News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Dow of Cities by StudentStuff on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @03:56PM (#16870577)
Requiring garden space and car storage for every bedroom built is a quick way to double a project's costs. Why have zoning codes that prohibit the best use of the land?
Re:The Dow of Cities by losteric on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @04:12PM (#16870730)
Zoning codes are a double-edged sword. On one hand, they stop someone from building a high-rise in the middle of a low-density residential area... on the other hand, the very same regulations prevent the market from scaling up to meet new demand. New zoning legislation moves slowly when constituents benefit from rising real-estate prices (to the detriment of the broader public).

Legislation like "new construction must not be more than N floor(s) higher than surrounding properties" might help, rather than the simple fixed height limit many areas set.

Re:The Dow of Cities by xvedejas on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @04:56PM (#16871109)
Building high-rises (well, 8+ stories) in the middle of low-density residential areas is something that happens in Japan, and I find it charming. Why are we enforcing the aesthetic wishes of some people but not others?
Re:The Dow of Cities by twelvechairs on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @05:44PM (#16871495)
High-rise should be close to shops, services and transport. In some currently low-density places these might be there (particularly in Japan), but in many they aren't.

'Heritage' is a different issue - most western countries are far too conservative here

Re:The Dow of Cities by konschubert on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @05:02PM (#16871162)
Because there are ugly cities and there are beautiful cities. And they are so for a reason.

This video is really informative in this regard and has changed my opinion on a few things:

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Hy4QjmKzF1c

Re:The Dow of Cities by rukittenme on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @08:34PM (#16872476)
Society would be much better off in ugly cities rather than expensive ones.
Re:The Dow of Cities by L_Rahman on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @05:34PM (#16871430)
the problem is that zoning is a bad hack to solve the problem of how a neighborhood feels.

we know that we don't want it get too big or loud - no 50 story office building, or vape shops and bars on every corner - so we write blanket rules restricting certain kinds of construction and grant power to the people already living there for changes to the code itself and approval over all buildings matching the existing code

this puts all the power in two types of people - those entrenched in this process with political and financial power, and existing homeowners. Both of these groups then use their power to preserve what they already have and impose their ideal of a neighborhood over everyone else

and because we live in America not only do the people in power act knowingly in the interest of preserving their wealth and power but also incorporate their biases - especially against members of a class or race - into exclusio

this is so fundamentally broken and yet as a fundamental construct American cities lack any mechanism for questioning the concentration of power in homeowners and it is crazy.

in a transit starved stretch of Brooklyn, homeowners blocked a bus lane from going up just because they wouldn't let go of a hundred parking spots during weekday business hours. entire communities suffer because people who own homes and cars refuse to compromise

Re:The Dow of Cities by aidenn0 on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @07:31PM (#16872181)
I find high-rise buildings to be a straw-man. You can get amazing density with 3-story apartment buildings, but those are rare in a lot of expensive markets.
Re:The Dow of Cities by clairity on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @09:04PM (#16872591)
cities should allow up to 6-story buildings in residential areas, because that's the reasonable max height of a wood frame building (it used to be 4 stories, but i hear construction practices have improved to allow up to 6).

wood frame is cheaper to build than either concrete or steel, which are the other predominant building materials (which allow much taller builds).

http://missingmiddlehousing.com/

Re:The Dow of Cities by StudentStuff on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @04:29PM (#16870883)
If a proposed high rise is near a BRT line or rail, a reasonable zoning code shouldn't mangle it or block its construction.
Re:The Dow of Cities by rosser on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @04:52PM (#16871068)
...and we're already pretty far down the rabbit hole of how zoning gets so complex.

There are always exceptions. There are always circumstances. There are always NIMBYs. AFAICT, you cannot regulate how land is used — which isn't necessarily a bad thing — without bumping into those things, which seems invariably to compromise, or at least complicate, the effort.

I would still very much prefer zoning over someone who can afford to do so deciding, simply on that basis, that he's going to build, say, a tannery up-wind of my home.

Imposing your externalities upon others is, IMO, a bright-line breach of the NAP. (Since it's so often Libertarian-leaning folk who are all, "But zoning!")

EDIT: phrasing

Re:The Dow of Cities by rayiner on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @10:18PM (#16872863)
Getting rid of zoning doesn't mean getting rid of nuisance law. If someone builds a tannery upwind from your propeety, you can sue him formcausing a nuisance. And he can either pay you, stop, or buy you out depending on what is economically efficient.

The peoblem with zoning is that it allows you to stop lots of things that would not qualify as a nuisance. And it prevents lots of things that would be an economic win (buildimg a high rise in a previous low rise neighborhood if property owners were willing to sell out).

Re:The Dow of Cities by rayiner on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @10:14PM (#16872845)
What's wrong with building a high rise on land you own?
Re:The Dow of Cities by rayiner on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @09:53PM (#16872758)
Because state and local governments hate America.