News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why does software cost so much? by ryandrake on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @12:39PM (#16868773)
With a drink, I'm getting a physical, tangible thing that I know individually took some amount of effort to make. I can watch it being mixed and poured and my reptile brain acknowledges that I'm paying for the raw materials and this bartender's effort (that's on display in front of me). Once I buy the drink it's mine. I can drink it, pour it on my head, give it to someone else, flush it down the toilet, whatever I want. I can take it home and put it under a microscope, maybe verify what it's made of. I can move it into a different container if I want and drink it from there. Due to laws, I have some level of confidence that it will not kill me or make me sick, and that it is fit for the purpose under which it was marketed.

With most software, I'm getting a copy that was made at $0 cost. Someone wrote a script long ago that could make an infinite number of copies of it, and the bits I have on my hard drive are from those copies. Sure, the very first copy took huge cost and effort, but my brain always needs to convince myself of this. Also, I'm not buying the software--really I have nothing after I hand my money over. Just some temporary license to use the software only in ways the manufacturer allows. I can lose this right at any time based on terms in some 100 page legal document that I didn't read but I know is written in favor of the manufacturer. I cannot do anything I want with the software. I can't learn how it works or modify it. I (often) am not allowed to move the software into a different computer and use it there. I have no guarantees that the software will work at all. The software is usually not warranted in any way, nor claimed to be fit for any purpose, and the manufacturer disclaims every possible liability for anything that happens as a result of using the software, again, in its 100 pages of legal documents.

I'm surprised it's normal to pay anything at all for software.

Re:Why does software cost so much? by borplk on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @01:03PM (#16868975)
That's just a lot of hand waving.

People throw $5 in the busker's hat as they are casually walking by without a second thought.

Yet they have a hard time paying for a $2 android game that keeps them entertained for many hours.

Of course it's their money and they have the right to decide how to use it but it's also just plain odd and unfair to suddenly treat $2 as if it was $200 when it comes to software.

Re:Why does software cost so much? by dredmorbius on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @01:21PM (#16869124)
And most people hear or see the busker's act and don't pay.

For those who do, the value is immediately cognisible, and, given a cash drop, the transaction is entirely transactional and self-contained.

For software, value isn't apparent, the transaction (especially with any ongoing service or billing) is not contained, there is a vastly larger scope of unforseen or unanticipated consequences (both positive and negative, though the latter tend to dominate psychology and behaviour), and more.

Though topically similar, the experiences really are not comparable.

Re:Why does software cost so much? by borplk on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @01:27PM (#16869169)
> For software, value _isn't_ apparrent, the transaction (especially with any ongoing service or billing) is not contained, there is a vastly larger scope of unforseen or unanticipated consequences (both positive and negative, though the latter tend to dominate psychology and behaviour), and more.

Again, we're talking about $1 and $2 here not $200 or $2000.

My point is the hypocrisy (if we can call it that) of spending that amount or more so easily and mindlessly with so little expectations and suddenly treating it as if it was $200 when it comes to software such that anything less than perfect means the software creator is not worthy of your precious $2 that you often throw at a beggar without a second thought.

Re:Why does software cost so much? by dredmorbius on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @01:55PM (#16869424)
There are tons of really shitty $1 & $2 apps.

My assessment costs for those are literally orders of magnitude higher than the price, and yet the price / access barrier, continuity and support risks, etc., literally get in the way of assessing true value.

Non-software, or at least bundled-software, example: the local organisation is exploring phone and comms options. Extant system is obsolete and failing. The market price of any given alternative is small, but the cost of sussing out features, suitability, comms link provider integration, and how that might change (POTS, VOIP, wireless, non-dedicated hardware, integrated messaging solutions via smartphone/tablet) opens a whole can of worms.

Meanwhile, staff in another department who aren't communicating or comprehending effectively have just purchased a system that manifestly doesn't consider any of this or even meet present needs.

Trying to impart on them even the basics of "POTS possibly won't exist in a year or few" has proved a challenge, let alone other organisational comms needs or wants.

Acquisition price of the system itself is actually, within a factor of 2-10, a minor concern, quite probably captured in ongoing service fees (or their elimination) in a matter of months.

Features offerred by various vendors, their communication of same, guessing future developments, configuration & integration, etc., are vastly more significant.

Price alone communicates effectively none of that. Markets are useful for commodity goods, far less so for complex and highly differentiated ones.

Re:Why does software cost so much? by watwut on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @01:17PM (#16869093)
1.) The majority of those games won't keep them entertained for hours. Most of them you look at and never open again.

2.) Most of those games simply make waiting for bus or someone bit more fun, but most people are fine actually staring at wall during that time.

3.) This is mostly equivalent of not impulsovely buying anything else - candy every time you are an hour to diner and bit hungry, shiny enclave when you see it etc.