News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft responds to NYT story on suppressing dissent in... by pvg on Monday September 13, 2010 @04:21PM (#1688073)
I didn't understand the kneejerky misdirected anger at Microsoft when this was first reported nor do I really get the congratulatory backslapping of the NYT now. Microsoft did not send their goons to some downtrodden NGO's office, they didn't confiscate anyone's computers, nor did they even accuse this particular organization of piracy. Their Russian offices may have been less than sympathetic to the NGO's frantic attempts to get their property back, but realistically, there probably wasn't a great deal they could do. The report itself suggested the NGO was running licensed software and this fact was simply ignored by the authorities who just happened to be using license enforcement as a pretext to harass an organization they didn't like. They might have well claimed Baikal Wave were running improperly licensed Ubuntu, for all the difference it would have made.

Russia is simply not a society governed by the rule of law. No well-intentioned Microsoft initiative or poignant NYT report is likely to change that.

Re:Microsoft responds to NYT story on suppressing dissent in... by credo on Monday September 13, 2010 @05:55PM (#1688485)
From the original NYT report "Interviews and a review of law enforcement documents show that in recent cases, Microsoft lawyers made statements describing the company as a victim and arguing that criminal charges should be pursued." (note that Baikal Wave says it purchased and installed legal Microsoft software)

In another section 'In southwestern Russia, the Interior Ministry declared in an official document that its investigation of a human rights advocate for software piracy was begun "based on an application" from a lawyer for Microsoft.'

Microsoft corporate has ignored complaints about this for months (yesterday's NYT report has made them change their policy)

Why do you describe concerns as "kneejerky misdirected anger at Microsoft".

Do you consider Microsoft's actions as ethical (or not an obstruction of justice) ?

[edit: to answer pvg's follow-up, in this context, by "obstruction of justice" I'm referring to Microsoft helping prosecutors commit a crime or Microsoft interfering with "proper" operations of a court]

Re:Microsoft responds to NYT story on suppressing dissent in... by pvg on Monday September 13, 2010 @06:14PM (#1688547)
Do you consider Microsoft's actions as ethical

I honestly don't know. Operating in such an environment ethically convoluted. I just don't think those ethical complexities are particularly important or worthy of handwringing when the problem at hand is 'the man comes and forcibly and arbitrarily takes your property'.

or not an obstruction of justice

I am not sure what you mean by 'obstruction of justice' in this context.

Re:Microsoft responds to NYT story on suppressing dissent in... by dchest on Monday September 13, 2010 @04:28PM (#1688101)
I agree with you, however, the article pointed out that Microsoft's lawyers took part in court proceedings.
Re:Microsoft responds to NYT story on suppressing dissent in... by pvg on Monday September 13, 2010 @04:45PM (#1688190)
Not in the Baikal Wave case, specifically, although that doesn't really matter. Local lawyers representing Microsoft have, according to the report, participated in similar cases. I still think the 'Microsoft' part of this is largely irrelevant - it could have been anyone. In a corrupt country you can, unsurprisingly, find corrupt lawyers.
Re:Microsoft responds to NYT story on suppressing dissent in... by dchest on Monday September 13, 2010 @04:57PM (#1688263)
Again, I agree that it could have been anyone (I think Adobe took part in the recent raid of LG offices [or the authorities made them take part in this] -- http://www.google.com/hostednews/afp/article/ALeqM5gQtvHJ_pY...), but if it were Microsoft's lawyers, Microsoft is fully responsible for their actions.
Re:Microsoft responds to NYT story on suppressing dissent in... by pvg on Monday September 13, 2010 @05:33PM (#1688410)
Well, it gets a little tricky for the reasons you just described. If the 'authorities made' some company's representatives do something, it's not so perfectly clear the company is 'fully responsible' for their actions. It's a huge morass of ethical issues which automatically appears when a company does business in such places. The extremes of the spectrum are not doing business there at all and full-on collusion. Microsoft and I imagine just about all US technology companies in Russia likely fall somewhere in the middle. My point is that the debate about where precisely is not really all that interesting or important.
Re:Microsoft responds to NYT story on suppressing dissent in... by VladRussian on Monday September 13, 2010 @05:38PM (#1688428)
'Microsoft' or 'Adobe' part isn't that irrelevant - they've successfully lobbied the Russian authorities for the system of enforcement through unscheduled police "inspection" raids without probable cause. One can't be deemed innocent when he knowingly engages in collaboration with devil to obtain benefits of its powers.
Re:Microsoft responds to NYT story on suppressing dissent in... by alecco on Monday September 13, 2010 @05:10PM (#1688336)
Microsoft funds vigilante legal groups worldwide with a few partners. They've been doing this for at least a decade in my country. And this kind of unethical abuse is very common.

Note this PR release only says

> The policy is intended to last until 2012 but could be extended, he said.

I'm still highly skeptical of MS with these regards. And their statements sound very vague.

Re:Microsoft responds to NYT story on suppressing dissent in... by pvg on Monday September 13, 2010 @05:23PM (#1688381)
Microsoft funds vigilante legal groups worldwide with a few partners.

This may be the case but it just isn't the issue at hand. Microsoft had nothing to do with the local authorities' decision to harass and intimidate Baikal Wave. Just go back to the NYT article and copy it somewhere and replace 'Microsoft' with 'Smapti'. After re-reading it, what do you think the fundamental problem is -

a) Smapti, Inc is an imperfect global citizen

b) Russian authorities suppress legitimate political dissent

Re:Microsoft responds to NYT story on suppressing dissent in... by dchest on Monday September 13, 2010 @05:35PM (#1688419)
Russian authorities suppress legitimate political dissent by [ab]using the laws lobbied by Microsoft and the like, using the militia department created specifically to solve their problems. It's not like the authorities couldn't use other methods, but it doesn't mean that these "copyright holders" and their anti-piracy partnerships (BSA, НП ППП) didn't take part in creating this problem.
Re:Microsoft responds to NYT story on suppressing dissent in... by dchest on Monday September 13, 2010 @06:13PM (#1688540)
For skeptics, or those who's looking for more information, I'm talking about Civil Code of Russia, Part IV, in effect since January 1, 2008.

A lot of people talked about how it could be abused, and it seems, they were right.

BTW, while looking for information in English on this, I found this gem from http://www.ustr.gov/:

Poor enforcement of IPR [Intellectual Property Law] in the Russian Federation is a pervasive problem. In the November 2006 IPR Bilateral Agreement, Russia agreed to improve IPR enforcement while the United States agreed to step up IPR training programs and technical assistance for Russian customs and law enforcement officials. In 2009, the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office conducted six IPR training programs for Russian police, investigators, prosecutors, judges, and customs officials and in total trained 149 Russian law enforcement officials. Russian Customs has drafted an “IPR Enforcement Handbook”, which will be used by all Russian Federal Customs Service officers. Additional training programs are planned for 2010.

http://www.ustr.gov/sites/default/files/uploads/reports/2010... [PDF]

Good job!

Re:Microsoft responds to NYT story on suppressing dissent in... by zackattack on Tuesday September 14, 2010 @12:16AM (#1689415)
>Russia is simply not a society governed by the rule of law. No well-intentioned Microsoft initiative or poignant NYT report is likely to change that.

Reminds me of http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=84MsRuC-1l8 ... does anyone else have any other interesting anecdotes, stories or links about "anarchy"/nepotism/realpolitik in international business?