if you happen to live in a newly-wired building in a major city or suburb.

The latter part of your statement is true. They're not wiring up rural areas. However, I live in a neighborhood that doesn't have a home newer than 30 years and am receiving AT&T U-Verse, 20Mbps down (and consistent).

I don't believe the future is in shiny discs. The near-future probably isn't in exclusive streaming video, but the longer term likely is. We're a few technological break-thrus away, perhaps, but for what my opinion is worth... I believe it'll get there.

Re:HDCP master key allegedly posted by ZachPruckowski on Friday September 17, 2010 @07:21AM (#1700717)
Yeah, but that's private homes. It's one thing to drag a cable to a house, it's another thing to rewire an apartment complex.