News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: Rejected from Y Combinator? Don't be upset or quit by BIackSwan on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @10:58AM (#16867888)
Would love to see the anti portfolio list of YC.[1]

FWIW - We have been rejected 3 times from YC over the last 3 years. We did not take it personally as OP said, put our heads down and got working on our startup.

After lot of hard work, setbacks and near death experiences, we are now currently growing ~10% MoM and generating millions in ARR. YC or any other investor/accelerator should never be the make or break thing for a startup - it should be your own judgement call on whether you want to continue or not based on market feedback.

[1] - https://www.bvp.com/portfolio/anti-portfolio

Re:Tell HN: Rejected from Y Combinator? Don't be upset or quit by dahart on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @01:33PM (#16869224)
> Would love to see the anti portfolio list of YC.

That would be interesting! I'd also love to see the list of both rejected and accepted applications that failed. BVP's "anti-portfolio" is a list of massive successes they happened to pass on. It wouldn't be as fun to look at the list of actual failures they passed on, or the failures they funded, but that might be even more instructive, right?

> YC or any other investor/accelerator should never be the make or break thing for a startup - it should be your own judgement call on whether you want to continue or not based on market feedback.

Absolutely!

Personally, early on, I made the mistake of thinking that an investor rejection somehow reflected on the viability of my ideas or my business, that they knew something I didn't.

Growing past that and realizing that investors mostly don't care about the ideas, nor do they usually even know what's viable before the market responds, was important.

It also helped me to realize that looking for money just to survive was bad for me, looking for money to accelerate before I was moving at all was bad for me, and most investors are not the right partners for me, no matter how much money they have.

*Edit: BTW, I did once apply and was rejected from YC. With hindsight, I know their call was correct. Not because YC isn't the right partner for me, but because I wasn't ready.

Re:Tell HN: Rejected from Y Combinator? Don't be upset or quit by dtawfik1 on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @02:49PM (#16869918)
>Personally, early on, I made the mistake of thinking that an investor rejection somehow reflected on the viability of my ideas or my business, that they knew something I didn't.

Spot on. An idea stage company is a theory. Validation occurs through real users. To become despondent because an investor didn't believe in your theory is not allowing yourself to really test the viability of your project. If users don't buy into your idea then you have a problem, but you have to play the experiment out.

Re:Tell HN: Rejected from Y Combinator? Don't be upset or quit by Mononokay on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @11:08AM (#16867964)
BVP's anti-portfolio is absolutely beautiful. It's so difficult to tell a success from a failure.

Sequoia, on the other hand . . .

Re:Tell HN: Rejected from Y Combinator? Don't be upset or quit by josephjrobison on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @11:32AM (#16868167)
Man, BVP’s anti-portfolio is much more impressive than their portfolio. Shows how hard it is to pick a winner early on.
Re:Tell HN: Rejected from Y Combinator? Don't be upset or quit by vthallam on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @11:56AM (#16868376)
Can't believe Jeremey Levine passed on the dream investments time and again.
Re:Tell HN: Rejected from Y Combinator? Don't be upset or quit by cbcoutinho on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @11:32AM (#16868174)
What do you mean? Those companies were all successes
Re:Tell HN: Rejected from Y Combinator? Don't be upset or quit by imarg on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @11:42AM (#16868262)
That's the point.

An anti-portfolio is the companies they rejected but went on to be successful.

Re:Tell HN: Rejected from Y Combinator? Don't be upset or quit by Mononokay on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @11:35AM (#16868201)
Exactly! They failed to see the value in any of them.
Re:Tell HN: Rejected from Y Combinator? Don't be upset or quit by m-p-3 on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @06:31PM (#16871840)
To be fair it's almost like gambling.
Re:Tell HN: Rejected from Y Combinator? Don't be upset or quit by l1n on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @01:41PM (#16869287)
Interesting that Tesla is on that list: I think it's yet to be sen if they can make it through their current crises.
Re:Tell HN: Rejected from Y Combinator? Don't be upset or quit by SamReidHughes on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @02:24PM (#16869686)
They IPO'd.
Re:Tell HN: Rejected from Y Combinator? Don't be upset or quit by loceng on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @11:03AM (#16867914)
Going through the exercise alone, regularly - say twice per year - is extremely valuable, without needing to actually submit or save the answers in the application form they provide. The questions are nicely structured and hit on important points.
Re:Tell HN: Rejected from Y Combinator? Don't be upset or quit by spinlock on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @01:07PM (#16869005)
I hate ycombinator comments like this. Now I need to go procrastinate by writing a tool where I can go through the YC application every quarter.
Re:Tell HN: Rejected from Y Combinator? Don't be upset or quit by loceng on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @07:18PM (#16872116)
Every quarter is a perhaps a bit excessive unless things are changing quickly. If you use a calendar, it takes a few minutes to just add a reminder at certain dates. Or I always just get reminded when I see YC posting about it.
Re:Tell HN: Rejected from Y Combinator? Don't be upset or quit by speby on Wednesday April 18, 2018 @07:13PM (#16872086)
Well said because the inverse is true as well. So many of the startups YC has funded either died a relatively short death, stagnated towards a long-death or eventually were acqui-hired in some shape or form. Just because you got into YC simply does not mean that the business you're starting is somehow more or less likely to succeed than one that didn't. At best, you might be able to increase your chances of success but that in no way happens without you pressing your foot on on the gas so hard it almost breaks.