News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mac OS X Public Beta by city41 on Monday September 13, 2010 @04:23PM (#1688080)
> Kudos to Apple for taking the risk

Apple has always taken the risk, it is one thing I love about them. You only need to look to their processor choices to see that: 68k -> PPC -> Intel. All transitions were just as painful as the OS9 -> OSX transition was. All in the name of pushing forward.

And I bought one of the first white iBooks (post toilet seat design) with the sole intention of using OSX (I'd used MacOS from 7 through 9, but departed briefly around that time). It was so slow it was literally completely unusable.

I do admit though, to this day there are things about OS Classic I really miss.

Re:Mac OS X Public Beta by jbrennan on Monday September 13, 2010 @04:33PM (#1688123)
I seem to recall the PPC -> Intel transition going rather smoothly, what with Rosetta instruction translation and Universal/Fat binaries. It took them about 9 months between shipping the first and final Intel Macs, and most apps were Universal within the first year (Photoshop and Office being the most notable, albeit gigantic, holdouts).
Re:Mac OS X Public Beta by chc on Monday September 13, 2010 @05:52PM (#1688475)
I would go so far as to say it was more painful for the last PPC buyers than it was for the first Intel buyers.
Re:Mac OS X Public Beta by mmphosis on Monday September 13, 2010 @07:26PM (#1688743)
I think it went a little more smoothly than the Motorola 680x0 -> PowerPC transition. Notice the ppc and i386 directories that were in Mac OS X from the get go.
Re:Mac OS X Public Beta by akl on Monday September 13, 2010 @04:43PM (#1688179)
Out of curiosity, what do you miss from MacOS Classic?
Re:Mac OS X Public Beta by mdasen on Monday September 13, 2010 @05:40PM (#1688439)
Let's see. . . cooperative multitasking! No, resource forks! Oh, better: the lack of a minimize!

Really, that's easy: Apple Platinum (see: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appearance_Manager). I know, it's heresy! Still, I like the elegant simplicity of Apple Platinum. The color is brighter than the Windows grey; I like the horizontal pin-striping in the title bar; I like the purple accents which give it a soft, classy feel (rather than a more contrast-y feel) and it feels easier on my eyes than, say, Windows; I like the simplicity of the controls (such as the simple two black horizontal lines for the "shade-up" function) combined with the soft gradient of the square control. I think it made great use of space as well. The title bar wasn't big as is the current trend (damn kids wasting my pixels).

I'm also just not the biggest fan of the transparent movement. I don't find that it increases my usability, but rather detracts from it by making things fuzzy. For example, the OS X menu (today) is mostly opaque - you can't read anything behind it. However, the little transparency makes it harder to read as there's fuzzy changes behind where you're trying to read. Windows Aero is the worst. Those transparent windows with the changing fuzzyness depending on how you move them - yikes! I also don't like that the menu is white. Contrast is good, but I prefer black on platinum to black on white for my eyes.

There's even a little part of me that misses pixel-based icons. Having a set canvas to work with meant that authors tried to pack good meaning into small space. Now, you're expected to waste lots of pixels. Yeah, I like my screen real-estate.

Now, nothing I've said is objective at all. It's just my aesthetic. OS X, as time has gone on, has gotten closer to my aesthetic. Some of the more garish things have left, but the horizontal pin-stripes have also left. I don't want to make this sound like I don't think OS X is nice to look at - it is. But there's a part of me that misses the simple look of OS 9 and BeOS (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:BeOS_Desktop.png) which had an elegance about them. Apple has done wonderful things with the OS X interface and I don't want to sound negative about OS X (plus, at least half of this is nostalgia talking). It's wonderful and so much better and I'm really happy with it.

Re:Mac OS X Public Beta by megrimlock on Monday September 13, 2010 @11:08PM (#1689273)
> not the biggest fan of the transparent movement

Completely agreed: the fact that OSX UI (and iTunes) change in arbitrarily small ways with each release seems like evidence that they are orbiting a local maximum rather than making absolute progress. But Linux distros and Windows are just as bad. And much more interesting advances are happening with multitouch on iOS, so I give Apple a pass.

At least there's a pref for the menu: System Preferences > Desktop > Translucent Menu Bar.

Re:Mac OS X Public Beta by mdg on Monday September 13, 2010 @05:54PM (#1688481)
> But there's a part of me that misses the simple look of OS 9 and BeOS

Have you given HaikuOS any time ?

Re:Mac OS X Public Beta by endlessvoid94 on Monday September 13, 2010 @04:43PM (#1688177)
What do you miss about OS Classic? I'm just curious.
Re:Mac OS X Public Beta by city41 on Monday September 13, 2010 @05:12PM (#1688347)
Apple just had a better respect for consistency back then IMO. iTunes 10 is a great example, now we have the minimize/expand/close buttons vertically down the side? Sure it looks cool, but consistency is much more important.

And just lots of other little things that added up. Like placing the close button on its own side of the window. So if you are clicking in that region, then you've only got one target so the app can more confidently know you really did mean to close the window. Now in OSX, maybe you meant minimize? Or how the trash can was always in the lower right corner, using the edges of the screen to its advantage. If you dragged an item that far down, then you only had one possible destination, the trash, so the OS confidently places the item in the trash without nagging you for a confirmation (like Windows does by default). No OSX doesn't nag you, but the trash can isn't taking advantage of the corner of the screen either.

Minor things, yes, but I still feel the Apple of old thought about these things more thoroughly.

Re:Mac OS X Public Beta by dsspence on Monday September 13, 2010 @10:38PM (#1689203)
Depends which consistency you mean. It wasn't consistent prior to 10 when you went to press the green button to get the mini-player and the orientation of the buttons changed from horizontal to vertical. If I'm remembering correctly.

I like your other points though.

Re:Mac OS X Public Beta by danilocampos on Monday September 13, 2010 @05:09PM (#1688330)
How about "my voice is my password?"

That wasn't bad.

Re:Mac OS X Public Beta by pillsy on Monday September 13, 2010 @04:29PM (#1688102)
They never really did FTFF, did they?