Fun fact: This seems like a very American thing to me (that is being imported into my culture). Where I live apprenticeships (2/3/4 years work and school) are frequently required for assembly work and the like, and has usually been seen as a solid way to make a good living. In the last 10-15 years there has been a pronounced rise of arrogance against journeyman ("Gesellen" i.e. those who completed an apprenticeship) and state-certified technicians ("Techniker" i.e. those who completed an extra two years of school on top of an apprenticeship; this usually entails a bunch of other additional qualifications and certifications); parents act like their children are failures if they don't manage to study at an university and put immense pressure on them.
Rationally speaking that doesn't make any sense; Gesellen and Techniker work full-time years earlier than anyone who goes to university and often climbed the pay ladder quite a few steps in those years as well. Depending on the profession they make good money. In some professions even a lot (e.g. industrial field service can pay six figures all things considered).
University and Abitur (the highest level of secondary school) aren't for everyone, but parents act as if it were so, often with detrimental effects to their children.
In my city for example the number of college students doubled within the last 10 years. Rents for small apartments got raised accordingly, obviously, and this put more pressure on blue collar workers to put their children into college.
Here’s hoping I’ve just ran into a round of bad eggs.
Otherwise I’m glad to hear about jobs that cannot be automated away.
And hence why programmers decided to appropriate the word "engineer" for their title...
Toyota's approach is different in that it takes in more input from people on the manufactoring line who are actually doing the work. It also helps that when they were getting up and running, their geography meant that pretty much everything they need is in a relatively short distance and they can make changes without needing to worry about long shipping times.
The "Big Three" which cares more about central control of the product and using their size to get everything done more cheaply. Their advantage is having the world's largest economy available to them so they have many suppliers to choose from.
Tesla's approach is that they're better at the technology and if you can throw more computers/robots at the problem eventually you can conquer anything. I think they're learning that this isn't always true, but it's still one of those cases where they're going to reach for the toolset they know best first.
But there is a difference between a time served machine tool setter and some one working on the line attaching wheels.
It takes an enormous amount of focus and concentration, the ability to learn complex routines quickly, to create efficiencies without breaking rythyms or rules. All while being payed less and treated like a second class employee.
Why is toyota different? Because they dont think like this. Line workers are thought of highly. Their ideas are integrated into the system. Most of all they are not disposable cogs